Monday, October 19, 2015

Joel Hilliker Ignoring the Muslim Condemnations of the 2005 London Bombings

On July 7, 2005, four terrorists bombed London murdering 52 innocent people. Those who carried out that most terrible mass murder in that criminal conspiracy are the ones responsible. No one else. We must not blame innocent people.

When writing the last post about Joel Hilliker's 2006 article fear mongering about British Muslims in which he mentioned the London bombings I noticed this particular complaint by Hilliker.
Thus, they flee from anything that could be remotely construed as such. One of the most common and predictable means of proving one’s credentials as an officially tolerant person is to insist—surely if one says it loudly and often enough it must be true—that the vast majority of Muslims detest what the terrorists are doing, and that violence is anathema to the imminently peaceful religion of Islam.

It is hard to ignore the fact, however, that these statements always issue from white, non-Muslim types—never from the leaders of this supposedly vast body of “moderate” Muslims.  (Joel Hilliker, The Sickness in Britain's Heart, November-December 2006.)
Note the condemning way Hilliker says "the vast majority of Muslims detest what the terrorists are doing". Hilliker insinuates that this assertion is false. Is Hilliker right?

So Hilliker says that only "white, non-Muslim" leaders make statements insisting that the vast majority of Muslims detested the terrorist bombing. This has the ugly insinuation that many (or even most) British Muslims side with the terrorists who bombed London in 2005 murdering 52 innocent people. Is Hilliker right?

Having read up on the phenomenon of Islamophobia I was aware that this is a common canard among such people. They tend to say, Muslims are silent about terrorism, and other such things. I knew that particular statement needed to be tested.

Turns out Wikipedia has an entire article devoted to listing the reactions to the London bombings. And many statements condemning the bombings came from all kinds of Muslims. Here are more statements from Muslim majority countries condemning the London bombings and Muslim organizations.
The Gulf Co-operation Council "condemns the terrorist attacks which hit the British capital in several locations this morning". ...

Egypt – Foreign Trade and Industry Minister Rachid Mohamed Rachid, who lived in London until his appointment in 2004, condemned the attacks while at a conference in Brussels. "Everyone is following what's happening in London with great anxiety. It is important to be brave in facing up to the scourge of terrorism," the state news agency MENA quoted him as saying.

Morocco – Communication Minister Nabil Benabdallah gave a statement on behalf of the government, saying that "these heinous attacks underline the need for the international community to...unite its efforts to fight these acts and abort their objectives".

Sahrawi Arab Democratic Republic – President of the Sahrawi Republic, Mohamed Abdelaziz expressed his condolences on behalf of the Saharawi people to the British people and government, vehemently condemning "the terrorist acts" that stroked the British capital. ...

Bangladesh – Prime Minister Begum Khaleda Zia within hours of the attacks condemned the act of terrorism and expressed deep sorrow upon the deaths in the attacks. Foreign Minister M. Morshed Khan later visited the British High Commissioner Anwar Choudhury to convey the condemnation of the Government of Bangladesh upon the attacks. ...

Indonesia – Foreign Ministry spokesman Marty Natalegawa has said, "We're shocked to hear the bombing attacks. We condemned them," He also expressed condolences to the victims and their relatives, and pray for the wounded for their early recovery. ...

Malaysia- Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said all Malaysians were saddened and distressed over the bomb attacks in London. He said every Malaysian hates violence and condemns it because violence is not the solution. He stated "I believe all countries and races condemn what had happened in London although we do not know yet who is responsible for the bombing". ...

Pakistan – Information Minister Sheikh Rashid said "We offer our heartfelt sympathies to those who suffered due to such acts". ...

Kuwait – denounced the attacks in a letter to British Prime Minister Tony Blair from Prime Minister Shaikh Sabah al-Ahmad al-Sabah, who is in the United States. Shaikh Sabah expressed Kuwait's "strong condemnation" of the blasts that left a number of "innocent casualties," said the state news agency KUNA. "These terrorist attacks which target innocent lives are against all human norms and values," the Kuwaiti leader said. Shaikh Sabah also expressed "Kuwait's sympathy and support to friendly Britain and to all actions it will take to eradicate vicious terror in order to preserve security and stability".

Lebanon – President Émile Lahoud said that "Lebanon, which has been the victim of violence for years, shares with the British their pain".

Saudi Arabia – Social Affairs Minister Abdulmohsen al-Akkas said his country, battling a two-year wave of attacks by Osama bin Laden's al Qaeda network, knew what London was suffering. "We understand. Since May 2003 we have been experiencing the horrors of terrorist acts" said Akkas, who was visiting London.

Turkey – Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan said that "we have always stressed that the fight against terror is something we all have to join into together. I believe especially that our mutual intelligence organisations need to pool their information and knowledge to be better able to support one another against attacks of this kind". ...

United Arab Emirates – Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Foreign Affairs Shaikh Hamdan bin Zayed al-Nahayan said The UAE government "condemns in the strongest possible terms these horrific crimes and declares full solidarity with the British government" and that the UAE also "supports any measures [the British government] may take to deal with" the attacks. ...

The Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia, Sheikh Abdul Aziz Al-Asheikh denounced the deadly blasts that rocked London, saying "Killing and terrorising innocent people and the destruction of property are not condoned by Islam". He also censured the terrorists for tarnishing the image of Islam by attaching their heinous crimes to the religion.

The Muslim Council of Britain said that it "utterly condemns" the "indiscriminate acts of terror".
The Australian Muslim Civil Rights Advocacy Network have issued a public statement condemning the attacks, offering their condolences to the British people, and pledging their support in bringing the terrorists to justice. ...
Grand Imam Mohammed Sayyed Tantawi of Cairo's Al-Azhar University condemned the attacks and said that the attacks could be not justified as an attempt to force Britain out of Iraq. "This is illogical and cannot be the motive for killing innocent civilians".
Also worth noting is the reaction of the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr. Rowan Williams.
Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Rowan Williams, spoke of his horror and grief. Amid widespread speculation that the bombings were the work of Islamic extremists, he said that, as it happened, he had "spent this morning with Muslim colleagues and friends in West Yorkshire; and we were all as one in our condemnation of this evil and in our shared sense of care and compassion for those affected in whatever way. Such solidarity and common purpose is vital for us all at this time of pain and sorrow and anger". On Friday he gave the "Thought for the Day" on BBC Radio 4 in which he spoke of the difference between shocked silence and calmness.
Even those associated with Hamas and Hezbollah condemned the London bombings. Would PCG ever to tell their readers such things?
Leading Lebanese Shi'ite Muslim scholar Mohammad Hussein Fadlallah [who was linked to Hezbollah] stated, "These crimes are not accepted by any religion. It is a barbarism wholly rejected by Islam." ...

Hamas – Moussa Abu Marzouk, a spokesman for The Palestinian Islamist organisation Hamas, has condemned the bombings, saying "Targeting civilians in their transport means and lives is denounced and rejected".
Even Assad, who would later horrify the world with the violent repression that has occurred under his rule since 2011 that has spawned so much pain and suffering, also sent condolences.
Syria – President Bashar al-Assad condemned the attacks in a cable sent to Prime Minister Tony Blair.
How did Hilliker miss all this? How is it that Hilliker dares to insinuate that many Muslims support terrorists or that Muslims leaders are silent about these things when there is so much evidence that this is simply untrue.

Hilliker misleading article was published in the November-December 2006 issue of PCG's recruitment magazine, The Philadelphia Trumpet. The editors of that issue are listed as Gerald Flurry, Stephen Flurry, Ron Fraser, Dennis Leap, Mark Jenkins and Ryan Malone. How is it that none of them bothered to note that Hilliker is so wrong with the statement at the start of this post? They also must bear blame for promoting Hilliker's misinformation.

How dare Hilliker and those fellows with him in PCG dare to spread such venomous accusations and insinuations against innocent people. 

Sunday, October 18, 2015

Joel Hilliker's Fear Mongering of British Muslims (2006)

Back in 2006 PCG's Joel Hilliker wrote an article in which he talked of people he opposed as being like a disease, like cancer and malignant. But does Hilliker try to distinguish between the guilty and the innocent? Let's see what Hilliker has to say.

The article is entitled "The Sickness in Britain's Heart". The sickness Hilliker refers to here are extremist Muslims and the British left for believing in things that Hilliker disagrees with.
The British have enabled extremist Islamism to infect their nation from within. It threatens to do them in.
Now at first it may be tempting to say that he is only talking about Al Qaeda like terrorists. But does Hilliker make a distinction between those who commit acts of violence such as the London bombing of 2005 and those who are innocent? As will be seen later Hilliker condemns the idea that "terrorists are just crazy fringers" among Muslims and instead builds up the supposed influence of Al Qaeda like terrorists among British Muslims.
When immunity is sufficiently disabled, a person faces certain death. Such is the sick state of Britain today. 

The United Kingdom is irreparably infected with a host of pathogens cultural, moral and spiritual. Though many of these hurt the national body, one is particularly deadly: the spread within British borders of aggressive, hate-filled, violence-loving Islamist extremism. This deep, creeping cancer has grown in Britain’s bowels for decades virtually unnoticed.
How strange it is to say that Britain faces "certain death" because of some extremist Muslims present within Britain today. What does he mean by this? That extremist British Muslims will somehow kill everyone in Britain?

Of course he does not believe this but this type of extreme rhetoric is merely emotive and prevents us from understanding what is happening in the world.

Historically when people wished to oppress others they were denigrated in various ways, including being compared to a disease. As will be seen later Hilliker downplays how pathetically marginal the terrorist bombers actually were among British Muslims.
Though the malignancy of radical Islamism is spreading in many non-Muslim nations—throughout Europe, North America and Southeast Asia in particular—in Britain the problem is uniquely bad. For its pathetic response to the incursion of militant Islam, commentator Daniel Pipes calls it the “weakest link in the Western chain.”
Official response to the July 7, 2005, terrorist attack in London provided a perfect CAT scan of the advanced state of the disease. Reportage of the event quickly produced a politically correct, Islam-free version of the murders: The perpetrators were “bombers,” not “terrorists.” That they were Muslims who had been recruited at a British- and EU-government-funded Islamic youth center known for its radical politics was glossed over.
Daniel Pipes is a notorious demagogue infamous for vilifying Muslims. He is part of what some have called the Islamophobia Network and he has been cited many times by PCG in their articles. The PCG leadership trust Daniel Pipes.

There is nothing wrong with condemning acts of violence and murderous terrorists. But we must be careful to distinguish between the guilty and the innocent.

So often in times past when people wished to justify treating other people in an oppressive way the victims were denigrated and insulted. Sometimes even compared to a disease.
British officials give the impression that they are far less afraid of terrorism than they are of being accused of racism or religious discrimination—hanging offenses under political correctness.
Notice how Hilliker condemns being accused of racism but Hilliker ignores the problem of racism. Hilliker acts as though racism is not a problem worth discussing.

Also it is should be noted that being condemned as being racist is not like hanging someone. This is a bizarre comparison.

Also as far as I know Hilliker has never lived in Britain. It is hard to be certain considering how reclusive PCG's leaders tend to be about themselves. How can Hilliker be sure he knows what is happening in Britain?
Thus, they flee from anything that could be remotely construed as such. One of the most common and predictable means of proving one’s credentials as an officially tolerant person is to insist—surely if one says it loudly and often enough it must be true—that the vast majority of Muslims detest what the terrorists are doing, and that violence is anathema to the imminently peaceful religion of Islam.

It is hard to ignore the fact, however, that these statements always issue from white, non-Muslim types—never from the leaders of this supposedly vast body of “moderate” Muslims.
This is absurd. Hilliker does not know what he is talking about. The fact he would denigrate British Muslims in such an ignorant and misleading way shows the contemptuous attitude Hilliker bears towards Muslims in Britain.
The Muslim Council of Britain said that it "utterly condemns" the "indiscriminate acts of terror". (Reactions to the 2005 London Bombings, Wikipedia.)
And it was not just Muslims in Britain who condemned it. Many Muslims all over the world condemned those murderous bombings. Here is one article from Sky News that shows this fact. Sky News is a media outlet partly owned by Rupert Murdoch, a right wing leaning media mogul.
Iran and Syria, both on Washington's list of states sponsoring terrorism, joined an unbroken chorus of condemnation, as did the Palestinian Authority, the Palestinian Islamist group Hamas and Lebanon's Shi'ite Muslim Hizbollah guerrillas.
"The use of violence to achieve aims is condemned," Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamid Reza Asefi said.
Syrian President Bashar al Assad, in a message to Prime Minister Tony Blair, condemned "these detested acts". (Sympathies From Middle East Countries, Sky News, July 7, 2005.)
Even Hamas and Hezbollah condemned these terrorist attacks.
Hamas, responsible for many suicide attacks on Israelis, said there could be no justification for the London bombings.
"Targeting civilians in their transport means and lives is denounced and rejected," Moussa Abu Marzouk, deputy chief of the group's political bureau, told Reuters in Damascus.
A Hizbollah statement on the blasts denounced attacks on civilians, citing humanitarian, moral and religious grounds. (Sympathies From Middle East Countries, Sky News, July 7, 2005.)
How did Hilliker miss all this? What sort of information bubble is Hilliker living in to ignore these many events and misinform his readers in such a way? Hilliker has done his readers a terrible disservice by misinforming them in such a way.

We now continue with Hilliker's article.

Hilliker then insists that many British Muslims sympathize with terrorists.
That a silent majority of European Muslims believed in democracy and despised terror was by now a truism,” wrote Bruce Bawer in While Europe Slept. “Observers found themselves thinking, however, that if that silent majority existed at all, it had to be one of the most silent majorities ever.” 
I will not comment about this particular book but the message Hilliker implies with this quote is wrong considering so many Muslims condemned the terrorist attacks.
In fact, polls such as those revealing that one in 10 British Muslims supported the 7/7 attacks—that one in four sympathized with the “feelings and motives” of the attackers—that more than half could “understand” why someone would blow himself up in order to kill innocent people—belied the idea that terrorists are just crazy fringers, motivated by something entirely separate from their religion.
Those murderers who bombed London were in fact extremists. But how can one get attention for oneself by saying that most British Muslims are just normal people who wish to live in peace? Instead Hilliker tries to scare the reader by making him or her think British Muslims cannot be trusted.

This statement shows that Hilliker makes little attempt to distinguish between the guilty and the innocent.

Hilliker then accuses leftists of apparently collaborating with Islamists terrorists just like the murderous bombers in London.
In the end, whatever the reasons, the effect of the left’s sympathy with Islamism is the same: When people—Muslim, Christian, secularist or anything else—are endlessly flooded with such messages, they are bound eventually to have increased hostility, even rage, against the U.S. and Israel, as well as any British policy that aligns with them.
This is an ugly attempt to demonize the left. PCG is right wing but instead of simply stating their stance they demonize the left by comparing them with the murderous bombers. What an extremist view it is to vilify half of political society by insinuating that they sympathize with the terrorists who bombed London.
Today, however, traditional British values have been almost wholly replaced by a rabid devotion to the hollow ideals of tolerance and multiculturalism.
So being pleasant towards ethnic minorities is vilified as "a rabid devotion" and as some sort of betrayal of "traditional British values". Standing up against racism is ridiculed.

Hilliker ends this article by insisting that all will be well in the end.
The disease is too far advanced; the body too weak. But they will not turn to God—the God who first gave them all their national blessings and who alone could restore them to health—not at first, anyway. Hosea’s prophecy is that first, like the Jews, the British will instead turn for help to the Germans. And that, as several dozen other prophecies plainly tell us, will prove to be a fatal mistake.

But the biblical narrative doesn’t stop there! Prophecy also tells us that, once the British have learned the invaluable lesson that those who trust in man are cursed—once they have suffered through the plagues that come as a result of their faithlessness—the remnant of them will turn in heartfelt repentance to God, and He will re-establish them as a strong, robustly healthy nation!
Of course this is largely nonsense. The British are not Israelites. The Germans are not Assyrians. And the false prophecies of Armstrongism based on British Israelism will never be fulfilled. And considering that Germany is supposed to be the problem for Britain why be so contemptuous (and ignorant) towards British Muslims?

We need to educate ourselves about is really happening in the world. We must avoid racist, stereotypical thinking and be sure that when we condemn acts of violence and terrorism we do not use this to slur innocent people. We must be careful to distinguish between the guilty and the innocent instead of letting scaremongers make us fearful of innocent people. It is wrong to vilify innocent people and use guilt by association rhetoric to condemn innocent people.

Saudi Arabia Spends 700% More on Its Military Than Iran



In all the many times PCG scare mongers about Iran it is quite likely that those under PCG's influence will be unaware that near Iran lies a nation state which last year happens to have spent 700% more on its military than Iran does and is at present quite hostile towards Iran. This nation state is Saudi Arabia.
It is worth noting that in 2014 Saudi Arabia spent $81 billion on its military, as much as Russia, and its purchase of more than $6 billion in military hardware makes it the world's largest importer of arms; the [United Arab Emirates] spent $23 billion more. ... [Iran's] defense budget is only around $10 billion. (Jeff Halper, War Against the People, 2015, Chapter 1.)
The world sure look different outside PCG's information bubble.

Friday, October 16, 2015

For PCG Israeli Jews Matter, Palestinians Do Not

For centuries now many in the United States have had to confront the problem of racism. In times past white supremacy was used to demonize and marginalize Jews in America. In 1913 one American Jew, Leo Frank, was lynched to death. He was murdered by racists. A victim of white supremacy.

Over time through trials and tribulations the problem of racism has abated although there are still many problems. But PCG, instead of recognizing that white supremacy is wrong, merely altered white supremacy by projecting their own white identity onto Jews using the false dogma of British Israelism.

British Israelism is false. Silenced.co has shown how British Israelism is built on a foundation of sand. In fact DNA evidence refutes British Israelism. 

But because PCG assumes that Jews are white like themselves this dictates that the State of Israel must be supported for racial reasons. PCG supports the State of Israel not because they are right but because they are white.

(How Israeli Jews view themselves is not relevant for PCG.)

PCG excludes Palestinians from any white identity. British Israelism assumes that Palestinians are not white. Therefore Palestinians are unimportant to PCG. They are aliens outside of "the (white) Israelite nations" of the United States, Britain and the State of Israel. But if any Palestinian commits an act of violence against Israelis it condemned, not because it is violent but because it is against whites.

But if an Israeli Jew should commit an act of violence against any Palestinian it is ignored or justified by blaming the Palestinian. Violence against Palestinians does not threaten PCG's version of white supremacy so PCG is blind to it. Such violence is not against whites therefore it is ignored.

Since a previous post was written PCG has now discussed the violence that is currently afflicting the Holy Land. In an utterly predictable way the only victims for PCG are Israeli Jews. The pain and sufferings of Palestinians are ignored because they are not white.
'Jewish lives matter.’ That was one Israeli commentator's response to the wave of terrorist attacks that have swept across Israel over the past two weeks. However, most of the Western media is silent about these attacks. On today’s show, Stephen Flurry shows why there is so much hatred toward the Jews. (PCG source.)
What about the Palestinians? Recently seven Palestinians of Gaza were shot to death by Israeli military personnel in a protest. In retaliation someone within Gaza launched a rocket towards Israel that failed to even injure anyone. Then the State of Israel sent a military plane to bomb a position in Gaza but this bombing killed a pregnant women and her three old daughter. Do their lives not matter to PCG?
Israelis are having to watch their backs thanks to a rash of knifings and small-scale terrorist attacks by Palestinians. (PCG source.)
What about the Palestinians? Palestinians have died in this terrible round of violence. Are they not suffering as well? PCG chooses to be selective in their sympathy for suffering based on the racist dogma of British Israelism. Oh the folly that British Israelism has wrought in PCG.
Over the past two weeks, seven Israelis have been murdered and many more have been injured in at least 26 terrorist attacks in Israel. In one particularly grueling attack captured by surveillance video on Tuesday, a Palestinian man rammed his car into Israelis waiting at a bus stop in Jerusalem. He then emerged from the wreckage brandishing a meat cleaver and started hacking at pedestrians. (Stephen Flurry, How the Jerusalem Awakening Is Prophesied to End, October 16, 2015.)
Of course this act of violence is terrible and awful. But the facts must be made known: PCG chooses to favor one side for racial reasons. And this particular act of violence is mentioned because it is against the side PCG favors.
State Department spokesman Mark Toner ... responded [to a reporter] saying, “[W]hat we’ve been very clear about saying is that we want to see both sides take affirmative steps, affirmative actions that reduce tensions in the region.” He then mentioned the horrific attacks against Israelis but added, “[W]e’ve seen also attacks on Palestinians, [investigations for which] remain ongoing.”

The attacks Toner referenced occurred “three or four weeks ago.” They supposedly legitimized a Palestinian “Day of Rage”—a day of killing Jews. Yet despite the facts on the ground, the United States kicked off another round of its moral equivalence game, with plenty of blame to pass around.

Matt Lee then asked what it was the United States expected from the Israelis to reduce the violence in Israel. Mark Toner said the Israelis should “[uphold] the status quo in Haram al-Sharif and [the] Temple Mount.” The problem with that statement is that it’s based on the lie that Arab propagandists have frequently repeated: “Dirty” Jews are secretly plotting to blow up mosques and desecrate Muslim holy sites. (Stephen Flurry, How the Jerusalem Awakening Is Prophesied to End, October 16, 2015.)
In this article Stephen Flurry makes no mention of the fact that some Palestinian Muslims were forbidden from entering Haram al-Sharif by Israeli personnel. This is a major reason why this round of violence has erupted. Instead of letting all Palestinian Muslims enter this important place freely some were forced to stay out. And further inflaming matters at the same time the Israeli authorities allowed some Israeli Jews to enter while keeping some Palestinians Muslims out. These facts are ignored by PCG.

Imagine if police forced WCG members of a certain age not to enter Ambassador College. Imagine the humiliation of not being enter a campus of one's own religious group by order of the authorities. That is the pain and humiliation some Palestinian Muslims have been forced to endure. But PCG chooses to ignore these pertinent facts.

It also needs to be stated that in recent weeks mobs of far right Israelis have been assembling themselves and intimidating Palestinians shouting "Death to Arabs" and "May your villages burn" as one YNet News reporter witnessed first hand as mentioned in an October 11, 2015 article.

Apparently it was in front of one such mob that a nineteen year old Palestinian man was shot to death in front of a mob that appears to have incited the police officer to use violence when he was not a threat.
Last Saturday an Israeli policeman shot and killed Fadi Alloun, a 19-year-old resident of the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Issawiya, after he was suspected of stabbing a 15-year-old Israeli near Jerusalem’s Damascus Gate.
A video that went viral following the incident shows young Jewish Israelis egging on the policemen to kill Alloun, despite the fact that it is unclear from the video whether he posed a threat when an officer shot him numerous times. (New video shows accused stabber posed no threat when shot, +972 Magazine, October 10, 2015.)
We need to be aware of what is happening. PCG fails to properly inform their readers by ignoring this situation.

It is wrong for PCG to use racist reasons to support the State of Israel. PCG uses an altered form of the same ideology that justified the malicious lynching of Leo Frank to support the State of Israel, namely white supremacy. The rationale behind PCG's pro-Israel stance is racist. PCG's supports the State of Israel for the wrong reasons.

Stephen Flurry: "We Are Not Here Making Predictions By Any Means"

While fear mongering about Jeremy Corbyn, Bernie Sanders, Barack Obama and leftists in general it so happens that Stephen Flurry makes the following astounding statement.
I mean we are not here making predictions by any means but we're certainly here to help you follow the trends, to watch your world, to look at where our nations are headed. (Stephen Flurry, Britain's Lurch to the Left, Trumpet Daily, September 18, 2015, 3 minutes.)
What a bizarre thing to say especially from a leader of a group that constantly claims to understand prophecy. So many of their booklets and their articles have the word "prophecy" in their titles.  

And these prophecies constantly fail. PCG have made many false predictions over the years.

Armstrongism has constantly boasted of being able to predict the future. And yet Stephen Flurry minimizes this in such a clumsy and boldly brazen manner.

PCG Moaning About Jeremy Corbyn

PCG is right wing. (Although PCG sometimes professes otherwise.) So PCG tends to be hostile and negative towards leftists.

So naturally when Jeremy Corbyn was elected the new leader of the Labour Party PCG condemned this.
The election of Jeremy Corbyn as the leader of Britain’s Labor Party is viewed by many as nothing short of a joke. Those on the right look at it as a political gift, essentially guaranteeing their side will win the next election. Yet in the last election, Britain’s Conservative Party won a majority by just a few seats. How quickly could a shift occur in Britain’s government? And what does it say about Britain today when the majority of its second-largest political party votes in a man with a reputation like Jeremy Corbyn’s? Listen to Stephen Flurry discuss Britain’s sharp left turn on today’s Trumpet Daily Radio Show. (Stephen Flurry, Britain's Lurch to the Left, Trumpet Daily, September 18, 2015.)
Instead of just being direct and saying, We at PCG are right wing. Corbyn is left wing. So we oppose him for that. Instead in McCarthyist fashion Corbyn is vilified as essentially a traitor.

He is accused of having "dangerous views" and "radical extremist views". Stephen Flurry tells his listeners that Corbyn views America as the moral equivalent of ISIL and is openly sympathetic towards Hamas and Hezbollah. All this may be heard within the first four minutes.

Ten minutes into the broadcast Corbyn is accused of not singing the British national anthem.

Actually PCG would never accept anyone from the left because PCG is so far to the right in regards to politics. These alleged views are not the real reason PCG opposes Corbyn. They do not approve of Corbyn because he is left wing.

Instead of trying to understand why the members of the Labour Party elected Corbyn he is vilified in such a wild manner.

A major reason why Labour has moved to the left and elected Corbyn is because of the austerity policies pursued by the current Conservative government in Britain. The Conservative government failing to help those in need by pursuing austerity led to Corbyn's election as leader of the Labour Party. In all the twenty minutes Stephen Flurry uses to condemn Corbyn in this broadcast this aspect of Corbyn's rise is never discussed or taken into account. PCG favors the right so PCG is blind to how the right unintentionally contributed to Corbyn's rise.

The left is alien to PCG. The PCG leadership spends no time in trying to understand those not like themselves. So when events like this happen because PCG do not understand it they portray it in such a terrifying way because they do not try to understand them.

If Corbyn is so bad as PCG alleges the British people will deal with him in due time. Why can't PCG trust the British people they claim to love so much?

PCG Does Not Vote, But Are Far Right Wing

In a recent broadcast Stephen Flurry mentions that PCG does not vote.
We don't get involved in politics except to comment on what's happening to our leaders. To the leaders of our nations. The lack of leadership ... And yet we don't vote. We don't endorse one group or the other group. (Stephen Flurry, Britain's Lurch to the Left, Trumpet Daily, September 18, 2015, 9 minutes.)
Even though PCG does not vote PCG leans very far to the right.

Stephen Flurry's father has even condemned President Obama as "another Antiochus," an Antichrist like figure of PCG's creation.

PCG hosted a certain Republican Congressman in their auditorium in 2013 as mentioned in a previous post. That points to PCG's position as right wing politically speaking. How could one be more right wing without actually joining the Republican Party?

Thursday, October 15, 2015

Reading PCG's Article, The Origin of Easter (1997)

Let us now read PCG's 1996 article, "The Origin of Easter" by David Todd with Stephen Flurry. Here Todd and Stephen Flurry uses Alexander Hyslop's ideas about Nimrod and Semiramis as the originators of the Babylonian religion to demonize Easter. This is done in order to condemn the Catholic Church and the Protestant churches as false and abhorred by PCG's God in order to compel the reader to join PCG. (And once one joins PCG he or she is required to pay three tithes and extra offerings to PCG for life.)

This article first appeared in the August 1997 issue of PCG's recruitment magazine, The Philadelphia Trumpet. It was later made available as a reprint article.

(For simplicity's sake I shall hereafter refer to Todd alone as the author of this article.)

At first Todd begins his article recounting how he celebrated Easter as a child in a Protestant church.

Todd complains about getting up early that day to perform in an Easter play.
What I didn’t like about Easter was having to get up hours before daylight to go to church and get our costumes on, so we could perform the play for all those who came. Most of them never attended church at any other time. (p. 1.)
It sounds strange to mention in print that one did not like to wake up early in order to perform in a play. That sounds like an activity one can be happy about and look back with satisfaction.

Todd then mentions going on a Easter egg hunt.
A prize awaited the child who found the most eggs. If you found the silver egg, you received an even better prize. But the best prize of all was reserved for the one who found the golden egg. That was the egg everyone wanted. To find the silver or golden egg was a real accomplishment. You had to be careful though. If you spotted the golden egg at the same time a bigger kid did, you might get clobbered trying to pick it up! (p. 1.)
Todd later adds a punch line to this anecdote on page 3 in order to demonize Easter.
When the apostle John wrote the book of Revelation, Babylon, as a city, had long been destroyed and left in ruins, just as the Old Testament prophets foretold. (p. 1.)
This is wrong. Babylon still existed as a city in the time the New Testament was written. But later it fell into ruin because other cities captured Babylon's markets and ran Babylon out of business.

Todd then recites the Armstrongite dogma  that Nimrod and his wife Semiramis founded the Babylonian religion from which all the pagan religions supposedly sprang from. HWA took this idea from Alexander Hyslop's book The Two Babylons, an anti-Catholic polemic which dates from the 1850s. It insists that the Catholic religion is essentially the Babylonian religion recreated. It is nonsense.

Todd even mentions Hyslop. It was Hyslop, a 19th Century Presbyterian minister of Scotland, who, for the most part, concocted this modern day myth in an anti-Catholic polemic. HWA merely took these ideas from Hyslop's book and used them to justify banning Easter and Christmas in order to demonize Catholicism and Protestantism. (Ironically it appears Hyslop never banned Easter or Christmas among his parishioners. He concocted this myth to condemn Catholicism, not to prop up his own following.)
Basing his conclusions on information that has come from history, legend, and mythology, Alexander Hislop has written in detail of how the Babylonian religion developed around traditions concerning Nimrod and his mother-wife Semiramis. When Nimrod died, according to the old stories, his body was cut into pieces, burned, and sent to various areas. Following his death, which was greatly mourned by the people of Babylon, his wife Semiramis claimed he was the sun god. Nimrod became a counterfeit “savior.” Semiramis, being Nimrod’s wife, labeled herself the “Queen of Heaven”. (p. 2.)
Todd also mentions Herman Hoeh and his ludicrous Compendium of World History.
Baal, like Nimrod, is referred to as the sun god. That is because they are one and the same. When the nations divided after the tower of Babel, they developed their own distinct gods with different names, but all originating in Babylon (see Genesis 11:9). Notice this quote by Dr. Herman Hoeh, in his Compendium on World History (page 48): “The Egyptian god Osiris was the Baal of the Phoenicians, the Marduk of the Babylonians, the Tammuz of the Semites, the Nimrod of the Bible.” All of those gods originated from the very foundation of man’s governments—Nimrod and Babylon. (p. 2.)
It is worth mentioning here that Hoeh was imitating Hyslop in that discredited book.
And who was the wife of Nimrod? None other than his own mother—Semiramis. It is from Nimrod and Semiramis that all of these pagan gods trace their roots. (p. 3.)
This seemingly Biblical idea actually comes from Hyslop. And Hyslop's writings about Nimrod and Semiramis was very confused as noted by one blogger.
One example is in that Hislop in various pages of his book [The Two Babylons] referred to Semiramis as being Nimrod’s wife, and again his daughter, and again his mother, and again that Nimrod had two mothers, and again nine mothers. And this is history? Woodrow counters with evidence that Semiramis and Nimrod did not even live in the same century together! (Source.)
It appears to have been HWA who tried to (partly) explain away Hyslop's confused writing on this topic by insisting that Semiramis was Nimrod's mother.

Todd then cites a 1981 book by Ralph Woodrow, Babylon Mystery Religion, which happened to be largely based on Hyslop's book.
Here is what Ralph Woodrow asked in his book, Babylon Mystery Religion: “From where, then, did Easter observance come? Did the early Christians dye Easter eggs? Did Peter or Paul ever conduct an Easter sunrise service? The answers are, of course obvious.”

The origin and meaning of Easter has no connection with the first-century Church. Woodrow continues, “The word [Easter] comes from the name of a pagan goddess—the goddess of the rising light of day and spring. ‘Easter’ is but a more modern form of Eostre, Ostera, Astarte, or Ishtar, the latter, according to Hislop, being pronounced as we pronounce ‘Easter’ today.” (p. 3.)
Woodrow is cited at length in this article on pages 3 and 5.

Woodrow later concluded that Hyslop's book was nonsense. Woodrow proceeded to explain this fact in his book The Babylon Connection? It was published in March 1997 several months before Todd's article was published. At much financial cost Woodrow renounced his 1981 book Babylon Mystery Religion. The reader of Todd's article would never know of Woodrow's renunciation of Hyslop's ideas. Why is it that so long after Woodrow exposed Hyslop's words as nonsense that PCG continues to promote this article using Woodrow's 1981 book?

It is intriguing how Todd cites Hyslop, HWA, Hoeh and Woodrow to insist that Nimrod and Semiramis founded the Babylonian religion. But in fact all of these persons are citing Hyslop. It is Hyslop who devised this modern myth about Nimrod and Semiramis. No one else.
The sun was considered to be the “golden egg” by the ancient Egyptians. (p. 3.)
This ties in with Todd's recounting of his childhood Easter egg hunt. What rank fear mongering.
Mr. Armstrong then concludes by asking the question, “Then why should you do it today?” Good question! (p. 4.)
Banning Easter is a tool that PCG (and the other COGs groups) use to make people socially dependent on them. This attempt to demonize Easter and make it utterly abhorrent to the reader is an attempt to isolate and control the reader. Those who join PCG are required to pay three tithes and are even ordered not to contact ex-members or the members of the other COG groups.
We can begin to see how this pagan custom celebrating the resurrection of Tammuz infiltrated its way in the “Christian” world under the guise of Jesus’ 40-day fast. Like so many of the customs of this world, no matter where they originate, people assume them to be of God as long as someone along the way stamps “Christian” on them. Yet God tells us not to trust man (Jeremiah 17:5). If God says to observe it, you can be sure it will be found somewhere in His inspired word—the Holy Bible. (p. 5.)
Everything is interpreted in a hostile and paranoid manner. Instead of seeing that using Lent to focus upon Jesus' devotion would be most useful in keeping people focused on the Christian religion it is condemned as a sinister infiltration. 

"Yet God tells us not to trust man" is loaded language that really means, Believe what PCG tells you. All else is wrong.
For those who might doubt these ancient pagan origins, ask yourself, where in the Bible does it teach us to abstain from meat on Friday and to instead eat fish? These traditions and customs are not of God. (p. 5.)
And, considering that Todd comes from a Protestant church in Oklahoma, why is he here fixated upon these Catholic customs? Because Todd is mimicking Hyslop's original purpose in concocting this Nimrod-Semiramis myth: to condemn Catholicism.

Near the end Todd gets to the point: He uses his demonization of Easter to condemn all other churches as false, Catholic and Protestant.
It is true that Jesus came and established the true Church. But as we have already seen, Satan has his pagan customs and beliefs. And he also has his church and false Christs . Few people realize that the Bible actually prophesies of two churches—one great false church and one small, persecuted true Church of God.

The great false church is pictured by the woman riding the scarlet beast of Revelation 17. On her forehead is written, “Mystery, Babylon the great.” Yes, the ancient city of Babylon has long been destroyed. But the pagan customs and traditions originating there have continued in Satan’s false churches. This false church is labeled the mother of harlots. She has many daughter churches that have come out of her in protest, calling themselves Protestant. The very name Babylon means confusion! Certainly, the hundreds of different denominations, sects and religions of this world point to nothing but confusion. God is not the author of confusion .... Satan is! (p. 6.)
How hypocritical it is for PCG to mock the hundreds of Protestant churches while Armstrongism itself has also splintered apart into hundreds of competing groups. PCG is but one of them.
These days of Lent, Good Friday, Easter Sunday, Christmas and other pagan holidays the world holds sacred, are an abomination to God. (p. 7.)
The demonization of Easter by PCG is an attempt to isolate the reader from mainstream society in order to control him or her by compelling the reader to join PCG and pay three tithes for the rest of his or her life.
Fortunately, God has recorded which days and observances are actually holy and sacred to Him! They are the annual holy days and His weekly Sabbath. These days do not originate in Babylon with Nimrod and Semiramis. They began with the God of this universe! Rather, they keep us in remembrance of God’s great master plan for mankind. Together, God’s holy days reveal the incredible human potential—the fact that God is a Family and that man, who has been created in the very image of God, has the opportunity to be born into that Family. Now that is exciting! (p. 7.)
This refers to the God Family doctrine which, unfortunately for those who believe in it, happens to be completely non-biblical. It is a doctrine concocted by HWA very likely taken from another source, possibly the Mormons or early teachings of the Jehovah's Witnesses. (Also is the God Family doctrine really that much different from pantheism?)

Todd's article ends with a section condemning hot cross buns as originating outside (PCG's version of) Christianity and also accursed by (PCG's) God. It seems odd to stick this section at the very end when the previous section seemed stylistically more fitting as the end. Perhaps it was an insert in the original magazine issue.

And so this article which demonizes Easter to get more tithes paying converts for PCG comes to an end. Too bad the reader has little idea of the extreme things PCG members are historically known to commit such as refusing medical treatment or shunning family members.

Israeli Haaretz Columnist Speaks Out About "Death Penalty Without Trial"

Recently some in Israel proposed applying the death penalty for terrorists. Netanyahu, to his credit, chose to bury that idea. But in recent days there has been a wave of stabbings (some fatal) against Israelis committed by individual Palestinians has given rise to a disturbing phenomenon.

While Israeli Jewish stabbers such as the murderer in the gay pride parade or the one in Dimona were successfully apprehended to face justice in a court of law when the stabber is Palestinian somehow it keeps ending with the Palestinian being shot to death.

Haaretz columnist Gideon Levy, an Israeli Jew, has condemned this as "a death penalty without trial."
Now add to the wave of terror attacks the worst kind of damage – Israeli society is losing its image. This society has had savage periods before, but not like this one, in which every stabber or anyone who threatens with a knife, screwdriver or vegetable peeler is executed, even after he has thrown down his weapon, while the killer becomes a hero of the nation.

Those who wanted the death penalty for terrorists are now receiving a more ignominious version – a death penalty without trial. Fourteen Palestinians have been killed this way in the past week, most of them would not be liable for a death sentence in a state of law. The blood lust, the likes of which is not remembered in these parts, wants more and more blood.

In some of the attacks, the security forces and civilians acted appropriately and neutralized the assailants. Sometimes, there is no choice but to shoot and kill. But in other cases, they carried out an execution, there is no other way to describe it. The video clips prove it indisputably. (Gideon Levy, "Israel's Lawless Death Penalty Without Trial Buoyed by Cheers of the Masses," Haaretz, October 11, 2015.)
What a tragic state of affairs.

We need peace in the Holy Land now so that all, Israelis and Palestinians, can live together in peace.

How dare the COGs use these bitter tragedies as fodder for their false prophecies. We need peace now.

Tuesday, October 13, 2015

Reading PCG's Article, Elijah Has Come Already (1995)

Let us now read Stephen Flurry's article, Elijah Has Come Already: "And They Knew Him Not". This article first appeared in the July 1995 issue of PCG's recruitment magazine, The Philadelphia Trumpet. Here he insists that PCG is the only true church among the many COG splinter groups by insisting that only PCG believes that HWA is the "end-time Elijah." It was later made available as a reprint article.

Let us see what Stephen Flurry has to say.
There is no prophecy more fundamental and yet more misunderstood than that of the end-time Elijah. Traditional Christianity virtually rejects this prophecy. What’s more, many of God’s own people have now lost sight of this vital knowledge. (p. 1.)
Actually HWA's WCG concocted this doctrine of saying HWA was the end time Elijah. "Traditional Christianity" barely knows of this outlandish claim.

Stephen Flurry then asserts that the members of PCG are the Temple of God today and are far more glorious than the First Temple.

Stephen Flurry compares HWA to Zerubbabel calling him an "end-time Zerubbabel". He cites various sermons by HWA in his latter years and Mystery of the Ages (which PCG has since changed) to argue that HWA proclaimed himself to be the end time Elijah.

The fact HWA made many predictions which simply did not happen thus proving himself to be a false prophet is never mentioned. Inconvenient facts such as the false prophecy of 1975 are simply shunted away to the memory hole.
For those who purport to be following in Mr. Armstrong’s footsteps today while maintaining a collegial, collective or democratic type church government, doesn’t it seem strange to see how often Mr. Armstrong referred to the fact that God always works through one man at a time? (p. 4.)
PCG was and is in intense competition with the other COG groups. Why attend PCG when there are hundreds of other COG groups which also believe much of what HWA taught as well? Stephen Flurry condemns other COG groups by insisting that only PCG has retained the kind of "church government" practiced within HWA's WCG.

These words refer to the Global Church of God's promotion of collegial government and United Church of God's practice of collective government by letting the UCG ministers participate in various decisions collectively and even to vote on various issues. But these words ignore the fact that most COG groups in fact has one man rule like PCG, often because most COG groups are so small that such an arrangement is manageable.

Also ignored in Stephen Flurry's article is the fact that a major reason why the Tkach changes occurred is precisely because of HWA's one man rule over WCG. With Tkach having such power that HWA possessed there was nothing the rest of the ministry or the lay members within WCG could do to contradict the Tkach changes. GCG and UCG's changes to how they administered themselves were in part a pragmatic response to the fact that one man rule could allow the leader to change the religion so drastically.

After Stephen Flurry's article was written Meredith appears to have decided there was too much collegiality and in late 1998 he broke away from GCG and set up another splinter group, the Living Church of God, in order for him to have more power for himself and to possess more complete power.
It’s clear that Mr. Tkach, and every other leader in God’s Church for that matter, with the exception of the Philadelphia Church of God, does not believe Mr. Armstrong fulfilled the role of Elijah. But at one time, Mr. Tkach did believe it, as is evidenced by the above quotes. (p. 6.)
Stephen Flurry is trying to make his PCG more attractive than the other COG groups. Exploiting the fact that Roderick C. Meredith does not believe that HWA was the "end time Elijah" PCG then boasted this doctrine to insist that only PCG could be the true church. But in actual fact other COG groups also preach this doctrine.

Also considering that all the COG groups are heavily influenced by what HWA taught to varying degrees and interpretations what difference does it make to say whether HWA was the "end time Elijah" or not? Roderick C. Meredith calls HWA an Apostle thus equal to distinguished figures in the New Testament. What difference does it make whether HWA was the "end time Elijah" or not since both of them view him as an Apostle?

Rather this idea is used as a wedge by PCG's leaders to insist that only PCG is the true church in order to gain more converts.
The truth is that as early as 1979, church members began to hear on a regular basis that Mr. Armstrong was the one fulfilling these prophecies. (p. 6.)
There is the possibility this doctrine is even older. In a previous post it was mentioned that the idea was present within Armstrongism as early as 1966.

It should be noted that in 1979 there was severe turmoil within WCG. Just the year before HWA had expelled his own son. With so much uncertainty and turmoil in there it is little wonder that at that time HWA should promote such a doctrine as proclaiming himself to be the "end time Elijah" in order to prop up his authority in the face of widespread dissatisfaction within WCG at its authoritarianism and false teachings.  

This "prophecy" of an "end time Elijah" was concocted by HWA because he had the power to say whatever he wanted and any who would dare contradict him could be ever so easily expelled from WCG.
The word restitution means a time of restoring something that had been taken away. The Gesenius Lexicon defines it as a “restoration of true theocracy.” Restitution simply means restore! God’s theocratic form of government was once here on this earth until Lucifer took it away when he became Satan! God’s government will soon be restored to this earth. Jesus Christ will be the one who brings about that restoration at His Second Coming. (pp. 6-7.)
Stephen Flurry admits it: He and the PCG leadership are theocrats. (Is it like Iran?) And by claiming this theocratic authority for themselves the leaders of PCG are able to command obedience in so many ways from their followers such as paying three tithes or even forbidding them from meeting with close family members. Any deviation from such a theocratic leadership can be condemned as against (PCG's) God's will. The potential for abuse is astounding.
There had to be an end-time Elijah because God’s government had to be restored within the Church! The problems and evils of this world stem from the fact that nations simply do not want Christ to reign over them (Luke 19:14). God is soon going to send His Son back to establish His government. But that will not happen until other government positions are filled by those who have been thoroughly prepared for and taught under that government. (p. 7.)
PCG like the other COG groups, teaches that church members are destined to rule over the world as deified God beings as fully God as God is God during the Millennium.
For those who might still insist there is no possible way Mr. Armstrong could have fulfilled the prophesied role of Elijah, ask yourself: If he didn’t, who did? And if no one has yet fulfilled it, that means nothing has yet been restored! And that is exactly what Satan wants you to think! He wants you to deny that this prophecy has been fulfilled so he can lull you to sleep—thinking there must be many years, perhaps decades, before Christ could ever return. (p. 7.)
It is now twenty years since these words were written and still PCG members wait for Christ to return while PCG's leaders get the tithes and build an auditorium that cost more than PCG's yearly income. How many PCG members expected Christ to have returned by 2015 when this article was published in 1995?

Saying that not believing Stephen Flurry "is ... what Satan wants you to think" is crude fear mongering. He knows most of those who believe that God was with HWA nevertheless chooses not to join PCG. He is crudely trying to intimidate people into joining his group, namely PCG. Any view contrary to PCG's is demonized as of Satan.

There is this superstitious fear within Armstrongism that if one no longer believes what is taught by the COG group then he or she has been blinded by Satan and is under Satan's rule.
Why is it so many people today reject this fundamental teaching on the end-time Elijah? In the first century, John the Baptist came in the spirit and power of Elijah. Yet Christ plainly said, “they knew him not” .... And so it is today. (p. 7.)
HWA concocted this idea and foisted it upon WCG members in order to justify his power over his followers.

And so this polemic trying to exploit religious differences among the COGs to compel readers to join PCG comes to an end. And why does PCG want more members? To get more tithes money. That is the real point of making so much out of one particular idea.