Friday, June 7, 2013

"Hateful and Awful Environment" Rumored at LCG HQ

From an Anonymous comment at Banned by HWA:

Jesus said hate was the equivalent of murder. Maybe LCG is content simply to not have another physical murderer like Terry Ratzmann in its midst, but Jesus holds his followers (are LCG members his followers?) to a higher standard.

I was reminded of this when talking to a friend whose son attended the recent LCG Singles Weekend in Charlotte. Mind you, this is all secondhand and hearsay, but what he heard from his son is that the amount of hatred among LCG HQ staff in Charlotte was shocking. Ministers there privately undercut other ministers, calling each names like "liberal" or "idiot" or "unsophisticated" or "liar". Meredith is seen as out of touch and as only listening to his favorites, who flatter him and lie to him. Many of the younger people are flagrantly disobedient to the teachings of HWA, and apparently if you are a friend of the right minister's son you too can get away with premarital sex, drug and alcohol abuse, Sabbath-breaking and more. Teens and young adults of the LCG in Charlotte are apparently split between those who are disgusted by the hypocrisy and those who are happy to live secret lives so they can have all the fun their church would officially deny them.

It sounds like a hateful and awful environment. But then again it sounds exactly like the fruit of the ACOG mentality. Whether or not it is true, it is certainly believable.
Seems the LCG HQ ministers are preparing for the funeral games of Roderick C. Meredith.

Seems many people at LCG HQ do not take the moral teachings of LCG seriously.

I feel sorry for those young people torn apart between what they are taught and what they do. May they soon be free.

Of course it is impossible to prove anything but it is fascinating to see rumors such as this, and it is certainly believable.

Thursday, June 6, 2013

PCG Members Say Mental Disorders Caused by Lack of Discipline and are Non-existant

As mentioned earlier PCG's Ron Fraser has written an article condemning mental health science as a money making scam of Germanic origin. He exploits honest criticism of the new edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders in order to claim the whole field of mental science is evil, made up, fraudulent and should be ignored. He has no evidence to back up these huge accusations. He is speaking ignorant nonsense like what you find from conspiracy theorists.

This is a very dangerous message. It is sickening to think how this message is going to negatively affect PCG members.

We can already see how some PCG members are accepting what Ron Fraser said in the comments they have posted onto that article and are parroting his inaccurate and paranoid ideas.

Some comments imply that mental disorders are simply caused by a lack of discipline.
When I attended grammar school back in the mid-60’s and 70′s, if someone had a ‘”behavior disorder”" they were immediately sent to the principal’s office and miraculously their “‘disorder”‘ was cured!

When I was in the 3rd(third) grade in the late 1960′s, a classmate was not only having “behavior disorder”, but also, he was bullying other classmates, myself, included. His father came to the classroom one day with him and spanked him right in the presence of my teacher and classmates. His father cured his “disorder”, right then and there.
If only more parents did what my classmate’s father did, all “behavior disorders” will immediately, be cured and there will be no need for “magic pills/medicines”.
We are in a sad state indeed. the number of invented illnesses that have been manufactured to account for our lack of proper parentage is staggering.

Are the parents of mentally disabled children within PCG going to be (falsely) demonized as being responsible for their children's mental illness?

Some PCG commenters seem convinced that mental disorders do not exist but are simply made up by doctors as part of a money making scam.
Thank you, Mr. Fraser, for a comprehensive analysis of this important topic....I believe diet must play a very important role, alongside proper child rearing practices, in contributing to so many of these “so-called” mental conditions.

Armstrongites have long speculated that changing one's diet can cure illnesses and serve as a substitute for the medicine HWA banned. (And how on earth can that small article be considered comprehensive in any way?)

Particularly troubling is this comment from DP in which he states he is throwing away his job because, he seems to say, (the Armstrongite) God does not like it. He is quite vague about it but it is clear he is making a very profound career change using advice most of us would regard as less than reliable.
Dear sir, Thank you for this article, this strikes a personal note. The practices of psychiatry, psychology is truly a world of confusion & evil! . It has lead more people into mental bondage , & as you point out often the medication that’s (forced) on people have not only caused secondary illnesses, but has lead to death. I know this all too well with 12 years working in this awful business. Thank God, it was only last week I received timely counselling from a God’s true Minister & made perhaps one of my best choices ever, to quit this work all togethor. Let alone those suffer at the hands of this evil system, even as mental health worker’s when one is a subject of any form of treatment, there’s no getting away from it. It simply enslaves lives, & in my opinion has caused mass mentaly/physical disabilities, a primary cause of unemployment & associated social problems. Thank God, time is almost up for this satan inspired world! The Kingdom of God is almost at hand! .

Another comment I would to highlight is this one, because it so perfectly encapsulates HWA's anti-medicine superstition which PCG is doing all it can to perpetuate.
What a great article I might be wrong about this but to me it seems like people want to be sick with some type of mental illness or disease , these people turn to their doctor(s) for healing instead of turning to God .

A lot of people within old WCG, PCG and possibly within other COGs have died because of following dangerously inaccurate advice such as that. Non-COG people reading this comment will have no idea that this attitude came from HWA's anti-medicine superstition (which he pinched from the Jehovah's Witnesses of the 1920s) which insisted that relying on doctors and medicine for healing was damnable idolatry. This attitude also fuels Ron Fraser's irresponsible contempt for mental health science.

PCG ministers have no right or qualification to spread such unfounded and dangerous information. It is terrible to think of all the people within PCG whose lives will be adversely affected because of these false, inaccurate and paranoid ideas.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

PCG Condemns Mental Health Science as Money Making Fraud of Germanic Origin

HWA taught that healing illnesses can only come from God alone. Anyone trying to heal an illness by going to doctors or taking medicine or taking vaccines is committing idolatry and committing a grave sin against God. He stole these ideas from the Jehovah's Witnesses who shunned medicine and vaccines from 1921 till 1952. Because of this many of his followers in the Radio / Worldwide Church of God got sick and died from this anti-medicine superstition. Some COGs no longer practice this doctrine of death.

Alas, Gerald Flurry's PCG shows no sign of putting a stop to this madness.

PCG has released an article by Ron Fraser, What Mental Illness is Not, condemning mental health medication as a money making fraud of Germanic origin.

In this disgusting article Ron Fraser exploits legitimate concerns about the new edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders  in order to claim that mental science is a money making fraud.

I have heard about the controversy about this new edition of that book. People are worried that some definitions may be wrong and that it seeks to categorize too much.

But that is not what Ron Fraser says. He instead misleads his readers by pretending that this controversy "proves" that mental health science is a money making fraud. That is deception. He is terribly misleading his readers.

He claims that mental illness is made up by doctors and psychologists to make money. (Is he projecting?)

Below I have highlighted some of the buzzwords he uses to show just how crazy this article actually is.
The whole field of human behaviorists was infected by an anti-God, evolutionary rationale.
Ungodly and evolutionary to the core
, the pseudo-science of psychology—following a century and more of foisting its trickery off on to a gullible public seeking basic answers to the most fundamental of human questions—stands largely revealed as a fraud.
It does not get any better in this article.
Nevertheless we continue to slice people’s craniums open to determine, for instance, how the operation of the left side of the brain varies from that of the right, and to experiment with brain surgery in hugely risky operations in which man was never designed to be engaged.
Is he saying we should never try to understand how the human mind works?
The problem is that, though having become the global standard for the description of mental illness and, as the Economist claims, being regarded by professional psychologists as “holy writ,” the book [Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders] remains a tremendously flawed attempt to describe, categorize and diagnose treatment for a whole pile of “illnesses” created by the human behaviorist professions.
This is conspiracy theory madness!
Of course adhd has been an identifiable childhood “illness” for decades. When I was a child, the school teacher quite correctly identified such behavior as resulting from poor parenting.
What chutzpah! Fraser easily dismisses all these scientists as frauds and charlatans and instead listen to his school teacher and himself. He insists he knows enough to know that ADHD does not exist but simply comes from bad parenting. He blames the parents.

He also blames Germans for creating mental health science.
Almost 40 years ago, when I began studying psychology as a student, I could not help but note that the main names attached to the establishment and growth of this field of study were Germanic... the early authors of various psychology textbooks had a uniquely Teutonic tone to their names and the culture from which they hailed. They largely hailed from the school of German rationalists. The same school that had sought to discount biblical revelation in favor of the false theory on which they attempted to found their own pseudo-science—the theory of evolution.
He condemns the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders as "the psychologist’s bible" and states that it is "regarded by professional psychologists as “holy writ,”".

(Is it not strange how he, a minister of a false religion, claims mental health science is like a religion? His demonization of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders strangely sounds like an Atheist condemning organized religion.)

Fraser thinks mental health science is simply a money making scam.
Meanwhile a lot of psychiatrists, psychologists, sociologists and pharmacists have been made rich by religiously following its dictums.What a sad world we live in.
The article is filled with negative buzzwords to make PCG followers hate and become suspicious of mental health professionals. Here are some of them:
charlatan authors

pseudo-scientists [who] created a richly rewarding profession for themselves

we are more ignorant than ever about the way that the human brain—and more importantly the human mind—operates [because of them].

professional behaviorist’s bag of tools

ignorance still breeds greater ignorance

so-called “experts” on human behavior

an admittedly false text, prescribing false “cures”

the false ways of a society hell-bent on its own destruction.
What a sad state of affairs in PCG that they are ruled over by such ignorant men. How many people will die or suffer avoidable health setbacks because of this article is impossible to know.

Ron Fraser is responsible for anyone who suffers or even die because of the astoundingly stupid and ignorant advice he gives here.

Like Dave Pack, Meredith Also Promises His Followers that "Every Nation on Earth, Not just a Few" will Hear LCG's Witness

Recently Banned by HWA has been noting how Dave Pack has been promising his followers that the work of RCG will soon greatly expand.
The Real Truth magazine subscription list will begin sprinting toward multiple millions....Of course, the number of magazines distributed in the Newsstand Distribution Program will skyrocket because of much greater funding.

Powerful Public Bible Lectures will be held worldwide. Our websites will become the biggest thing in religion online that the world has ever seen. Internet advertising will multiply to awesome proportion. So will large newspaper ads. The list of how the Work will grow bigger could go on and on.
Pack is just like the advertizer who always says "and more..." at the end of his product description.

These words instantly reminded me of how Meredith would claim to his members that LCG is just about to witness astounding and drastic growth. He promises his followers that soon the whole world will be listening in rapt attention to what Meredith and LCG has to say about true religion, the future, society, etc.

One can see this in his booklet, Fourteen Signs Announcing Christ's Return. This is seen under sign eight: 'The Gospel of the Kingdom Preached to All Nations'. This is still posted in LCG's website.
The great “Olivet prophecy” of Jesus Christ is pivotal in understanding future events. In Matthew 24:3, Jesus was asked by the disciples, “Tell us, when shall these things be? And what will be the sign of Your coming, and of the end of the age?” As we have seen, Jesus first warned them about false prophets, wars and rumors of wars leading to world war, famines, disease epidemics and earthquakes, and said, “All these are the beginning of sorrows” (v. 8).

“Then they will deliver you up to tribulation” (v. 9). The coming Great Tribulation will affect the Church as well as national Israel. “And [they will] kill you, and you will be hated by all nations for My name’s sake.” This verse is quite significant because it says, in effect, that God’s true Church and Work will be known by all nations. People will not hate it unless they know about it, will they? They will hate the true Work of God because they will hate its message....
Every nation on earth, not just a few, will hear about this...(Source.)
Note that Meredith uses the future tense. This is supposed to happen in the future. Some COGs and individual Armstrongites teach that HWA already witnessed to the world and therefore say there is no need for them to tell the world about Armstrongism. Meredith is not from that school of thought.

Has this great expansion of 'the work,' spreading Armstrongite heresies, occurred? Obviously not.

We can count this as yet another false prophecy Meredith continues to spread.

Is Dave Pack Self Deluded after Fourteen Years of Producing and Listening to his own Propaganda?


An inside source has told us that Dave Pack's fledgling little group consists of 1,700 people.
Dave is also disappointed in this SMALL number of people.  Try as he might will all the media advertising, bombastic boastful letters, attacks on all the splinter groups, and outright poaching of men he thought would bring legions of followers with them, he cannot draw members into his group.
He seriously is perplexed as to why no one cares!  Can he be that naive?
I think he is that naive. But there are reasons for this.
For a start he has deluded himself. For the last fourteen years (5110 days) he has surrounded himself with (1) people who genuinely believe he is God's gift to humanity, the successor to HWA, or (2) cunning flatterers and yes men who agree with whatever nonsense he spouts in order to be on his good side for selfish reasons.
For all these fourteen years these people have continuously put to fruition whatever Pack proposes to do. 
In RCG Dave Pack has no one to answer to for his acts.
If anyone dares to cross him he fires them, disfellowshipps them. Even in his days as a WCG minister Dave Pack displayed strong authoritarian tendencies. Maybe his vicious acts of repression teaches him that anyone who oppose him is worthy of contempt. No one tells him, "What you have done is a terrible thing." Instead they agree or acquiescence in it and he (in his simplistic black and white thinking) encourages himself into deluding himself that he only acts out of the noblest of intentions. There is no accountability whatsoever. He is free to act how he wills.
(I am not blaming those who work with RCG for Dave Pack's wild megalomania. I am simply describing a situation Dave Pack has created for himself. He persuades and coerces people to conform to the will of himself and his organization. Dave Pack bears responsibility.)

What must it do to someone to be told for fourteen years he is wonderful and excellent, that whatever he does is noble and pure?
 
They all tell Pack that he is a great man. They tell him news he wants to hear. Pack is stuck in a information bubble of his own making.
Maybe he actually believes his own propaganda.

Maybe he is drunk with his own filthy propaganda. 

Maybe he is like a fourteen year alcoholic.

Maybe at some point in these fourteen years he forgot that the point of his false teachings is to control people and instead actually believed it literally.

Why shouldn't he? No one around him will say he is wrong.

The Boom and Bust of Armstrongism

From a comment by Joe Moeller at thisBanned by HWA post.

It intriguingly compares the boom and bust of Armstrongism with how a bubble market operates and that the bubble has long popped. The COG ministers are merely fighting over what little remains.

HWA started with 19 people about 80 years ago.

There are about 25k people today who are Sabbatarians who can trace some type of lineage back to that 1934 beginning.

The compounded rate of return of member growth is therefore 9.39% annually.

The rate of return on the SP 500 over the equivalent period of time (with dividends reinvested) is nearly exactly the same as that, from 1934 to present.

Thus we can say that Armstrongism has grown at a rate equivalent to American industry which is not out of the ordinary.

What we can also add, is that the period from 1950 to 1970, where the bulk of the WCG was grown, was a type of "bubble market", much like the late 1990s internet stock boom, or the early 2000s real estate bubble.

Markets that are growing at 30 to 40% annual growth rates for a number of years, ALWAYS blowoff and collapse. 9% is the historical norm for markets and return on capital. WCG was a speculative bubble that was levitating on a unique period of time and space... that of Cold War terror and limited , captive audience, communciation through both radio and TV.

Companies expanding at such high rates of return end up hiring less than trained personnel, and also start to face the dilution factor of new competitors coming into their market share, especially if the margins are so good in the expansion. In effect, they sow the seeds of their own destruction.

What you see in the COG today is a normal correction phase of an inflated market, and a normal market shakeout. Much like the internet boom, the hundreds of companies that had no real business plans and no real markets will eventually fade away. The same goes for the miniature coglets. The hundreds of little websites around will slowly be disappearing over the years.

Eventually, mature market places tend to settle down into perhaps two major players, and two more lesser players, for a total of all four controlling 90% of the marketplace. This has happened in finance, airlines, automaking , trucking and many other industries. It is the nature of things.

The COG is going through a major cyclical market cycle, with the boom top being somewhere around 1995. In the long economic cycles of wave theory, within a 75 year cycle, about one third of it is actually moving backwards. This means 25 years of consolidation, backing and filling, and shakeout per each long cycle. This implies that perhaps the bottom in the COG marketplace might be in finding footing at around 2020 or so.

We shall see.

Joe Moeller
Cody, WY

Tuesday, May 28, 2013

LCG's 20th Anniversary Celebration: Prelude to LCG's Crises

On pages 20-21 of theMarch-April 2013 Living Church News is an article by Jim Meredith detailing the celebration LCG HQ held for the 20th anniversary of the founding of the Global Church of God.

It is unjust that the man who enforced Herbert W. Armstrong's divorce and remarriage doctrine, causing the unnecessary termination of many marriages and the destruction of many families, who had eye surgery to save his eyesight while followers were told to avoid doctors or else they might be cast out into nuclear World War III and the lake of fire, who spread many false fear inducing prophesies (that Christ will return in 1975, etc.) and exploited people's fear by getting their three tithes and offerings. That is how Meredith gets his money.

It is not right that a man who has caused so much trouble for what Armstrongites call "God's Church" should be honored and adored in such a manner.

One good thing that self-ordained false prophet Bob Thiel's departure from LCG did was to mar this day for Meredith and his collaborators at LCG HQ. They would not have welcomed his temper tantrum, especially at a time like that.

However since this anniversary celebration LCG seems to also be in a financial crisis caused by LCG members not sending in as much money as LCG HQ anticipated. Maybe seeing Richard Ames hand over that "Baccarat crystal eagle" to Meredith made LCG members realize they did not need to send in so much money to them. LCG HQ has even cruelly disfellowshiped Thomas Baca II, an employee in their TV department. One LCG minister, Rod Reynolds, has resigned. 

Things are far from ideal within LCG, despite what their propaganda tries to tell LCG members.

Monday, May 27, 2013

The "HWA is End Time Elijah" Doctrine Dates Back to 1966 At Least

In a Banned by HWA post about Dave Pack trying to associate himself with HWA by boasting of getting a RCG member to pay $24,000 to get a Steuben Crystal and claiming possession of it somehow gives him authority over the scattered COG members.

In that post Byker Bob gives the following comment that I feel deserve greater attention:
This guy is a revisionist, who delights apparently in inserting himself fraudulently into the past history of WCG.

The Elijah connection with HWA was alive and well at AC in Pasadena in 1966, the year prior to Dave's arrival on campus. How do I know this? Some of the less reverant amongst the student body, and I immediately picked this up myself, based on some of the sermons and Bible Studies, began calling HWA "Elijah" some times.

A good friend, whose parents were in town visiting, was given car privileges on one particular summer Saturday night. We ended up using it for an awesome joyride seeing some of the pop culture things we'd only heard about throughout the L.A. area. At one point while rounding the corner from Grove to Orange Grove, my bud wondered, as we passed HWA's home if "Elijah was home".

Pack has come up with an Al Goreithm, and is equally shameless!

BB
COG authors have always been terribly vague about when this particular idea first arose within the Radio Church of God/Worldwide Church of God. Now Byker Bob tells us it dates to at least 1966, and it seems it was around even earlier than that.

Of course it is complete nonsense. HWA was a false prophet who made many false prophesies.

Sunday, May 26, 2013

Is Dave Pack Losing his Mind?

Recently Banned By HWA devoted eight posts to analyzing Dave Pack's latest screed to the other COGs insisting that his organization is far and away the best COG there is and that God is not working through any other human being except himself.

Dave Pack Says COG Members of Other Groups Are Unclean

Dave Pack: All Non-COG People are Infidels

Dave Pack On Vile Rotten Music and Other Filth That COG Members Wallow In Like Pigs

Dave Pack: The Restore Church of God Is God's Temple On Earth and the Dwelling Place of God

Dave Pack: Any COG Minister Coming to the RCG Has To Be Reeducated Before They Can Receive God's Blessings

Dave Pack Damns UCG For Council Report on the Role of Women in the Church 

Dave Pack Says: If you Rejected HWA as Zerubbabel Then You Will Reject Me as Joshua

Dave Pack: My God Is Ready To Strike Down Ministers Who Disagree With Me

To me these posts seem to show a most disturbing turn of mind Dave Pack seems to be undergoing at this moment. Dave Pack seems determined to out do himself in pomposity and wild speculation.

Is he losing his mind?

Thinking you are someone really important and special when you are not is actually a sign of mental illness. Has Dave Pack actually deceived himself with his own propaganda?

I shudder to think what Restored Church of God members have to go through because of this man. He does not show the signs of a stable man. I fear for them.

It is terrible that he has built himself to be such a great man, because this makes it impossible for him to receive correction from other people. So if he makes a mistake no one can advise him to correct himself without being demonized as an unbeliever.

I think Dave Pack's increasing delusions of grandeur are a matter of concern. I fear for RCG members who are under the influence of Dave Pack while he is in a state of mind like this.

Gerald Flurry Bizarrely Obsessed with Shunning "Laodiceans"

Banned by HWA has a very good post about PCG leader Gerald Flurry's vicious No Contact policy with "Laodiceans", namely ex-PCG members, ex-WCG members who did not join PCG, and anyone baptized into another COG. 

I posted the following comment to that post:

Gerald Flurry has always been bizarrely obsessed with shunning "Laodiceans". This was true even in a 1990 edition of Malachi's Message.

Once I did a blog after I read a 1990 edition of Malachi's Message. Here's one part of it relevant to this discussion.

I quote:

""If the work to the world is basically finished - most of what remains to be done is separating the Laodiceans and the Philadelphians.... That should not taken very long - but it will be painful! Very painful - in some cases it will break up families." (p. 78.)

"My word! This has to be one of the most disgusting, horrid and shocking statements Flurry ever says in this book. Here is the terrible no contact policy in embryo. Although (as far as I know) the no contact policy was not yet in force then, it seems clear that the seeds of self-righteous hatred against so-called Laodiceans (WCG members and members of other COGs) is already there in Flurry's heart.

"He knows the hatred he is teaching towards those he defines as Laodiceans will tear up families. But it seems clear from these words he is determined to do it regardless, as early as February 1990.

"It is a terrible tragedy that Flurry found himself in just the right time to gain enough converts from WCG to became one of the major Armstrongite COGs."

End quote.

I have always been particularly disgusted at PCG's no contact policy, even when I was an Armstrongite.