Tuesday, February 23, 2016

"Nonwhite" WCG Congregations in South Africa (1976)

HWA's WCG used to have racially segregated congregations in Apartheid South Africa.
PRETORIA, South Africa - About 45 members from the Johannesburg and Pretoria nonwhite churches met Feb. 1 at Pretoria Zoo for a picnic. A record player, provided by the family of a member, played music during meals. Also present was Sydney J. Hull, a local elder from Pretoria. (Worldwide News, March 15, 1976, pp. 13-14.)
And just imagine. WCG tended to be quite supportive of the Apartheid regime. PCG has tended to be sympathetic towards the Apartheid regime.

Sydney Hull would later join LCG. At one time he was the leader of LCG in South Africa. Then he switched allegiance to RCG before going back to LCG but he was only allowed to return as a laymember. He passed away on March 13, 2011.

Monday, February 22, 2016

Interview with Authors of Burning Country




Middle East Monitor has published an interview with Robin Yassin-Kassab and Leila Al-Shami, authors of the recently released book, Burning Country: Syrians in Revolution and War.


Saudi Arabia to Send SAMs to Rebels in Syria

In the latest development Middle East Monitor reports that Saudi Arabia announced they will be sending SAMs to rebels in Syria.

Alas there is no sign that this most terrible war will end anytime soon. It is to be hoped that that may soon change.

Links (February 22, 2016)

The COGs offer a way of viewing the world with the assurance that members are "in the know" about what is really going on. Events and stories are presented to COG members in such a way as to prop up the dogmas taught by the COG groups.

Here are some news articles that contradict various aspects of what is taught within many of the COGs.

***

(Warning: Contains graphic content:) Mondoweiss discusses the shooting to death of Mohammad Khalaf at the Damascus Gate in Jerusalem. It is mentioned that Israeli personnel continued shooting after he was no longer a threat to them.

Mondoweiss reports how some in Saudi Arabia initiated a Twitter campaign entitled "#WeWillRespectHomosexualRights."

Alternet reports that an Israeli-American scholar at George Washington University proposed flattening Beirut (a city of many men, women and children) to get Hezbollah in an article published in Haaretz.

Recently one Likud MK absurdly said that since there is no P in Arabic therefore there is no Palestinian people. Haaretz reported on this (February 10, 2016).

So often the COGs complain that men are no longer properly respected, are being feminized, and feminism is often condemned. Here is a sobering article from The Guardian noting the corrosive effect of sexism upon the English language. (January 27, 2016.)

Arutz Sheva During 2014 War in Gaza

In July and August 2014 a most severe war raged in Gaza. By the time it was over 2251 Palestinians, 66 Israeli soldiers and 6 Israeli civilians had been killed.

Arutz Sheva is a far right media outlet based in Israel that caters for national religious Israeli Jews. It is closely associated with the settlers. Its headquarters are in Beit El, an Israeli settlement in the West Bank regarded as illegal according to international law because it is built on land acquired by the State of Israel because of the Six Day War of 1967.

Arutz Sheva is often quoted by PCG and to a somewhat lesser extent by UCG, LCG and RCG. It is never criticized by the COGs. The COGs trust Arutz Sheva. They have never bothered explaining to their readers the political stance Arutz Sheva tends to take.

According to Israel Shahak and Norton Mezvinsky's book, Jewish Fundamentalism in Israel (1997, 2004), Arutz Sheva refused to broadcast women singing on their radio station for religious reasons.

Below are the tweets from the opinion account on Twitter for Arutz Sheva (@Arutz7_Opinion) that were posted during the deadly war.

(Linking does not imply endorsement.)

***

July 8
Hamas Violence: The Bigotry of Low Expectations: This absence of Western moral judgment of the Arab world, in... http://t.co/H7BCipc3eM

When They Ask for a Ceasefire - Not so Fast: Israel's passive policies of measured responses, supplemented by ... http://t.co/7vy0Djz2kU

How to Answer a Three-Fingered Salute: Since the establishment of a Palestinian Unity Government that includes... http://t.co/jxyK4AFImk

July 9

The Only Solution is a Return to Gaza: It may be difficult, but retaking Gush Katif may be the only way to sto... http://t.co/UkEiTHl13Y

Israel and the Palestinians: Who is Stronger?: Although terror and rockets cannot destroy the state of Israel,... http://t.co/eiJ1D3NFef

Post-Oslo Terror Planning: Records from Jerusalem's Orient House prove that the PLO began violating the Oslo A... http://t.co/TfcmzWHBeF

Why This Operation is Different: http://t.co/5kGjqCz5qF

July 10

Land Invasion: Beware the Trap Laid by Hamas: There are more effective choices. http://t.co/2VlqeneHbq

Gaza: Blame The Left For This War: The crux of the war taking place at this moment. http://t.co/qsmjAAYKsA

Jewish "Victim Mentality": The core of the problem. http://t.co/iSxla6LCsD

July 11

They Still Believe It's All Israel's Fault: The world is misled and prefers it that way. http://t.co/QnWKaHPEho

July 15

The World Gloats at the Thought of Jewish Assassins: The West would love to see Israel act as the rest of the ... http://t.co/lIjoFKwUJT

Stop American Jewish Extremists: This is a war between good and evil, light and darkness. Every decent Jewish ... http://t.co/VUQ4A3qQ1r

Fighting Terror With Our Hands Tied Behind Our Backs: There are Israeli legal professionals who seem to fear t... http://t.co/xqd1551l0k

When a Ceasefire is not a Ceasefire: Advice to jounalists: The three Arabic nuanced terms being discussed with... http://t.co/Ji3KeWwIi9

Why a Ground Invasion Is Imperative: The writer explains the reasons there cannot be victory without a ground ... http://t.co/vKOHFs936S

My Outline for a Solution in Gaza: Clear and concise, the steps towards achieving quiet in Gaza. http://t.co/2bk3mjqwAr

July 16

Lessons from the Gaza War, III: Abbas Sides with Hamas: It's time to put Fatah back on the U.S. list of terror... http://t.co/vu6aIzk52G

July 17

A Gaza Ceasefire Now Would Be a Strategic Miss: If Israel holds out longer, its intelligence would improve, Ha... http://t.co/gnBJ0bzl0F

Europe is Just Fine with the Killing of 626 Jews: The EU supports PLO-Hamas unity. How many murdered Jews does... http://t.co/6P8QcurKtT

This Time, Re-possess the Philadelphi Corridor: It is under this corridor that Hamas and other Palestinian ter... http://t.co/ZOxs6Mz74b

Firing Deputy Minister Danon is Killing the Messenger: Firing Danon is perceived as weakness. http://t.co/eokyvVPFr4

Want Proportionality? Give Israel 22 Countries: Spare us the pieties and righteous indignation of Europe. The ... http://t.co/CISNnUgfPM

Gaza, A Tragedy of Errors: Many of us simply do not understand how Hamas works. http://t.co/E9J3qYpe9b

July 18

Israel Must Abandon the Obscene "Purity of Arms" Mantra: This military morality, which Jews call "purity of ar... http://t.co/6YK0vFWAs3

Invasion - the American Way: America would invade and take down the government. http://t.co/ftDVchpxzk

July 19

From the Israeli Press: Prophets of Israel: Something has changed in Israel. The 2005 prophecies have turned o... http://t.co/XlURZ1T5x1

July 20

Gaza - What Next?: Will there be a reversal of the "disengagement" disaster? http://t.co/ly7KORttRu

Israel Holds the Free World's Destiny in Her Hands: These stubborn Israeli Jews are alone - alone in resisting... http://t.co/ygO6tHbONx

July 21

Geraldo, Get Real: Geraldo Rivera thinks Israel has lost its moral authority. How sad. http://t.co/MvpJzQKQgx

The Europeans in Gaza who fight with Hamas: These are not good men, who endanger themselves to help those in n... http://t.co/mPtMtUUPpy

No to Negotiating With Hamas: De facto recognition of Hamas is a terrible mistake. http://t.co/aLstSCkzIE

Believe Nothing From The BBC: Forget news. You are getting stories. http://t.co/gAzJpWH9Bp

Those Gazans, What's Their Story?: Where are the Gazans who want to live a quet life? http://t.co/xWGLAwi6qN

July 22

Kerry to the Rescue: He is rescuing the wrong side. http://t.co/9ZoXz0spJy

The Sensitivity of a Radio Presenter: A UK rabbi weighs in on disproportion. http://t.co/c9vcQyorU0

Unicef Declares War on Israeli Children: Are Palestinian Arab children more “innocent” than Jewish ones? http://t.co/bG1mbIVoHD

July 23

Hamas Tunnels: Analysis and Initial Implications: The attack tunnels create a new equation in the power balanc... http://t.co/2ZsiF12lgR

Finally Obama Leads from the Front: The Hamas-FAA Move: The message is prejudicial and the timing is suspiciou... http://t.co/OCUPBWDRSA

July 24

FAA Ban - Politically Motivated?: Supporting Israel, our ally and friend, in the Mid-East significantly streng... http://t.co/EeCOVyol7N

J'Accuse: Western Academics Who Condemn Israel: J'accuse: every single Western academic, each intellectual and... http://t.co/igFGkjTA73

July 25

Mega-siege attack thwarted, US still pushes ceasefire: Hamas intended to send a swarm of 1000’s of terrorists ... http://t.co/5VZbMGdY5J

View From Inside the Halls of Power: Israel's Strategy: Analysis backed by in depth interview with a leading e... http://t.co/m3JNp1Y9R8

US Weapons Resupply - Also to be Grounded?: In the coming days, Israel will likely need a massive re-supply of... http://t.co/4YXOebQh0r

The Hate-Wave All Over the Islamicized West: Welcome to the Middle Ages. http://t.co/RjQ0vA10YY

July 26

No, Supporting Hamas is Not 'Feminist': Only the IDF is considered "hyper-masculine" - not Hamas, Boko Haram a... http://t.co/vXDcDEND7L

Abbas Slaps US Again: From day one of the Gaza war, Abbas's Fatah movement has openly sided with Hamas. http://t.co/QckRVPBVRL

Academic Lies in the Cognitive War Against Israel: The entire so-called “occupation” has also become a target ... http://t.co/7WjCaNymrz

Israel, Stop Placating the World’s Opinion: For the world, no matter what Israel does, it is in the wrong. http://t.co/vH2heTOipy

July 28

Curb The Nitpicking: It is not the time to fight among ourselves. http://t.co/lj2svX7Syv

The Real Reason: They want to erase all evidence of those Jews who carried that sacred ark into Jerusalem fill... http://t.co/j7qI3aV3BE

Christians United for Israel Make Themselves Heard: Support when it is needed most and connecting with the "mi... http://t.co/5egwOANV8i

The Anti-Israel Bias of the New York Times: Interview with Ricki Hollander and Gilead Ini of CAMERA. http://t.co/jtk57NWqOE

July 29

IDF, Don’t Take Your Foot Off the Gas Pedal: We must deliver a knockout to Hamas. http://t.co/4PKWEQmuUk

The Outburst of Dutch Anti-Semitism and Anti-Israelism: A close up of one country in an increasingly ugly Europe. http://t.co/gU7HNNNOcy

Broadcast Media Hostility Towards Israel: The confrontational and hostile interviews with Israeli representati... http://t.co/gJXz2Yqeyx

No Economic Aid to Hamas-Ruled Gaza: The world should not be rewarding the most extreme Palestinians for viole... http://t.co/BFjRzmG5wn

July 31

Obama's Walter Cronkite Moment: Obama's policies, Israel's actions and Middle America. http://t.co/KRWjbGcuZX

Why Hamas is Still Holding Out: There are six differences between Israel and Hamas that have a role to play in... http://t.co/y3hdQ7dAg2

Gaza’s Present is 'West Bank' Prologue: A terrorist from the "West Bank" with a small and light-weight 122mm r... http://t.co/UGxF5eQyH2

Putting Israel's Self-Defense in Context: Israel's operations against Hamas are perfectly legal. http://t.co/Pi6vzwqVL0

August 1

Humanitarian Ceasefire: Hamas Cries Uncle: Israel has to decide whether it wants "quiet" or surrender. http://t.co/oHQzIUCJpP

August 1, 2014: The Centennial of World War One: It began on the 9th of Av. It was a war of unprecedented horr... http://t.co/fuo1boOz0o

Israel Should End Hamas Rule in Gaza: As the 72 hour ceasefire is declared, read why Israel must continue. http://t.co/7g5YjBET3U

Lieut. Hadar Goldin Abducted This Morning in Gaza.: How very different we are from them. http://t.co/hueBg32XJr

August 2

Hamas Terror: Beyond Operation Protective Edge: Hamas terror and Islamist sacrifce demand different and more p... http://t.co/9fouci21XD

August 3

Behind the Scenes: Muslim Anti-Semitism in Holland: Interview with a Muslim young woman who monitors Jew-hatre... http://t.co/8Rf355cua3

August 4

NY Times Supports Demilitarization, But Not in Gaza: Demilitarize everything everywhere, just not when it come... http://t.co/lzEpZ9eG8X

Israel Needs A Ceasefire From the United Nations: Get the UN off Israel's back. http://t.co/QVUQCdryZo

Is Israel Going to Let Hamas Win?: Is Israel afraid to win? http://t.co/IiwiOB3vmp

Crying "Ceasefire" in a Crowded Military Theater: Most Israelis do not know John Kerry as well as we Americans... http://t.co/wGUJoYz5oY

Bill Clinton's Mistake Haunts Israel in Gaza: The designer of the Qassam rocket was once within reach. http://t.co/7OV3fdNwSD

August 5

How I Learned To Hate The Iron Dome: The Iron Dome has become the answer for everything. http://t.co/on4M0lBgGr

August 6

There Will be Blood: Islam presently has its stranglehold over on a billion humans and the rest of humanity ig... http://t.co/382bdPbdY4

Anti-Semitism Rages, Jewish Values Attacked from Within: The misapplication of tikkun olam. http://t.co/bTP6ZFlK5f

The Media are a Bunch of Anti-Israel Hypocrites: A media pogrom. http://t.co/4bZj5LWJbL

August 8

What is Going to Become of Gaza?: Pipe-dreams that have no connection with reality are not going to come true. http://t.co/iamgKD0I7j

Top Israel PR Spokespersons during Protective Edge: The people who explain Israel's position best are given th... http://t.co/CcSnvV9oEB

One Big Step Backward for Mankind: Israel's right to self defense is supported, as long as Israel doesn't act on it. http://t.co/IlRffWAK5s

Dutch Jews Wonder About Their Future: It is quite clear where the rampant anti-Semitism comes from, but not to... http://t.co/GckSmMwo1O

August 10

Obama in NY Times Interview: Pro Zoabi, Anti-Netanyahu: Is Obama totally off the mark or has he consciously ch... http://t.co/q5zJ98Rgsw

Who is Israel's Most Powerful Enemy? The West: This is what happens in the West when Israel decides that thous... http://t.co/GlSCpcFRRS

August 11

"The French Intifada", Coming Soon to Your Area: Written before the recent anti-Semitic demonstrations in Fran... http://t.co/dP6HBSlJTf

When We Said Never Again, We Meant It: What would appease the world's moral barometer? http://t.co/aWnLhQzsJe

August 12

From Israel's Press: Conversations with a Blasé Israel: A popular weekly column addresses the attitude of Isra... http://t.co/7zacRqvhTI

A Pro-Jewish Ad and the Mess it Caused: Distancing the Netherlands from anti-Semitism should not entail its Je... http://t.co/73nToidSdh

August 14

10 Palestinian Authority Sites Gov. Cuomo Should Visit: A suggested itinerary for New York's intrepid governor... http://t.co/eYBHc7JnnM

Has Qatar Surrendered?: A Lebanon-based Arabic media network report seems to point that way. http://t.co/D01Qiwd2v4

A Novel of Ideas in the Era of Anti-Israelism: "Field of Exile" is a brave and moving book of love, betrayal a... http://t.co/l2UnzPP8ui

August 16

Why Israel is the World’s Best Nation: With all the accusations hurled at us, it is good to see a "righteous G... http://t.co/1Izj4pJegj

August 17

Empire of Influence or Conspiracy of Power?: Are Jews looking to control the world? http://t.co/AYNjwojxiB

An Open Letter to the Jew-haters: Jew-haters confirm Goebbel's observation: When you tell a lie a thousand tim... http://t.co/fCylsERNEc

Broken Britain: Everyone shares the belief that Britain is on the verge of some kind of 1930s-style nightmare. http://t.co/bMfpUhVxYn

Schabas’ UN Gaza Probe – Theater of the Absurd: When sarcasm is mixed with fury, there is nothing like Yiddish... http://t.co/sgl1m75klK

August 20

What is UNRWA Doing in Gaza?: How does it make sense? And American taxpayers would go through the roof and und... http://t.co/QLhSRVIbrd

August 22

Confusing Complacency with Resiliency: http://t.co/9nCtZeCKfY

Riots in Ferguson, USA -- A Quiet Murder in Miami: American justice 2014. http://t.co/fxRgugbuAv

"Follow Me": The age-old call of Jewish leaders is sounded once again. http://t.co/wFQKcyzYc6

August 23

Israeli Arabs in Search of Identity: The Balad Party – inherently – cannot identify with the Jewish State, des... http://t.co/IeJwJAfEXC

Why Peace Failed: Written for Arutz Sheva: Still hidden examples of Palestinian non-compliance. http://t.co/xnlfnRCfof

August 24

To the Educated West, Israeli Children are Guilty: They are also expendable. http://t.co/vnR7Nsl9Su

August 25

Is it Hot in Here or Am I Crazy?: The world today has the writer wondering... http://t.co/XNn4gf6f0Q

Our Most Dangerous Enemy: Hamas is an overt danger. So are Islamic Jihad and other terrorist organizations. Th... http://t.co/VkThIPOBL7

Suspicious Behavior: It's getting harder to know when to be alarmed. Some of us think there is no reason to be. http://t.co/gLEtXgsj8Y

August 26

"Holocaust Victims" Challenge Elie Wiesel: His "crime"? Defending Israel. http://t.co/LwwueFTl9u

The Latest at Temple U.- an Anti-Semitic Hotspot: Jews who fund Temple University should make their voices heard. http://t.co/0osNBViNeZ

Playing with Terror: How to Stop Qatar's Funding Hamas: Through its money and mediating of conflicts, Qatar se... http://t.co/QtXBlu6NUG

Survivors for Hamas – Really?: I do not know who they are, these people. They are not my people. http://t.co/L9ZShaCAzG

Ceasefire? 18 Rules for Fighting a Gaza War Chelm-Style: http://t.co/A7jCvdV2Ja

[The ceasefire came into force on August 26, 2014.]

August 27

The EU, US Gave Hamas the Reason to Fight to the Death: Ceasefire? Israel is still helpless to stop Hamas from... http://t.co/qGu3unwZ8c

Bibi Lost the Battle - But Israel can Win the War: Despite Hamas losing the military battle, the Israeli gover... http://t.co/bcHwW3vrvM

August 28

Can Israel See A Stronger Right-Wing Leadership?: Possible results of the Gaza war. http://t.co/A4kQxUNGBJ

***

Currently the blockade is still in force against Gaza even though it has failed to overthrow Hamas after all these years. The blockade clearly is not working in that purpose. But so many in Gaza continue to suffer because of the blockade.

Since the blockade has failed in its original purpose and yet it is still enforced resulting in much pain and suffering why maintain it? The blockade needs to go.

Only a political solution can end this terrible conflict that has killed so many people. May peace soon come to the Holy Land.

Saturday, February 20, 2016

The House of Ron Fraser

There is very little information about Ron Fraser to be found in the issues of Worldwide News. But it is still worth taking a look.

Ron Fraser was born in Australia in 1941. He entered the world of Armstrongism around 1968 and joined HWA's Radio/Worldwide Church of God. By 1982 it appears he was based in Brisbane.

The January 18, 1982 issue of Worldwide News mentions Ron Fraser's wife helping to host Women's Club meeting.
The BRISBANE, Australia. SOUTH Women's Club had a men's evening for the final meeting of 1981 Nov 18. Director for the club was pastor Colin Sutcliffe. Mrs. Ron Fraser was hostess, and she warmly invited all to be involved. The questions presented by [another individual] received hearty responses. Theme for the evening was "Family Recreation," and many helpful points were given by [four names are then mentioned]. The evening was highlighted by a supper prepared by Mrs. Fraser [and two others]. (p. 9.)
Colin Sutcliffe was an early supporter of PCG. He set up PCG in New Zealand. According to PCG Information it was Colin Sutcliffe who devised the name Philadelphia Church of God. But for whatever reason he fell out of favor within PCG around 1998. This is mentioned in the Ambassador Report. He now leads another COG group based in Australia and New Zealand.

The December 1, 1986 issue of Worldwide News features a little report by Ron Fraser describing a rafting trip made by 59 WCG members on September 21, 1986.
Fifty-nine BRISBANE, Australia, SOUTH Church youths and parents took a raft trip down the Logan River Sunday, Sept. 21.
Canoeists paddled downriver to Aquatic Gardens, south of Brisbane. There they had a barbecue of hot steaks and sausages, salad, baked potatoes and ice cream. Forty family members joined the group for the barbecue. Ron Fraser. (p. 5.)
The June 27, 1988 issue of Worldwide News contains the following announcement.
Mr. and Mrs. Ron Fraser of Brisbane, Australia, are delighted to announce the engagement of their daughter Leanne to G. Roger Brandon of Pasadena. An October wedding in Brisbane is planned. (p. 6.)
There is one Roger Brandon who works for PCG. A 2011 article mentioned that he was a "facilities manager" at PCG's unaccredited "college". He has also written articles for PCG. He also wrote an article that idealistically describes HWA's family life.

Leanne Brandon later worked as a teacher for PCG's Imperial Academy.

I cannot quite confirm at present that they are Roger and Leanne Brandon's children but it can be mentioned that there one James Brandon who has written for PCG since 2012 (as may be seen here and here) and there is one Jessica Brandon who has written for PCG since 2014.

And that is not the only family connection the House of Ron Fraser has within PCG.

In 1994 his son, Gareth Fraser, married the daughter of John Amos and Helen Amos. John Amos was Gerald Flurry's assistant pastor and was fired with him from WCG in December 1989. John Amos was instrumental in establishing PCG with Gerald Flurry. Gareth Fraser has written for PCG since 1996 (if not earlier). His articles may be seen here and here.

In time Ron Fraser left WCG and joined Gerald Flurry's PCG. Ron Fraser wrote many articles for PCG as may be seen here and here.

His writings has often been commented upon on this blog as may be seen here. Here is one (bizarre) opinion he stated once in 2009.
One has to wonder if such a judicial attitude had prevailed during World War II—in which British soldiery often entered battle grossly underequipped—whether the rule of the tyrant who could have overwhelmed Britain [Adolf Hitler] would have produced results any worse than the present tyranny of the feminist, homophile, politically correct thinking that dominates the British judiciary. (Ron Fraser, 'Human Rights' in Warfare?, August 2009.)
Ron Fraser died on October 7, 2013. His family is still closely aligned with PCG.

(Update: February 21, 2016: Ron Fraser had another son involved with PCG, namely David Fraser. His articles may be read here.)

Palestinian Lives Don't Matter for the COGs

On February 19, 2016 Al Jazeera released very disturbing footage of the fatal shooting in Jerusalem of one Mohammad Khalaf by Israeli personnel.

It is asserted that he tried to stab the Israeli personnel stationed outside Damascus Gate. But since he was fatally shot numerous times it is now impossible for him to face a trial.

Among the COGs the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is simplistically viewed in black and white terms. One side is good. One side is bad, evil, sometimes even portrayed as satanic.

The COGs "watch" events in Jerusalem and the Holy Land thinking that the unfolding events reveal that the Great Tribulation and Christ's return will soon occur. In PCG for instance one future event they "watch" for is for Jerusalem to become divided. They expect the Palestinians to become stronger later.

But what they are not "watching" for anything that contradicts this view. They are taught to believe that the State of Israel will soon collapse and be conquered by Europe.

So when yet another Palestinian gets killed by Israeli personnel the COGs ignore it because it does not fit any prophetic scenario they have concerning the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. So far about 180 Palestinians and 30 Israelis have been killed in the Holy Land since October 1, 2015.

The COGs should look at the situation as it is instead of trying to find some sign that their false prophecies will soon come true.


Gazan Women Face 63% Unemployment

From Ma'an News Agency:
GAZA (Ma'an) -- The unemployment among women in the Gaza Strip has reached more than 60 percent, a women’s organization said on Saturday.
Fida Abu Darbi, the executive officer for the Association Of Women’s Work Committees, said the unemployment of women in Gaza had reached "astronomical" levels at 63.3 percent. (February 20, 2016.)
The blockade was supposed to engineer the fall of Hamas from power. It has failed to do so. But while the Israeli-Egyptian blockade is in force so many within Gaza are suffering. The blockade needs to go.

PCG's Trumpet Website Now in German

PCG has now released a German language website: Die Posaune.

As if Germans did not have enough problems already.

Friday, February 19, 2016

UCG Falsely Portraying HIV/AIDS as Associated with Gays in the US

Back in late 2000 UCG published an article about HIV/AIDS. (Melvin Rhodes, AIDS: How a Killer Plague Can Be Stopped, December 20, 2000.)

Let's take a look at what is said here.

Rhodes acknowledges that HIV/AIDS originated from a disease that infected an animal. For some reason he says it was from the African green monkey. But according to  The Origins of AIDS by Jacques Pepin (2010) HIV/AIDS came from SIV, a disease that infected the Central Chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes troglodytes).
No one knows for sure how or when AIDS started. The many theories come down to the fact that the African green monkey carries the HIV naturally in its bloodstream. Somehow, several decades ago, the virus in the blood of the green monkey was transmitted to people, probably when hunters killed and butchered HIV-carrying monkeys or consumed meat from infected monkeys. Once in the human bloodstream, the virus proved to be a deadly killer.
As mentioned in a previous post it is widely known this initial infection occurred around the 1920s. There appears to have been two initial infections, one in Cameroon but that strand never got out of Africa. The other appears to have come from what is now known as the Democratic Republic of the Congo and appears to have first established itself in the city now known as Kinshasa around the 1920s. But due to modern means of transportation introduced by European colonial rule the undetected disease spread from Africa. It was that strand which managed to spread itself all over the world before being detected in 1981. One account trying to determine where HIV/AIDS came from may be found in The Origins of AIDS by Jacques Pepin (2010).
It could have ended there, in the jungles of tropical Africa. But it didn't. Once the virus made the jump to man, it spread quickly around the world. Whereas trade in the Middle Ages was slow, modern transportation is fast. The result was that people all over the world were dying from AIDS before the disease even had a name.
So even though it is well established in Rhodes' mind that this dreadful disease came from a disease (SIV) that afflicted apes (the Central Chimpanzee) he still tries to stereotype HIV/AIDS as being somehow closely associated with homosexuals.
In the United States the problem was first seen among homosexuals. It was soon established that certain homosexual practices were particularly effective means of spreading the disease.

However, it would be wrong to describe the disease as only a “gay plague.” Well more than half the people with AIDS are in Africa, where it is a heterosexually transmitted disease.
If, as even Rhodes admits, that it is wrong to describe HIV/AIDS as being somehow associated with gays then why say that "certain homosexual practices were particularly effective means of spreading the disease" in the United States?

It is also bizarre and inaccurate to describe HIV/AIDS as "a heterosexually transmitted disease" in Africa when it can easily be transmitted like that everywhere.

It is clear that this is one stereotype that need to be thrown away. HIV/AIDS afflicts all those infected and affected by it. It is wrong to slur a certain group as being somehow associated with them. This is wrong morally and factually. Let us not use this dreadful disease to try to slur others.