Friday, May 8, 2015

Reading PCG's Booklet, Ezekiel: The End-Time Prophet

Let us now read Gerald Flurry's booklet, Ezekiel: The End-Time Prophet. This booklet superseded an earlier 1992 booklet by Gerald Flurry entitled The Ezekiel Watchman. This booklet was first printed in 2002. It has since been republished in 2004, 2007 and 2009. For this post I am reading through the 2004 version of this booklet. You can read the current 2009 version of this booklet on their website.


Among the topics explored in this reading of Ezekiel: The End-Time Prophet are:
  • Flurry obliquely proclaiming himself to be "That Prophet" (Chapter 3). More on that doctrine of PCG's may be seen here and here.
  • Flurry advocating HWA's deadly anti-medicine superstition (Chapters 6 and 11).
  • Flurry stating that he has banned makeup for female PCG members (Chapter 6, pp. 54-57).
  • Flurry apparently blaming women, specifically the ministers' wives, for causing the Tkach changes to occur (Chapter 6, pp. 54-57).
  • Flurry saying he has given up drinking alcohol (Chapter 10).
  • Flurry extolling showing no emotion upon the death of a loved one. "Nothing must get in the way of God’s work—not even mourning the loss of a loved one. We must put in check any emotion or anything else that holds up God’s work." (Chapter 10, p. 101.)
  • Flurry saying "God’s hand is directly guiding me today as well." (Chapter 10, p. 103.)
  • Flurry fantasizing about the members of the other COG groups (so-called "Laodiceans") wetting themselves. "They will be so scared, they will have urine running down their legs." (Chapter 10, p. 104.)
  • Flurry boasting about himself on proclaiming his "new revelation" that there will be no animal sacrifices during the Millennium (Chapter 14, pp. 139-141).
Let us begin.

Chapter 1

Parts of this chapter come from articles by Gerald Flurry written in the July-August 2001 issue of Royal Vision.
In a few short years, Ezekiel prophesied, the whole world shall come to know God! That is where everything is leading. This world is about to know God for the first time ever. ...

Before that happens to this world, God says His end-time very elect will send out a warning message. They will declare the book of Ezekiel in its entirety, and help lead the world to get to know the true, living God. There is nothing more thrilling than truly knowing God! God reveals Himself in Ezekiel. (p. 1.)
HWA and his imitators have been saying Christ will soon return continuously since the 1930s. It has still not come about as they said it would.

The vision of Ezekiel 1 is described in great detail in this chapter. Of course Gerald Flurry will later claim to reveal the true meaning behind the words of one allowed to see such a vision.

Accompanying this description is a picture on page 3 of what Ezekiel saw in the vision.

Royal Vision, July-August 2001.
Flurry then continues:
Has anyone else ever had such a vision? (p. 4.)
Although Flurry glorifies Ezekiel's vision it is actually to glorify Gerald Flurry since he claims to be the only man capable of properly understanding the Bible.
This is the God of the Bible. This is not little Lord Jesus in a manger, or Christ riding on a donkey. This is the God of Ezekiel and Revelation and the whole Bible! This is what He looks like and how He travels. How many people know this God? (p. 5.)
And thus we see Flurry belittling how Jesus Christ has been often portrayed by mainstream Christianity. This is part of indoctrinating the reader to be utterly alienated with mainstream Christianity so that he or she will be convinced into joining PCG (and paying its leaders three tithes).HWA taught that Jesus was to be never represented in an illustration.

After describing Ezekiel's vision Flurry asks the reader what he or she would do in Ezekiel's place?
If you were Ezekiel, wouldn’t you listen? I believe I would, if I saw a vision such as this. Well, we are, in fact, receiving a vision like this—though not directly as Ezekiel did. God is revealing Himself to us today in powerful, miraculous ways—even in this message you are reading. (p. 5.)
In other words reading this booklet is just as astonishing as what Ezekiel went through. Saying such boastful words will cause the unsuspecting reader to be mesmerized by what Flurry says in this booklet. When Flurry talks of the God Family dogma a reader in such an excited state will be most impressed. All that is done to make the reader feel compelled to make contact with PCG and join them. But when they join they will be told to pay three tithes to PCG for the rest of their lives.

Chapter 2
God is sending the Ezekiel message to the nations of Israel today through the Philadelphia Church of God! (p. 8.)
Well, I guess we can just stop right here and say this booklet is trying to get you to join PCG. Everything else in this booklet are merely details.
This message must be delivered when all these events are being fulfilled. Mr. Armstrong could not do much of this work because he died before many of these prophecies were fulfilled. (p. 8.)
HWA was a false prophet. HWA constantly insisted that catastrophe would soon occur at any minute now. And it never happened. This is not because he was off by a few years, but because they were never going to happen anyway.
I don’t believe there is a single instance in the Bible where God sent a prophet to say, hey, you’re all doing great! The fact that there is a prophet on the scene shows correction is necessary. That’s why God sends one—to warn. If a prophet has a message from God, you know there must be bad news in the short run. But every prophet of God brings wonderful news in the long run. (p. 8.)
Gerald Flurry insists that the message of the Book of Ezekiel actually only applies to himself, Gerald Flurry. This alludes to Gerald Flurry's claim to be 'That Prophet', a teaching which he unveiled to PCG members in 1999. More on this idolatrous doctrine may be seen here and here.
God promises to make us the toughest Christians on Earth! God will use us to deliver this difficult message, and He tells us in advance that Israel won’t hear it!
Gerald Flurry fear mongers that persecution will soon come upon PCG members. In fact Armstrongism has never had to endure such persecution ever since HWA started up his own group back in the 1930s.

Gerald Flurry fantasizes that once the Germans come and conquer America and turn Americans into slaves and that once this happens the captive Americans will remember what PCG taught them and convert to PCG's religion while in captivity. This is nonsense.
However, our message and their response is only stage one. It’s not the end result. Stage two brings the Great Tribulation, when many of God’s rebellious people and the nations of Israel repent. They will respond belatedly to the Philadelphia Church of God’s message.
This will never happen.
The emphasis here is not on preaching the gospel. The message of this book is also bitter —it is a message of lamentations and mourning and woe. Our message is very difficult to deliver. But it’s better to speak about lamentations, mourning and woe, than to experience it! And that is exactly what is going to happen to those who fail to heed this message! (p. 11.)
In other words, Don't any of you PCG members dare complain that PCG ministers are constantly claiming the world will fall apart at any moment. Clearly some in PCG are weary of the gloomy and dire proclamations of PCG's false prophets and here it would seem that Gerald Flurry is telling them they have no right to complain. This is an attempt to silence dissent within PCG.
You have access to that little book today! If you do not understand our teaching on this subject, write for our booklet The Little Book, and for a copy of Malachi’s Message. (p. 11.)
Since 1992 Gerald Flurry has taught that Malachi's Message is the Little Book of Revelation 10. Needless to say this doctrine is complete nonsense. It even contradicts what HWA said about the Little Book. HWA said the Little Book referred to his numerous visits to world leaders. But this inconvenient fact has since been thrown into the memory hole.

In the early days of PCG when it could not be foreseen that PCG would emerge as one of the main offshoot groups of Armstrongism those who joined PCG were discouraged and fearful.

PCG's leaders mainly used Malachi's Message in order to lure WCG members into PCG. But the 1% of PCG overcame their problems and established themselves as a major offshoot group for Armstrongism. Those who were of small stature in WCG were suddenly in charge. The adulation and authority given to HWA was now given to them.

To the 1% of PCG it must have seemed as though Malachi's Message had done this for them since they used it so often to lure in new members from WCG. To them it must have seemed as though Malachi's Message had the power of life itself. It gave them tithe paying members. No wonder they should have idolized it the way in the disgusting way that they have, namely by proclaiming it to be the Little Book of Revelation 10.

Actually it is widely known that many of the ideas within Malachi's Message were plagiarized from The Letter to Laodicea by Jules Dervaes, written December 1986-January 1988. It was sent to 237 WCG ministers including Gerald Flurry and John Amos. In fact on September 26, 1990 Jules Dervaes sent a letter to Gerald Flurry in which he denounces Malachi's Message as "a direct and clear plagiarism" of his work. 
The problem with the Laodiceans is they have forgotten who they are! They have forgotten that they’re the sons of the God of Ezekiel 1! That is why even Mr. Armstrong said to the members and ministers of God’s Church, “Most of you just don’t get it.” They wanted to follow the god of this world and still be in God’s Church. The powerful God of Ezekiel 1 would not tolerate that! (p. 12.)
This is referring to HWA's sermon for Pentecost in 1985. That sermon is not what Gerald Flurry portrays it as. Rather HWA was talking about why, in his view, it was necessary for some to become "firstfruits" and be resurrected at Christ's return while the vast majority needed to wait until after that. That is what HWA was talking about.

HWA did not have some divinely inspired premonition foreseeing the Tkach changes as Flurry so often insinuates.
If we fail to warn them about the consequences of these actions, God will hold us responsible for their blood! ... Who is giving God’s warning today? God help me if I don’t do it. These verses are talking about Mystery of the Ages (we have already mailed over 130,000 copies!) and Malachi’s Message, which represent our two commissions. (p. 16.)
So PCG mailed out over 130,000 copies of Mystery of the Ages between 1997 and 2004. Has PCG gained any great expansion in membership for it? Think about all the people who ordered it and did not join PCG. PCG's use of Mystery of the Ages failed to get those many people to join PCG. What inefficient efforts on PCG's part! PCG would have been better off not having Mystery of the Ages considering how few people have joined PCG because if it.
A court injunction temporarily stopped our mailing of this book. But God intervened and gave us the victory in that court case. (p. 17.)
PCG did not win the court case. Tkach's WCG won the court case however PCG essentially bought the copyrights from Tkach's WCG after paying the Man of Sin's organization $3 million. It is was not a victory, it was a purchase.

Chapter 3

Here Gerald Flurry insinuates he will be alive when Christ return.
This watchman is prophesied to be present when Germany rises to power and destroys the modern nations of Israel—unless they repent. The watchman is on the scene when it all happens. Herbert Armstrong fulfilled the watchman role in a general way, but there is a more specific fulfillment today for the PCG. (p. 20.)
This is complete nonsense. Gerald Flurry will simply die one day and others will run PCG in his stead.
Mr. Armstrong saw prophecies about the sword and the direction world events were moving. But did he actually see the sword coming? The answer is no; only we can fully see that happening today. (p. 24.)
This is nonsense. HWA most certainly saw a sword coming. But because he was merely a false prophet the sword never came.
Mr. Armstrong thought the end of Israel would occur in his lifetime. He was exactly right about the prophecies, but his timing was off a few years. God did not reveal to him many of the specifics of Ezekiel’s book. For example, Mr. Armstrong didn’t understand about the Laodicean Church era in these prophecies. Most of that truth was to be revealed after his death. (p. 24.)
This is also nonsense. HWA made many false prophecies. The fact that his words failed to be fulfilled prove HWA is a false prophet and that God was never with him.
There is a group of Philadelphians who “sigh and cry ... for all the abominations” (Ezekiel 9:4) and warn the Laodiceans and Israel. And there is also a sanctuary (temple or church) of God that God has to punish for not doing its job as a watchman (Ezekiel 33:5-6). Both of God’s end-time churches will be on the scene when Israel falls apart. One group will be protected, and the other will be punished in the Great Tribulation. (p. 25.)
Once again Gerald Flurry insists that only PCG members will escape the Great Tribulation.
One of the reasons the watchman warns the Laodiceans and the world is to save his own life! The PCG delivers this warning message, and God takes it to a place of safety during the Tribulation (Revelation 12:14). We are not bashing people. The purpose of our work is to save physical and spiritual lives! And God says the only way we can do that is to warn! Israel’s last watchman doesn’t come on the scene until the enemy is rising and getting prepared to attack Israel! (p. 26.)
Flurry threatens his readers that divine punishment will befall them if they do not do what he says and join PCG.
You have “delivered thy soul” if you deliver this warning message! This is how you save your life! It’s your ticket to a place of safety ! If you don’t support God’s warning to the Laodiceans and Israel, you will pay with your blood!

God says this watchman group will be there when the blood is spilled. That is why we must be protected by God. (p. 26.)
Here Flurry promises that those who give money to PCG will get to go the place of safety and escape the Great Tribulation.

Back in 1999 Gerald Flurry proclaimed himself to be That Prophet. (More on that declaration of his may be seen here and here.) In the quote below he is surprisingly blunt about claiming to be a Prophet and to be the only prophet in the entire world. Essentially he is saying that one can only know God through himself, Gerald Flurry.
When the Tribulation comes to pass, then they will know that a prophet was among them! Obviously, the prophet is on the scene when it comes to pass. The phrase “lo, it will come” is translated in the Soncino Commentary as, “Behold, it comes.” The Interlinear Bible reads, “Behold, it is coming.” Yes, it is coming. It is coming speedily! God warns us to either submit to His government now or learn a big part of that lesson by being conquered by the Nazis.

Verse 33 reveals that there is a modern-day Ezekiel watchman on the scene who is a watchman and a prophet. He prophesies about the sword coming. He says, “Behold, it is coming! ” Even Mr. Armstrong, though he was a watchman in a general way, did not specifically fulfill Ezekiel 33 because he could not see the sword as this man can today. This individual comes at the “last end.” He is called a prophet in Ezekiel 33:33 and a watchman in verse 7. He is termed a prophet in Ezekiel 2:5 and a watchman in Ezekiel 3:17. He comes to watch and prophesy. He is not here to restore all things. That has been done by Mr. Armstrong. The watchman is on the scene to warn the Laodiceans and the world of what is coming— behold, it is coming!

Who is this watchman—this prophet? Haven’t I given you revelation about Ezekiel and all the prophetic books? Almost every book and booklet I have written is filled with revealed prophecy. Has anyone else done that? Is revealed prophecy present in any of the Laodicean churches? Do they even have a smattering of the new revelation which God has rained down on His people through me? They have no new revelation.

How many true prophets are there on Earth today? Only one. People may scoff at that, but soon they won’t. When the Tribulation comes, they’ll remember a man who was out there with a powerful message that probably got him into some measure of trouble internationally . Then they will know who he was—after it is too late physically! (p. 28.)
Of course it is complete nonsense that Gerald Flurry is a Prophet, That Prophet or any other kind of true prophet.

Most of his prophecies are based on the dogma of British Israelism. As Silenced.co has shown British Israelism is built on a foundation of sand. In fact DNA evidence refutes British Israelism.

Gerald Flurry and his yes men said the Muslim Brotherhood would take over Egypt and turn it into a state like Iran. But Gerald Flurry's prophecy failed. The Muslim Brotherhood was overthrown and violently suppressed by the military in 2013 at the cost of at least 638 lives. Just recently former President Morsi has been sentenced to twenty years in jail. It is clearly seen that Gerald Flurry has no idea what will happen in the future.

Chapter 4

In this chapter Gerald Flurry fear mongers that African Americans will soon go on a rampage against white Americans. He had a chapter on this fear mongering topic in the original 1992 booklet which was published soon after the LA riots of 1992. Alas, to this day PCG's leaders say the same wild accusations and fear mongering against ethnic minorities whenever some riot should occur in an "Israelite" nation such as America or Britain.
It was the Rodney King court case, in which white policemen were acquitted of using excessive force in arresting a black man, that triggered the L.A. violence. In the last decade, there have been several more highly publicized cases of police acting against minorities, particularly in large cities like Los Angeles and New York. Serious rioting in Cincinnati, Ohio, and Bradford, England, in 2001 were also sparked by racial incidents. The public outcry has been intense and sustained. Now, as a result, the police fear to act, even more than they have feared to in the past. (p. 35.)
Since at least 1992 Gerald Flurry and his fellows have constantly exploited communal clashes to stir up fear that the end will soon occur. When the riots in London occurred in 2011 PCG's leaders said these same things again. Throughout the current crisis regarding police brutality PCG has constantly fear mongered that African Americans are on the verge of unleashing "race war" against the white majority in order to make PCG members fearful of the world so that they always stay in PCG despite its many problems.
We are told to “ prophesy against ” Israel. The Laodiceans have failed to do that. The PCG must not fail. (p. 38.)
Actually many of these "Laodiceans", the members of the other COG groups, also continue to insist that Germany will soon destroy America. Why does Flurry say untrue things?
The last third of Israel will be taken captive and made slaves around the world. In their captivity, these slaves will tell their captors about the prophecies of the PCG! The Gentiles will learn about God from their slaves! So we see that even Israel’s slavery will serve God’s work.

There is a big lesson Israel and the world must learn. “And they shall know that I am the Lord, and that I have not said in vain that I would do this evil unto them” (verse 10). The people of Israel will be punished. Then they shall know all the prophecies of Mr. Armstrong and the pcg were not in “vain”! These warning prophecies have been written and spoken because they were inspired by God. The words of Mr. Armstrong and the PCG are from the great God, who doesn’t speak words in vain! People either listen, or pay a terrifying price! (p. 39.)
This is all nonsense based on the false idea that only PCG speaks for God. PCG does not speak for God. This is nonsense. PCG speaks for themselves, not God.

Chapter 5

This chapter recites HWA's teaching that Ezekiel 28 reveals how Satan used to a cherub named Lucifer but he rebelled against God thus becoming Satan the Devil. This is an idea inherited from HWA.

Chapter 6

When Gerald Flurry was kicked out of WCG he started up another group, the Philadelphia Church of God. Now for decades WCG members had been told over and over again that God called them to join WCG and it was their duty to stay in it. Flurry needed more people to join his PCG and he had to argue against this deeply held idea that one must stay in WCG to be with God. So of course Flurry says that God has moved to be with Flurry in PCG and not Tkach in WCG.

As part of his bid to get more WCG members to join his PCG he wrote his various booklets and said things about them that HWA had never said. Flurry called this "new revelation" and proclaimed that it proved that God was with him and no one else, not Tkach in WCG or any of the other hundreds of COG groups that sprang up in response to the Tkach changes.
Where did God go when He left His sanctuary in this end time? He removed His lamp to another physical location where He then started revealing Ezekiel and other prophecies to the people who didn’t leave God spiritually— but who did leave the Laodicean Church along with Him! Who understands Ezekiel? Who has new revelation in books and booklets on all the major and minor prophets? We have these and other prophetic books that tell us what is happening today. That is where you will find God’s sanctuary. (p. 50.)
Once again Flurry appeals to the new doctrines he devised and insists that they are "new revelation" that "proves" that God is with PCG alone. This is also bid to claim the right to receive the three tithes from potential new members.
Anciently, 70 elders had meetings with God! The number 70 is God’s way of revealing that these end-time elders also had meetings with the true God! But then they betrayed Him and turned their backs on Him. God used this number 70 for a very special reason. He is telling us these are His own ministers going astray! It is a revealing sign!

God speaks in coded language. Then when the time is right, He breaks the code. God reveals all of His truth. We can’t discover it for ourselves (Amos 3:7). (p. 52.)
Ridiculous. Just because there are seventy elders in Exodus and seventy elders mentioned in Ezekiel they have absolutely nothing to do with WCG ministers accepting the Tkach changes. Flurry has just devised this idea himself.

Now onto the next topic.

One of the very worst things that HWA did was that he taught an anti-medicine superstition in which his followers were forbidden from taking medicines or "relying" on doctors to heal them.

Many WCG members died or had their health permanently compromised because of trying to follow this anti-medicine superstition. Considering the horrendous toll this doctrine of death imposed on WCG members it is little wonder that this was one of the very first doctrines changed by Tkach.

But Gerald Flurry proclaims that this doctrine is correct and continues to teach it. He even denounces this attempt to stop people dying and suffering as a sign of turning away from God.
One of the first doctrinal changes that came after Mr. Armstrong’s death was with the healing doctrine. Spiritually they were saying that God has forsaken the Earth. They couldn’t rely on God to heal them. Those men couldn’t see the God of Ezekiel 1! They had a monumental faith problem, and then afflicted the whole Church with it! Remember how it all started with weakened faith. Allow your faith to weaken, and that’s when Satan can really begin to work on you. (p. 53.)
The same horrendous results continues to predictably ensure in PCG. In 2006 Garth MacDonald died and it was reported that one reason for his death was his reluctance to take medicines because of HWA's anti-medicine superstition. Garth MacDonald's brother is Brad MacDonald, who has since emerged as one of the main leaders of PCG.

Now we enter another topic.

After this Gerald Flurry then launches a bizarre rant against women who fail to conform to his stereotype of the docile and submissive woman. Among other things he insinuates that such women helped to engineer the Tkach changes and lead people away from God, meaning away from PCG.

Here we see Flurry begin his bizarre rant against women.
These are God’s own women weeping for another god. The women of this world have always been following Tammuz or some false god. So this has to be God’s own Church! They are not happy with God and His religion. They want to follow the god of this world (2 Corinthians 4:4), and, like Eve, they are used by Satan to lead the weak men astray! (p. 54.)
Here Flurry is preemptively silencing any objections the women of PCG by insinuating that their complaints prove they are worldly and not in tune with PCG.
Less than a year and a half after writing that [in support of HWA's makeup ban], Mr. Tkach expressed drastically different views on the subject, and changed the ruling. Something radical must have been going on in the Church at the time for him to have had such a drastic, Habakkuk 1:11-like mind change. Again, in the 1970s, that was the issue that started everything on the wrong track.

You may think this is not a big issue. But look at the fruits! In retrospect, we can see that Satan was working on the women, just as he worked on Eve in the Garden of Eden. This is not unprecedented. Now, it is one thing to be weak in faith, and it is quite another to turn away from God! We have witnessed an Adam and Eve scenario all over again. And, just as it did in the 1970s, it has derailed the whole Church. (p. 55.)
It is complete nonsense to insinuate that allowing makeup led to the Tkach changes. The real problem is that HWA assumed to himself absolute authority and then passed this absolute authority to Tkach. This gave Tkach the ability to do whatever he wished to WCG. Those within WCG were powerless to stop him because of HWA's legacy of authoritarianism. Why scapegoat makeup? It was HWA's one man rule that opened the way for the Tkach changes.
This issue is really not about cosmetics—it’s about women weeping and wailing for another god! (p. 56.)
Meaning this is about cosmetics. It is about cosmetics. Once again Flurry plays the religion card to force women to not wear makeup and socially isolating them from mainstream society. This is make them socially dependent on PCG for their social life.
Satan repeatedly follows this pattern. This is the inner temple, where only true ministers are supposed to serve God, and yet we see some women are there having a wrong influence on God’s ministry! It is God’s way of saying women are having a sinful and damaging affect on the Laodicean ministry today! It’s the same trend that affects this world. It is terribly abominable because these leaders had the truth and are turning away from it! (pp. 56-57.)
This is just disgusting to vilify women in such a way. These words are garbage. They as loathsome as vomit.

We now carry on after that disgusting rant.
There are details in these scriptures that we must understand, or we won’t know how to handle these events. I prophesy that events will get even worse. As the work gets more exciting, our adversary gets more wrathful. We must know how to combat our enemy. (p. 58.)
Flurry has constantly said things will get worse. Thirteen years since this booklet was published we are still waiting for catastrophe to occur.
People say we are bashing the Laodiceans. Actually we are “sighing and crying” about the abominable doctrinal changes! Then we warn them, in love, about the great slaughter on the horizon unless they repent! It is the same slaughter Mr. Armstrong warned us about for over 50 years! God’s people are without excuse. (p. 59.)
Here Flurry is obliquely justifying his no contact policy against "Laodiceans", namely WCG members and members of the other COG groups. This policy requires PCG members to shun the members of WCG and the other COG splinter groups, even if they are close family members. This astoundingly draconian policy has inflicted the most frightful harm upon PCG members and those who love them. That policy appears to have been in force among PCG members since 2000, before the publication of this booklet.
These are the kinds of strong emotions in God’s people who “sigh and cry” because of the abominations committed in God’s Church, first of all, and secondarily in the nations of Israel. Only these people who sigh and cry receive a mark and are delivered to a place of safety. (p. 59.)
What Flurry really means is that only PCG members will go to the place of safety. Some wonder why PCG members stay in it despite the many problems there. Part of the reason is that they believe they will be cast into the Great Tribulation if they should ever leave PCG.
When the Laodiceans go into captivity, God will not leave them alone. ... God will be a little sanctuary to them. They are His Family, and He loves them and will be right there with them. ... Fifty percent of them will believe Him and come through it, dying in the faith and securing a place as part of Christ’s bride. ... At that point they will be childlike—submissive and teachable. (p. 65.)
Join PCG or die. Flurry is crudely threatening his readers that a most terrible fate await unless they join PCG. It is essentially blackmail.

On page 63 is a little insert article.
God’s spiritual temple—His obedient Church—is being measured. A great part of this occurred with the great falling away of the Laodicean era. When God measured, if any of us became ashamed, turned ourselves around and gave ourselves to God, He then put us in His inner court with the rest of His very elect. (p. 63.)
In other words Flurry has proclaimed that PCG members are the only true Christians in the entire world.
If God gives revelation, as He did here to Ezekiel, He wants the recipients to write it, publish it, so that all Israelites—physical and spiritual—have a chance to measure themselves by it—so they can keep God’s laws and ordinances. That includes following God’s government and sticking to all the doctrines of the Church. (p. 63.)
In other words, do whatever you are told to do by PCG.

Chapter 7

In this chapter Flurry uses a chapter of the Book of Ezekiel to say that the Tkach changes are like a wall which will soon be destroyed a great hurricane, namely the Great Tribulation which HWA and his imitators have been shrilly insisting will soon occur since the 1930s.
Those false ministers are daubing the wall with false doctrines. If you examine the wall carefully, you see how false and foolish the doctrinal wall is. This is not just speaking of the Worldwide Church of God. The other Laodicean churches have also rebelled against major doctrines of God. Their walls of doctrine appear to be strong, but examine them closely and you see they are like mere Hollywood props! (p. 70.)
Meaning, Don't listen to them. Listen to me.

Chapter 8
The marriage of Boaz and Ruth was a type of Christ’s marriage to the Church. “I spread my skirt over thee” also means that God protects His wife as any good husband should, if His wife is loyal. (p. 73.)
It is insisted that at any given time salvation can be lost in one fails to do what PCG commands. Some wonder why so many stay in PCG despite the many problems there. Partly it is because PCG members are afraid they will lose salvation if they leave or are kicked out of PCG. This is simply an induced phobia designed to keep people within PCG.
The Laodiceans have lost this marriage and Family of God concept because they are spiritually blind. This is the greatest mistake they or anyone on Earth can make today! ... We know that many of them will wake up before or during the Tribulation. But why must they be so rebellious that they allow Satan to turn them away from their most noble, majestic crown? (p. 78.)
In fact most of the other COG groups continue to teach the God Family dogma that HWA taught. Flurry is misleadingly insinuating that the other COG groups have done what Tkach's WCG have done.
The Laodicean children must go through the Great Tribulation—mainly because of their rebelling parents! What a horrifying penalty for God’s people who had the truth and rejected it! (p. 78.)
This is crude emotional blackmail. Here Flurry is threatening even the children of his readers with being cast into the Great Tribulation for not sending money to PCG and joining it. This is disgusting behavior.
Again, this warning to those in God’s Church is far more serious than any warning to the nations of Israel, because their salvation is at stake! His wife is taking “strangers” instead of her Husband. That is what all the doctrinal changes are about in the Laodicean churches! Christ says this is no “small matter”! He is condemning the end-time Laodiceans—His wife—who have left Him! That is their cardinal sin! (p. 79.)
While it is accurate to say that Tkach's WCG have changed many doctrines including the God Family dogma, these words do not accurately describe the other COG groups which have continued to teach many of HWA's doctrines including HWA's God Family dogma.
They have been given the highest calling in the Family of God! In God’s Family they will be on the wife level, while all the other saints will be on the children level! God will judge His wife according to her wedding covenant. That is judgment on the highest level! If only we can see what a fabulous, majestic calling God gives us today! (p. 81.)
This teaching has present in Armstrongism since at least 1957 as may be seen in a sermon by Richard David Armstrong. This idea that "the church" will constitute some sort of "elite" within the God Family for all eternity continues to be taught within the other COG groups such as LCG. PCG is not alone is promoting this elitist nonsense.
When we are married to Christ, what will our job be? “And it shall come to pass in that day, I will hear, saith the Lord, I will hear the heavens, and they shall hear the earth; And the earth shall hear the corn, and the wine, and the oil; and they shall hear Jezreel” (verses 21-22). God’s physical and spiritual laws will be in harmony. The heavens and Earth are here personified as needing each other’s cooperation. Everything in the heavens and Earth—the whole universe—is brought into harmony with God’s laws! This is the monumental work that Christ and His bride will direct for all eternity!

We are not getting ready to marry Christ so that we can pluck on harps forever! Our future job is of such magnitude only the mind of God can comprehend it! (p. 82.)
Flurry then insists that the Laodiceans will repent in the Great Tribulation.

This chapter ends with the following words.
The firstfruits must be preparing fervently now for their marriage to Christ. We must have the vision to see beyond the marriage. Our great work isn’t ending when we marry Christ—it’s just beginning! (p. 82.)
These words ended the original 1992 booklet, The Ezekiel Watchman. These words are a clear imitation of the ending of HWA's book, Mystery of the Ages.

Chapter 9
God says we must declare Israel’s abominations to them. We must prophesy about Israel’s abominable sins and the violent double-cross by the Germans! We must declare it! No other church can or will do so! The Laodiceans and Israel will fight against this message. Still, God says declare it! 
Many of the other COG groups also insist that the Germans are fated to soon conquer and enslave the American people. By saying only PCG can deliver this message is untrue. Why does Flurry say things that are not true?

Chapter 10
All of the Laodiceans are going to fall by the sword! There will be no escape for them!

Many Laodiceans scoff at us. They don’t believe God would send a prophet in our day. Their criticisms are worse than anyone’s from the world. The reason is that if you want to fight against the people who have God’s truth, about the only way you can do that is to demonize them and their leader. (p. 99.)
Thus any word spoken against PCG is demonized as just personal attacks. The reader is being told to ignore any information that might make him or her reconsider joining PCG. The reader is being trained to ignore any information PCG's leaders do not want him or her to know about.
Never forget: Things could end suddenly. I don’t know exactly what God’s time schedule is. I don’t know how much time we have left. I just want to make sure we keep God’s perspective, and never let some date or some land deter us from giving our all to God. We can never afford to let up in this work. (p. 100.)
Flurry keeps using fear to keep his followers fearful of being outside of PCG.
This job is a test of how much we love the people in the world. Are we willing to put our lives on the line for them? Do you love them enough to give yourself as a sacrifice to the great God of Ezekiel 1? To give Him your all, with no restrictions—nothing holding you back from Him, not even the death of a loved one? We must examine ourselves for areas where we may be holding back God’s work. 
Some of God’s people, for example, still drink too much alcohol. Yes, God sanctions and encourages the right use of alcohol. But I know that some people would be better off without it. I haven’t had a drink of alcohol in several years. Why? Because I feel I can be more effective in the work without it. Am I against alcohol? Of course not; I love to see people enjoy alcohol, as God instructs us. But if something is getting in your way, it is better to eliminate it. ... For some, that offense may be alcohol. (p. 100.)
This is clearly a response to the fact that Gerald Flurry got arrested in 1993 for being in control of a car while intoxicated with alcohol.
That is His message to us today. Don’t act like other men. Follow Ezekiel’s example. Nothing must get in the way of God’s work—not even mourning the loss of a loved one. We must put in check any emotion or anything else that holds up God’s work. (p. 101.)
This is inhuman. To take Ezekiel's example out of context to insinuate that human beings should deny their feelings of grief upon the death of a loved one is strange behavior. This is not good.

Here what happened upon the death of Ezekiel's wife is exploited to tell PCG members to keep emotions in check, even the loss of a loved upon death. It is talk like this that produces fanaticism. 

This is quite horrifying if one thinks about it thoroughly. The natural human emotions to grieve upon the death of a loved one is devalued, minimized and belittled in order to aggrandize devotion towards PCG. With talk like this it is no wonder so many people have had such bad experiences with PCG.
This is an opportunity we will never, ever have again! I believe if you asked all God’s saints throughout history to choose a single time to have been called by God, they all would choose the time just before the return of Christ! We have the greatest opportunity God will ever give to anyone, coupled with the best time to be called. (pp. 101-2.)
This assertion denigrates all the distinguished personages of the Old Testament and the New Testament. If today is the best time to be a part of "the true religion" (as defined by Gerald Flurry) then why listen to the Old Testament, the New Testament or even HWA? Ultimately only following Gerald Flurry matters if one accepted this assertion.

Why do PCG members even call themselves Christians if the events of today are so much more meaningful and important than what happened in Jesus' time? If this assertion is correct then it would mean that Herbert Armstrong and Gerald Flurry are far greater than all the personages in the Bible, even Jesus Christ Himself. 

Some wonder why so many PCG members stay there despite the many problems within it. Partly it is because PCG members are told by PCG's leaders that being in PCG means they are the elite of the world.
The Laodiceans have lost that stronghold. God is not going to protect them from the Great Tribulation. These are our Family members. God wants us to love them and to express that love through this work. Your dedication to this work shows your degree of love for the Laodiceans and the world. (p. 102.)
Here Flurry is obliquely justifying the no contact policy imposed against members of the other COG groups, who are demonized by Flurry as "Laodiceans". According to PCG Information this policy began to be enacted upon PCG members in 2000. It was restated again in 2005. This policy has inflicted much harm and strive upon PCG members. It is a most cruel and terrible punishment designed to intimidate PCG members and force them to be unfailingly loyal.
As I spoke of earlier, one Laodicean evangelist said that it was a mistake to think God directly guides His Church. Here is what Ezekiel wrote about that: “So the spirit lifted me up, and took me away, and I went in bitterness, in the heat of my spirit; but the hand of the Lord was strong upon me” (Ezekiel 3:14). God’s hand was strong upon Ezekiel; it was strong upon Mr. Armstrong. Anyone who restored all things had to have God’s hand strong upon him! It is pure vanity and arrogance for someone to push all that work aside and deny that God directly guides His leader and Church!

God’s hand is directly guiding me today as well. It must be, for us to fulfill this job. ... A man is doing that job. (For more information, write for our free booklet Who Is That Prophet?) (p. 103.)
Of course Gerald Flurry is referring to himself. In the 1999 PCG ministers conference Gerald Flurry proclaimed himself to be That Prophet citing Scriptures that are usually applied to Jesus Christ Himself. More on this idolatrous doctrine may be seen here and here.
They like to talk only about a God of love. They usually won’t even discuss the God that smites! They don’t want to know that God. Those Laodiceans and the world MUST hear this message! The arrogance will stop! “All hands shall be feeble, and all knees shall be weak as water” (verse 17). They will be so scared, they will have urine running down their legs. (p. 104.)
Once again Flurry shows us his sick imagination. Flurry has a sadistic imagination when talking about those he disapproves of.
In verse 22, God refers to His “secret place”—His holy of holies. It is there spoken of as being polluted by God’s people. But when we are loyally serving God, that “secret place” is a refuge for God’s people. God loves us and wants to invite us into the most special place in His life. Imagine the most majestic people on this Earth and multiply it by thousands, and that’s where we are in God’s mind. We are His special possession. (p. 104.)
Once again Flurry is claiming that PCG members will be the elite of the Earth, and even the elite of the God Family. Such extravagant flatteries cause PCG members to think that paying three tithes to PCG is no great sacrifice. It is only when they realize that God could not possibly with PCG that they see that the three tithes has been an exploitation they dearly wish they had not endured. 

Chapter 11
These people will hear the watchman message but won’t act on it until the Tribulation comes to pass—if they act on it at all! (p. 105.)
The reason the vast majority of people do not join PCG upon watching The Key of David or reading The Philadelphia Trumpet is because is it nonsense. Most people can tell it is just nonsense.
God revealed Israel’s modern identity to Herbert Armstrong, and that opened up one third of the Bible to his understanding—that third of the Bible which is prophecy. (p. 106.)
This is complete nonsense. HWA plagiarized the idea from British Israelism. HWA got the idea from other people. This is a clearly well documented fact.

PCG ministers and members can fantasize all they like that HWA got the idea of British Israelism just by reading the Bible but it is simply not the case. No amount of make believe will change this fact.
This means that none of the Laodiceans are doing God’s work of warning. The whole book of Ezekiel is about warning Israel of a coming nuclear attack and enslavement! But if you don’t know who the nations of Israel are, how can you warn them? God says in Ezekiel 2, 3 and 33 that if the people of Israel aren’t warned of the coming Tribulation, then their blood will be on the head of the watchman! That is a direct warning to all of the Laodiceans and the PCG! (p. 108.)
Once again Flurry is misleading insinuating that only his PCG is sending out this massage. In actual fact most of the Armstrongite COGs continue to passionately believe that a German led European Empire will soon conquer America and enslave the American people as slaves and take them away to Europe. It is simply not true that only PCG delivers this message of coming catastrophe. Why does Flurry say untrue things?
So many have come to the PCG from the lukewarm Laodicean churches and said, “I was starving spiritually.” The ministers can no longer detect and help cure spiritual disease! The people are perishing spiritually (p. 108).
Flurry often says this. But regardless of how new converts to PCG may feel or think PCG is still not the one true church. God is not with PCG.
Verse 4 continues, “... neither have ye healed that which was sick ....” The Laodiceans are not being healed because of a watered-down healing doctrine. Ministers have got - ten the people’s minds off faith. The WCG discontinued Mr. Armstrong’s healing booklet and replaced it with a very deceitful booklet with no focus on faith. The new booklet destroyed the faith of WCG members! It takes faith to be healed! (Write for Mr. Armstrong’s edition of The Plain Truth About Healing.) (p. 108.)
Many WCG members have suffered and even died because of HWA's anti-medicine superstition which he plagiarized from the Jehovah's Witnesses of the time. It is truly appalling that Flurry continues to promote this most dangerous doctrine of death.

It has even been reported that one Garth MacDonald died in 2006 because he refused to take medicine for a condition he had. His brother Brad MacDonald is now one of the main leaders of PCG.

Chapter 12
Later, when David was getting quite old, another son, Adonijah, rose up against him. This time Abiathar made the mistake of siding with the rebellion. Perhaps he believed David really had gotten too old for his job. The high priest turned on the king! For David, that betrayal must have been one of the most depressing moments of his life. (p. 114.)
Or maybe Flurry is projecting his own disappointments regarding the Tkach changes upon the Biblical events described.
All through that treachery, a noble group, the sons of Zadok, were loyal to God’s throne. Ezekiel 44:15 is talking specifically about the ministers, but it applies to all of us as we follow God’s loyal ministers. It began through me, strongly supported by John Amos. We weren’t men of stature in that church, but we clung to what Mr. Armstrong had taught! (p. 115.)
Here is an admission of the fact that Gerald Flurry was not particularly important within HWA's WCG.
We became sons of Zadok in the midst of that watershed event. That Church split was a special moment in our history, one that will ennoble us for all eternity—the greatest moment in our spiritual lives! Developing and displaying loyalty in the midst of that betrayal was really an act of qualifying for very prestigious positions. We must qualify to become an eternal son of Zadok! What a vision this is! This is a job God will give us for all eternity because we remained Philadelphian in the midst of the Laodicean rebellion. God is challenging us with this vision. Our eternal reward depends on the choices we make now, on a daily basis! (p. 116.)
Here Flurry is reinterpreting the WCG - PCG split as an act of faith towards God. Flurry talks as though only WCG and PCG exist and the other COG groups do not even exist. This misleadingly ignores the many other WCG members who left WCG to follow HWA's teachings outside of Tkach's WCG but did not join PCG.
Don’t ever let this vision slip—this is what makes you what you are. We must know who we are and how much Jesus Christ loves each one of us. Even in times of trial, we must recognize God’s love for us. Every trial will pay off in the long run. God is working in terms of preparing us for eternity! Don’t ever let Satan make you believe otherwise. God has a love we can’t even fathom. (pp. 118-119.)
And thus the reader will believe that any attempt to point out that PCG's dogmas are wrong will be viewed by the reader as a wicked attempt by Satan to wrench him or her away from the "true religion" (PCG).

The truth is many of PCG's dogmas are simply untrue. Most people who encounter them can clearly see this. But some people think they have discovered the truth and whenever someone tries to tell this to such a person he or she simply assumes that Satan is trying to stop them from entering the God Family.
It takes time, and God must put those pillars [PCG members] through some tests. But that is exactly how the Philadelphians are proving themselves today. They won’t be intimidated by a son of perdition or a whole church going astray! They will stay with God even if it gets them killed! (p. 119.)
And so with words like these the reader becomes convinced that anything preventing him or her from joining PCG or fitting in with them is of a supernatural test on the way to Godhood. Of course this is complete nonsense. A narcissistic delusion used to render people into loyal tithes payers.

Chapter 13
God always has a work that emanates from His headquarters. God gave beautiful headquarters buildings for the work under Mr. Armstrong. Mr. Armstrong built a house for God—Ambassador Auditorium. None of the other buildings at Pasadena headquarters remotely compared to that house.
God also gives the Philadelphia Church beautiful structures. Consider the effect God’s headquarters can have. God inspired us to do some beautiful landscaping around the PCG headquarters here in Edmond, Oklahoma. (We hope to move our headquarters to our 170 acres soon.) The landscaping has not only beautified the area around our building, but also those next to us. We were told that many tenants close to us were not happy with their business condominiums. They weren’t certain they wanted to stay until we rebuilt the pond and did our landscaping. Now all the tenants want to stay and help improve the complex. That is just one small example of how you can turn the minds of men in a positive way. (p. 123.)
Here Flurry is teaching his followers to be very attached towards what happens at their headquarters in Edmond.
No matter what men say, this is the great and only hope of mankind! (p. 124.)
The reader is being taught to ignore any information contrary to what Flurry says. This will make the reader very susceptible to whatever Flurry says.
This is a prophecy that we will proclaim Ezekiel’s temple to all the world. (p. 125.)
But PCG has completely failed to do so. PCG is a small group only composed of about 5000 members. They think they will soon become God beings fated to be the elite of the God Family for all eternity. While waiting for this future they throw away three tithes and vast amounts of money to PCG's leaders and those people get to live in luxury. This is how PCG can get about $19.5 million a year in income as was the case in 2012.
The expression “many mansions” should read “many offices.” God has many offices to fill in His Ezekiel temple. These same king-priests will later have offices in new Jerusalem!

I hope this destiny stirs us far more than anything else in our lives! The reward given to these pillar-priests, the highest-level offices in God’s Kingdom, is magnificent beyond words! (pp. 126-127.)
This is HWA's God Family heresy. It is nonsense.
It is easy to get bogged down in the present-day drudgery of this world. God has an unbelievably exalted goal for all of us. He wants to lift our thoughts out of this world into an illustrious future world that He will rule. Many people think it is just another fantasy. But they are wrong. Soon Christ will be here to bring peace, joy and abundance to this wretched world. (p. 127.)
"Many people think it is just another fantasy" because it is another fantasy. Both the Mormons and even the early Jehovah's Witnesses taught that one could become God beings in the afterlife. The God Family doctrine is a heresy that had long been taught by many other persons. HWA was not original with this idea.
Of course, there is great symbolism in all of this. God’s people must eat manna, or spiritual food, today. They must be ruled by the Ten Commandments, or the law. That means there has to be government based on the law—symbolized by Aaron’s rod. That government must always emanate from God’s throne. The ark of the covenant is all about God ruling man. God’s Church is His temple today (1 Corinthians 6:19; Ephesians 2:21). God is building His spiritual temple now—this very moment! (pp. 127-128.)
In other words one must always be loyal to PCG or else (PCG's) God will not be with you. This is manipulative nonsense designed to make people mentally dependent upon PCG.
We do God’s work through His Holy Spirit—typed by the bowl of oil—not by human ability. (p. 130.)
Here "human ability" is redefined to mean activity without PCG approval. Any field of activity outside of PCG's purview is belittled as worthless and without divine approval from PCG's God.
All of the Laodicean groups teach a government of man—not God’s government, which Mr. Armstrong taught. (p. 131.)
Here "government of man" actually means living outside of PCG's authority.
Everything in the temple revolves around God’s altar, just as the Church today revolves around God’s ministry—symbolized by the altar. God’s very elect today are being trained for a spectacular job in the Ezekiel temple. These saints are compared to pure gold in God’s present and future service. They will be on the highest king-priest level in the Millennium and throughout eternity. God wants us to deeply understand how highly He values our unswerving loyalty! (p. 132.)
This is part of why PCG members stay in it despite the many problems there. They think a great reward awaits them if they stay in PCG. So enduring the problems within it seems like a small sacrifice.
Notice the gold has “become” dim. The fine gold is changed. And God is discussing His sanctuary —His own Church and, specifically, the ministers who serve Him! They had God’s precious truth and now are losing it! They have changed from fine gold to dim gold. Thankfully, at this point, they are still gold. There is still hope! This is temple language that obviously applies to God’s own Church. Satan has deceived the ministers and then led most of God’s people astray. “The precious sons of Zion, comparable to fine gold, how are they esteemed as earthen pitchers, the work of the hands of the potter!” (verse 2). God likens the “precious sons of Zion” to fine gold. He is discussing His own ministers first of all. Of course, it applies to all of His people too. This same truth is covered in Malachi’s Message. (p. 133.)
What Flurry means is that he is disappointed that, aside from John Amos, not one WCG minister chose to join Flurry's banner and serve him within PCG.
God wants us to see the value He places on His own people! Do you see how precious you are to God if you remain His very golden elect? (p. 133.)
Flurry wants PCG members to think staying in PCG brings them God's favor. This makes it possible for PCG members to ignore and put up with the many problems within PCG.
Psalm 68 includes prophecy of God’s future world (p. 133).
It should be noted that PCG's recruitment program, now called The Key of David, was originally entitled God's Future World. It was later renamed The Key of David, which obliquely refers to the God Family dogma.

Flurry boasts that when Christ returns an earthquake will occur in Jerusalem that will drastically alter the topography of the landscape.
That dramatic event will alter the landscape where Ezekiel’s temple is to be built. This mountain is going to split in half. One half will move to the north and one half to the south. That will create a deep valley running east and west. The Mount of Olives will probably be a good deal higher than it is now. That miracle will immediately bury much of the filth in Jerusalem and will make our landscaping and building programs much easier. (p. 134.)
Flurry boasts that such dramatic changes to the topography of the area will occur merely to make it easier for glorified PCG members to rebuild Jerusalem in a manner they wish.

Chapter 14

In this chapter Flurry unveils a "new revelation" to impress PCG members and "prove" that God is only with PCG and no other church, Armstrongite or otherwise. Namely he here proclaims that there will be no animal sacrifices during the millennium.
Because of what is stated in Ezekiel 40 through 48, I thought for years that physical sacrifices would be offered in the Millennium. That is simply not true. Those sacrifices were to deal with carnal people only. Now God gives His Holy Spirit—after His Son was sacrificed—to make us perfect (Matthew 5:48). (p. 139.)
I wonder what other persons who lived within HWA's WCG would have to say on this topic. I will note that the topic of whether or not animal sacrifices would be offered during the Millenium was not often discussed.
I have never read or heard where any man taught that the sacrifices in Ezekiel 40-48 were spiritual. But God has revealed this truth to us now to expand the great vision of our future jobs. (p. 140.)
And so once again Flurry can claim to have "revealed" some sort of "new revelation". The real purpose of this "new revelation" is not to reveal said knowledge but to provide (inaccurate) evidence that God is with Gerald Flurry alone and to be a Christian is subtly redefined to mean being a PCG member.
When Christ stopped the physical sacrifices, it was forever. Now is the time for spiritual sacrifices forever! (p. 141.)
Once again this is Flurry trying to motivate his followers into being willing to go through any sacrifice on behalf of PCG. The PCG follower thinks he or she is pleasing God in this way but rather they are learning how to love being exploited by those who live off of the three tithes and extra financial gifts PCG members are strongly encouraged to give to PCG's leaders.
This gloriously bright Being is the real architect of the temple in Ezekiel’s prophecy! He is the royal author who has revealed this new truth about Ezekiel’s temple — the very subject you are reading about right now! (p. 144.)
Here Flurry is assuming to himself the authority of God and claiming to speak in His name. He is claiming that it is God who has "revealed" that there will be no animal sacrifices in the Millennium. In fact it is Gerald Flurry who has made this declaration.
Why would God take men like Josiah or Mr. Armstrong out of the way? (2 Thessalonians 2:7). It’s very simple. Today, God doesn’t want some exalted leader to carry the rest of us. God wants to see how many Josiah and Armstrong attitudes there are so He can see who the elite will be in Ezekiel’s temple. It’s almost time to start building the physical temple. God wants to know who will fill His world-ruling offices! (p. 145.)
Many WCG members expected HWA to remain with them until the return of Christ and then forever in the God Family. But HWA is a false prophet so of course these members found themselves to be bitterly disappointed.
We are living in a prophetic time when God is revealing our individual dedication. There are several churches of God in this end time, but only one is doing God’s work. Those saints who commit to Christ’s work are going to receive a fabulous job in Ezekiel’s temple. Soon the whole world will know who is who. It will be obvious by their work.

God plans to send us to other planets in the universe in the future. He sent Lucifer to planet Earth to administer His government. Lucifer rebelled and destroyed this Earth. God then saw He must recreate Himself (Genesis 1:26). Only His character can rule the Earth and universe. (p. 146.)
In other words Flurry claims that only PCG is the legitimate continuation of HWA's WCG. Even though both UCG and LCG and maybe even COGWA are able to command the loyalty of even more people than PCG Flurry insists only PCG is legitimate.

And Flurry has a strong financial motive to say this because if one should join PCG then he or she is required to pay three tithes to them and he lives off of the money sent to his organization.
God doesn’t look to evangelists and apostles — men of stature — to do His work. God looks to the very humble man who trembles at His Word. This is where God looks—where you will find His power and His work! (p. 148.)
Flurry loathes the fact that (aside from his assistant John Amos) no WCG minister chose to follow him into establishing PCG. This was because Flurry was only ordained in 1973 and was not of particular importance until he got fired by Tkach's WCG.
There will be “no end” to the growth and increase of God’s government. Endless growth! Perhaps God will continue to expand His Family. What God does with His Family beyond the Millennium will make even the Millennium seem dull by comparison! (p. 150.)
This is Flurry's attempt to get his readers "on a spiritual high". These words sound marvelous beyond words. But it is all based on the heretical nonsense of HWA's God Family dogma.
God has His people keep the Feast of Tabernacles each year to deeply etch this vision into our minds. We must be taught, retaught and taught again to learn this magnificent vision. That is the only way we will ever get it! Then, when Christ gets here, we will be ready to teach it to the world! (p. 151.)
PCG observes the Feast of Tabernacles in an unbiblical and illegitimate manner. HWA devised a completely non-biblical manner of observing it. Rather people were supposed to set up booths within their property and live in it to remember the wanderings of their ancestors. They did not drop everything to go to some place which could be far away and meet up with other Jews in some big eight day indoctrination convention. Rather they met up with their families and built tents within their houses.

The Armstrongites have been dreadfully fooled on this matter. Their perversion of the Feast of Tabernacles into an eight day indoctrination session shows the complete   

Flurry ends his booklet with these words.
Before God’s plan is complete, we will help Him teach many billions of people . This is no small concept. God keeps pounding this majestic message into our minds. We are temporary, but created to live forever in God’s Family. That is why we were created!
This is God’s most noble vision. It is beyond human understanding. Only God can reveal such a future to us. (p. 151.)
What Flurry really means is to accuse all of humanity outside of PCG of being cut off from God. He insists one may only approach God through his PCG. No where else.

Here "God's most noble vision" is subtly redefined to refer to PCG's teachings. But it is not from God. It is from Gerald Flurry, largely inherited from HWA.

Here "human understanding" is subtly redefined to mean any thought or idea contrary to what is taught by PCG. The reader is being told to not trust any person or any thought contrary to what PCG has taught.

And so we reach the end of Flurry's booklet.

This is yet another booklet designed to make the reader convinced that God is with Gerald Flurry and no one else in order to get the reader to join PCG. No mention is made in this booklet that the members are PCG are required to pay three tithes to PCG's leaders. It is with this teaching that PCG was able to enjoy an annual income of $19.5 million in 2012

Wednesday, May 6, 2015

UCG's Reliance on WorldNetDaily

Because the other major COG groups are so authoritarian and dysfunctional UCG has tended to be viewed the sensible COG group.

I have not focused much on UCG because during my experience as a believer in Armstrongism I had little to do with UCG. Because I was never interested in UCG when I believed in Armstrongism I am not interested in UCG now even as one who woke up about Armstrongism. 

But this reputation of being sensible seems to be somewhat exaggerated as, to my surprise, they seem to be even more dependent on WorldNetDaily for information than either LCG or even PCG. In one article UCG's leaders even called it "a leading Internet news site".

And just like PCG and LCG UCG's leaders have not one bad word to say about WorldNetDaily. They seem to trust WorldNetDaily.

WorldNetDaily is far to the right when it comes to politics. The only way one could be even more right wing than WorldNetDaily is to become an actual right wing extremist. They are not just some respectable news organization. It is a far right wing organization. They are very far to the right politically speaking. You would never know this reading what UCG's leaders say about them. UCG's leaders have not one bad word to say about them. This is also true for PCG's leaders and LCG's leaders.

It amazes me that UCG's leaders seem to have no suspicious about it. They have not one bad word to say about them. UCG's leaders seem to be mesmerized by them. If they have any suspicious about it they keep such feelings very well guarded.

Some of UCG's articles are interviews with an editor of WorldNetDaily, Joe Kovacs, talking about his two books, Shocked by the Bible (2008) and The Divine Secret (2012), which actually perpetuate many of HWA's teachings. Banned by HWA reported on this fact.

The other COGs constantly compete with each other to get more tithes paying members. PCG even shuns the members of the other COG groups, demonizing them as "Laodiceans". But they all seem to get their news from the same far right organization, WorldNetDaily.

There are actually more quotations of UCG's leaders quoting WorldNetDaily but I have chosen to ignore articles made by affiliate blogs (san-jose.ucg, bible.ucg, etc.,) and focus on their main website.

Below is a collection of quotes from UCG quoting various WorldNetDaily articles. They do not express the slightest skepticism or weariness about what they quote from WorldNetDaily. This is also true for LCG and PCG.

***

(2000 WorldNetDaily.com; PRNewswire; The Guardian; The Observer; Washington Post Service; “Stem Cell Research,” by Mona Charen, August 28, 2000, Creators Syndicate, Inc.) (Cecil Maranville and John Ross Schroeder, In Brief... Abortion in the News on Several Fronts, October 20, 2000.)

Arabs are understandably jealous over the amount of water possessed and used by Israel. Israel's per capita daily use of water is about 66 gallons. In Syria, the average citizen uses 50 gallons of water per day. In Lebanon, the rate is 41 gallons per day in contrast to Jordan, where the average citizen uses 25 gallons every day. In stark contrast is the consumption rate of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza, where the people manage on only 20 gallons per capita per day-and their water is heavily polluted with nitrates. Sources: WorldTribune.com; WorldNetDaily.com, Inc.; Time, Inc. (Cecil Maranville, In Brief... Middle East: War Exercises and Water, February 1, 2001.)

Sources: Stratfor, WorldNetDaily, AP. (Cecil Maranville, Jim Tuck, John Foster and Ken Martin, In Brief... Saudi Crown Prince Cautions Islamic Leaders, January 1, 2002.)

Joseph Farah, who is the founder of WorldNetDaily.com and former editor of The Sacramento Union, espouses a totally different view about intimate same-sex relationships. He wrote in The Washington Times : “You see where the brave new world is heading. When the church abandons its tenets, when it refuses to recognize sin, when it glorifies immorality, when it compromises on the Word of God, when it becomes a tool of political correctness, it becomes a tool of evil. It becomes an abomination” (Weekly Edition, June 30-July 6, 2003). (John Ross Schroeder, Controversies Concerning Homosexuality Hound the Anglican Community, August 4, 2003.)

[The Washington Times is closely associated with a controversial religious group. How appropriate. - Redfox712.]

However, not “everybody” feels it's a good idea. Joseph Farah [editor of WorldNetDaily] comments: “I don't believe this would be happening now without the U.S. Supreme Court decision invalidating the anti-sodomy law in Texas. Now the homosexual activists are working at a fever pitch to transform Western civilization. Indoctrinating the next generation is an important step in that process… “Do you see where our culture is headed? Do you now understand what Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia was warning about in his dissent in the Texas sodomy case?” (Cecil Maranville and Jim Tuck, In Brief...World News Review: New York City Establishes Gay High School, August 6, 2003.)

But, for the most part, we have lost sight of what’s right and wrong. “As a signatory of the Convention on the Rights of the Child, Canada is obligated to make periodic appearances before the U.N.’s Committee on Rights of the Child, which said the country should ‘adopt legislation to remove the existing authorization of the use of “reasonable force” in disciplining children,’” the National Post reported (Oct. 9, 2003, WorldNetDaily.com). (Jean Jantzen, Does God Believe in Tough Love?, August 3, 2004.)

The study revealed that “a quarter of teen girls who said they were sexually active also said they had been depressed ‘a lot of the time' or ‘most of the time.'” In contrast, most who refrained from sexual activity were “never” or “rarely” depressed. Researchers concluded that “sexually active teens are far more likely to be depressed … than those who hold off until marriage” (WorldNetDaily.com). (Jerold Aust and John Ross Schroeder, World News and Trends: Teenage sex linked with serious depression, August 15, 2003.)

[I have no idea if the above quote is true. But I would never rely on WorldNetDaily to confirm such an assertion as is done above. -Redfox712.]

World Net Daily published a report saying that Iran will have nuclear weapons by 2008, indicating that international inspections have delayed the nation's nuclear capability by two years. The report "suggested that Israel may conduct an attack on Iran's nuclear facility to prevent Tehran from attaining a nuclear weapon" (July 30). (Jerold Aust and John Ross Schroeder, World News and Trends: Growing evidence of Iran's hostile intentions, October 15, 2004.)

[Ten years later we are still waiting for Iran to build a nuclear weapon. It is almost as though they actually do not want one. It has been reported that Iran's Supreme Leader made a fatwa in 2003 condemning nuclear weapons as unislamic. UCG's leaders might have to wait a long time for Iran to get nuclear weapons. - Redfox712.]

In this new translation, sex is a given, but marriage is optional, and so is the partner's gender! According to the “One” organization that produced the new Bible, it is dedicated to challenging “oppression, injustice, exclusion and discrimination” as well as accepting one another and “valuing their diversity and experience” (World Net Daily , June 24, 2004). But instead, they are changing the fundamental teachings of the Bible. (James Capo, In the News: Trashing the Truth: New Bible Translation Promotes Sin, December 4, 2004.)

“Dear Nordstrom,” she wrote, “I am an eleven-year-old girl who has tried shopping at your store for clothes (in particular jeans), but all of them ride way under my hips, and the next size up is too big and falls down.
“I see all of these girls who walk around with pants that show their belly button and underwear,” she continued. “Your clerks suggest that there is only one look. If that is true, then girls are supposed to walk around half naked. I think that you should change that” (http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=38605 ). (James Capo, In the News: A Return to Modesty?, December 7, 2004.)

Also according to a report in World Net Daily, the Palestinian Authority continues to urge genocide against Israelis. One specific directive was: “Use TV broadcasts to urge killing of “brothers of the monkeys and pigs' …” (Sept. 16). This implies much more than mere distasteful rhetoric. (Jerold Aust and John Ross Schroeder, World News and Trends: Does Israel have the right to exist?, December 9, 2004.)

(Sources: Forbes ASAP, Associated Press, Reuters, WorldNetDaily.) (Jerold Aust and John Ross Schroeder, World News and Trends: United States faces growing threat from 'nuts with nukes', April 13, 2005.)

A variation of this theory appeared on WorldNetDaily, suggesting that the viral exchange may take place on a somewhat different level. “In southern provinces of China, farmers raise hens, ducks, pigs and fish in one integrated system. They use the droppings and leftover food from the pigs to feed the fowl. The fowl droppings, in turn, help fertilize the fish ponds. While it sounds like a perfect system, raising three different species with no waste, the species may be exchanging viruses among themselves through the feces”... . (Scott Ashley, Lessons From the SARS Epidemic, May 3, 2005.)

(Sources: International Herald Tribune, Newsweek, MSNBC, WorldNetDaily .) (World News and Trends: Gaza's Uncertain Future, December 2, 2005.)

“Heightened alert comes in the wake of reports that Iranian crackpot president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad met with Hezbollah leaders in Syria earlier this year” (Michelle Malkin, “Hezbollah Is Here,” WorldNetDaily, July 19, 2006). (In Brief... World News Review: What Harm Could Iran Do?, February 8, 2007.)

(Sources: Associated Press, Cybercast News Service, WorldNetDaily, ACLU Web site.) (Jerold Aust and John Ross Schroeder, World News and Trends: California court approves gay marriage--what does it mean?, August 3, 2008.)

An article on WorldNetDaily.com concerning author David Flynn's latest book begins with the question: “Was the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem more than a place of worship?” Expanding upon this thought-provoking question, the August 14, 2008 article continues, “Was it, indeed, a roadmap to future events—a kind of prophetic landmark whose significance is only now revealed through the development of satellite imagery? “That is the contention of an explosive new book 'Temple at the Center of Time: Newton's Codex Deciphered and the Year 2012,' by David Flynn, a book that has risen dramatically to No. 1 among unexplained mysteries, No. 1 in world history and 73 overall on Amazon.com. The book asserts it has 'deciphered Isaac Newton's greatest paradox: None other than “the unified field theory” of Bible prophecy.'” (Randy Stiver, Temple at the Center of Time: Fact or Fiction?, September 4, 2008.)

In his new book Shocked by the Bible Kovacs, currently executive news editor for WorldNetDaily.com, questions everything people think they know about the Bible. (Mike Bennett, Shocked by the Bible?, November 23, 2008.)

[Kovacs's books, Shocked by the Bible (2008) and The Divine Secret (2012), have been denounced by The Berean Call as Armstrongism. Those books teach many of HWA's teachings. Banned by HWA reported on this fact. - Redfox712.]

Journalist Joe Kovacs has written for broadcast, print and online media for more than 25 years, receiving awards for excellence in news coverage from both the Associated Press and United Press International news services. Mr. Kovacs has been executive news editor for WorldNetDaily, a leading Internet news site, since 1999. His strong interest in the Bible led him to write the recent best seller Shocked by the Bible: The Most Astonishing Facts You've Never Been Told. The book documents many surprising facts regarding common beliefs that are and are not supported by Scripture. (Jerold Aust, Shocked by the Bible, March 24, 2010.)

[Kovacs's books, Shocked by the Bible (2008) and The Divine Secret (2012), have been denounced by The Berean Call as Armstrongism. Those books teach many of HWA's teachings. Banned by HWA reported on this fact. - Redfox712.] 

To most religious-minded people, the unvarnished facts of the Bible can indeed be shocking. One person who was shocked was Joe Kovacs, executive news editor of WorldNetDaily. An interview with him appears in this issue, see Shocked by the Bible. Kovacs has written a book titled Shocked by the Bible, in which he offers his readers some interesting Bible facts. (Jerold Aust, Shocked by the Bible, Changed by the Truth, March 25, 2010.)

[Kovacs's books, Shocked by the Bible (2008) and The Divine Secret (2012), have been denounced by The Berean Call as Armstrongism. Those books teach many of HWA's teachings. Banned by HWA reported on this fact. - Redfox712.] 

The Canadian press has taken an interest in the lost tribes of Israel—at least in a group that some think is one of the tribes. An unusual community of 1.5 million Jews living on the India-Burma border has captured the attention of some influential people. WorldNet Daily has picked up the story. (Cecil Maranville, David Palmer, John Ross Schroeder and Mario Seiglie, In Brief...World News Review: Lost Tribe of Israel?, July 22, 2010.)

[British Israelism is complete nonsense. Silenced.co has shown that British Israelism is built on a foundation of sand. In fact DNA evidence refutes British Israelism. - Redfox712.] 

Best-selling author and award-winning journalist Joe Kovacs, executive news editor at WorldNetDaily, has recently written a new book, The Divine Secret: The Awesome and Untold Truth About Your Phenomenal Destiny. This insightful new book documents little-understood truths from the Bible that few are aware of but that everyone needs to know. (Jerold Aust, The Divine Secret, September 6, 2012.)

[Kovacs's books, Shocked by the Bible (2008) and The Divine Secret (2012), have been denounced by The Berean Call as Armstrongism. Those books teach many of HWA's teachings. Banned by HWA reported on this fact. - Redfox712.] 

Joe Kovacs of WorldNetDaily published a very supportive report on August 29 with his article, “Glenn Beck: U.S. Identified in Bible.” His article began: “Radio and television host Glenn Beck is now going public with his belief the United States is among the famous “Lost 10 Tribes of Israel,” and America today is suffering calamities just as ancient Israel did due to its disobedience to the laws of God.” The WND article is at http://www.wnd.com/2013/08/glenn-beck-u-s-is-lost-tribe-of-israel/. (Don Hooser, The 7 Reasons - no, 8 Reasons - America Became a Great Power, April 2, 2014.)

[British Israelism is complete nonsense. Silenced.co has shown that British Israelism is built on a foundation of sand. In fact DNA evidence refutes British Israelism. - Redfox712.]

Joseph Farah, editor in chief of WND (the former WorldNetDaily), commented prior to the caliphate announcement: "Do I expect to see ISIS conquer the Middle East, North Africa, part of Europe and Asia in the 21st century? No, I don't. But I do expect to see enormous carnage and destruction and bloodshed as a result of this movement—far more, perhaps, than most other analysts project. There is a ferocity to ISIS that makes even al-Qaida uncomfortable. It has already captured more wealth and armaments, including chemical weapons, than all but a handful of countries in the world possess . . .
"Brutality difficult for Westerners to even imagine is the modus operandi of ISIS. It calls for a scorched-earth policy against its enemies—which includes Christians, Shiites, Alawites, Jews, non-believers and all non-Sunnis. ISIS leadership advocates and practices barbarism designed to strike fear into the hearts and minds of its opponents and anyone who doesn't stand with them in their strict Shariah Sunni code.
"Already the ISIS marauders have crucified victims, beheaded them and conducted mass executions of Iraqi soldiers and civilians. No atrocity is beneath them" ("ISIS Rising—What It Portends," June 23, 2014).
Farah compares the speed of their conquest with the original march of Islam and even Alexander the Great. "The success of campaigns like that requires that superior forces faint in fear of the coming hordes. You can see it's working already in Iraq" (ibid.). (Tom Robinson, Islamic Caliphate Declared: What Does It Mean?, August 27, 2014.)

Regarding a more recent incident, WND.com (formerly WorldNetDaily) editor in chief Joseph Farah writes: “For a moment, forget 'same-sex marriage.' Forget the fact that so many television shows and movies feature sympathetic 'gay' characters … Forget that 'homophobic' is the new 'racist' slur. Think about … the headlines that a sports figure gets simply by coming out of the 'gay' closet.

“Today, when a 'gay' NFL [National Football League] draftee kisses his same-sex partner [on TV], he is congratulated by the president of the United States. That's what happened last week [in May] when Michael Sam became the first openly gay player drafted to the NFL … When other athletes pointed out the gratuitousness and impropriety of the moment, they were vilified —not just by 'gay' activists, but by the sports media” (“How Far the 'Gay' Revolution Has Come,” May 18, 2014, emphasis added throughout). ...

“Remember,” Farah asks, “when the rhetoric of the 'gay rights' movement was, 'What I do in the privacy of my own bedroom is nobody else's business'? Today … the 'gay revolution' … has done a 180 and now believes what people do in the privacy of their own bedroom is everyone's business. It must be considered a heroic act when a homosexual tells the world what he or she is. Dissenters are punished. It was always cool to be an athlete. But now it is especially cool to be a 'gay' athlete.” (Tom Robinson, Government and the Gay Agenda, October 31, 2014.)

Over these same decades, morality has plummeted throughout the world and in the United States. Commentator Mychal Massie remarks: “They took away 'thou shalt not kill' and 'honor thy father and mother' and replaced it with school shootings, abortion and homosexual sensitivity. With God out of schools, school crime has increased 700 percent, but I'm sure that's just a coincidence” (“God, Not Crime, Barred From Schools,” WND.com, August 4, 2014). (Tom Robinson, America's War on God, October 31, 2014.)

***

It is concerning to see UCG's leaders have taken such a source as though it were gospel. No good can come from this.

It is surprising to me to note that UCG seems to quote from WorldNetDaily even more than LCG or PCG. I more quotes from UCG than from those other major COG groups. This list does not even have all of their quotes. I have ignored some quotes from affiliate blogs instead choosing to focus on UCG's main website.

People deserve to know that UCG uses WorldNetDaily in this way.

Monday, May 4, 2015

LCG's Reliance on WorldNetDaily

It is not just PCG that uses WorldNetDaily to convince people about what they say. LCG uses WorldNetDaily in this way as well.

Just like PCG LCG's leaders also have not a single bad word about WorldNetDaily. Whatever is quoted from them is treated as an incontestable fact. One relying on LCG's writings would never know that WorldNetDaily actually has a bit of a bad reputation.

It is amazing for me to have to note that LCG's leaders seem to trust WorldNetDaily. Not once do they say maybe WorldNetDaily might just have made a mistake about what they have said.

It is sad that LCG's leaders trust such a controversial group to inform their followers.

Below is a list of quotes from LCG's writings which quote WorldNetDaily. The first one is from 1999, less then a year after LCG's founding. Roderick C. Meredith, Douglas Winnail and Jeffrey Hall quote WorldNetDaily, but other articles are written anonymously. In all of these articles there is not one critical word for WorldNetDaily. Whenever they quote WorldNetDaily they seem to just take it at face value. There is no hint of skepticism about what WorldNetDaily says from LCG's leaders. LCG's leaders seem to trust WorldNetDaily.

Some quotes are from lcg.org. Others are from tomorrowsworld.org.  

***

One analyst believes the next major war will be based on "strategic positioning, aerospace, and the ability to protect maritime assets" which are the focus of China's current policies (WorldNetDaily.com, 1999). (Douglas S. Winnail, Sea Gates in Peril, July-September 1999.)

The story of Protestant decline is the same in America and other countries. At a recent conference of the Presbyterian church, liberals' attempts to ordain practicing homosexuals and question whether belief in Jesus Christ is necessary for salvation (see John 14:6; Acts 4:12) sent shockwaves through a denomination long considered a bastion of conservative Christian theology. One delegate commented that "the homosexual and christological debates have diminished the church's ability to minister" (2001, WorldNetDaily.com). (Douglas S. Winnail, Significant Religious Trends, November-December 2001.)

Homosexual political lobbies want same-sex relationships recognized as the legal equivalent of heterosexual marriage. Laws pending in Sweden and Canada would make any negative reference to homosexuality a crime (WorldNetDaily, Oct. 21, 2002). (Douglas S. Winnail, Sodom Rises Again!, March-April 2003.)

An article in WorldNetDaily reported: "In addition to being bound by state statutes to promote homosexuality in its 'diversity and "safety' programs, schools face the threat of lawsuits by groups such as the Gay Lesbian and Straight Education Network." ... In the huge Los Angeles school district, according to the same WorldNetDaily article: "Instructions on homosexual sodomy and a glorified account of lesbian pedophilia are among the instructional materials approved...for use in 'diversity' and 'safety' programs being presented to elementary through high school students." ...

One might think that the pace of change in Israel, which is the birthplace of Old Testament scriptures, would lag way behind the rest of the world. Not so! In a WorldNetDaily article, it was reported that "the Tel Aviv city council approved a measure to recognize unmarried homosexual (and) lesbian… couples as family units and grant them the same discounts for municipal services that married heterosexual couples receive." (Jeffrey Hall, The 'Evolution' of Society, January 6, 2005.)

According to the World Net Daily: "The Muslim Brotherhood which is said to have aided the Palestinians in their cause have a slogan: "The Koran is our constitution, the prophet is our guide; Death for the glory of Allah is our greatest ambition." (Jeffrey Hall, A Cup of Trembling, January 6, 2005.)

Also, China is gaining increasing nuclear capability. China is the largest nation on earth in terms of population and, increasingly, is competing with the United States and the western nations in world trade and world influence. Following is a significant quote from WorldNetDaily.com, last March 19: "Here’s one that tops the Dubai Ports World deal—but, so far, no one is complaining. U.S. taxpayers are lending Westinghouse Electric Co. almost $5 billion to build nuclear power plants in China—even though the company, based in Pennsylvania, is about to be sold to Japan’s Toshiba Corp., and even though the company is currently owned by British Nuclear Fuels Ltd. And, so far, no one in the U.S. government is showing any interest in scrutinizing the sale over the transfer of nuclear-power technology— or in halting the loan from the Export-Import Bank." (Roderick C. Meredith, Do You "See" God in Current Events?, May-June 2006.)

This idea is not new and has proponents around the world (World Net Daily, August 22, 2008). (Everyone doing what is right in their own eyes…, September 3, 2008.)

One town newspaper was contacted ahead of time and provided a reporter, but chose not to notify the church of the demonstration. Members of the gay activist group marched down aisles shouting profanities. They pushed and shoved church members in an attempt to get them to “push back.” The demonstration quickly broke up when the sheriff arrived. A statement on Bash Back’s website read, after the event, “Let it be known: So long as bigots kill us in the streets, this pack of wolves will continue to BASH BACK!” (WorldNetDaily.com, November 11, 2008). (Homosexual Rampage at Michigan Church, November 17, 2008.)

A spokesperson for the law firm that will represent the pastor and his wife commented, "[we are] troubled by this draconian move to suppress home Bible studies… If the current trends in our nation continue, churches may be forced underground. If that happens, believers will once again be forced to meet in homes. If homes are already closed by the government to assembly and worship, where then will Christians meet? I'm deeply concerned that if in the US we are not able to meet in our homes and freely practice our religion, then we may be worse off than China" (WorldNetDaily.com, May 22, 2009; FoxNews.com, May 28, 2009). (Scott D. Winnail, Is a Famine of the Word on the Horizon?, June 11, 2009.)

The Apostle Paul warned that in the last days, society will become increasingly evil by rejecting God’s ways and favoring their own lusts (2 Timothy 3:1-5). This prophecy and many similar ones are now coming true… and sadly, our children will reap the consequences (WorldNetDaily, January 29, 2013). (What's Ahead for the Boy Scouts?, February 20, 2013.)

In a recent interview, a former PLO operative who has since renounced his terrorist ways, reported on a recent celebration at an Egyptian wedding, where “a group of men in a frenzy tear apart a live chicken by hand, then scrabble over its pieces to eat its raw flesh” (WorldNetDaily, April 22, 2013). Walid Shoebet (the interviewee) suggested the behaviour at the wedding “demonstrates the ‘demonic’ spirit that has gripped the nation since its 2011 Islamic revolution” (ibid.). Many are starting to long for a strong ruler who will again enforce the law as Hosni Mubarak did, and bring back a time when “no one dared to do such things” (ibid.). (A Perverse Spirit in Egypt, May 6, 2013.)

[Note: Walid Shoebat is part of the Islamophobia Network and many people are very skeptical about his story of being a terrorist.]

“A federal judge has backed a homosexual-rights group [from Uganda] in its claim that members were injured by an American pastor’s biblical preaching in Uganda against homosexual behavior” (WorldNetDaily, August 15, 2013). Should this type of lawsuit be recognized in the U.S., virtually anyone opposing legislation that supports homosexual rights could be jailed for crimes against humanity (ibid.). (Upside-down Justice, August 20, 2013.)

According to a quietly revealed U.S. plan, the Vatican and an international coalition would control some of Jerusalem’s most holy sites (WorldNetDaily, December 15, 2013). “The exact composition of the international mandate is up for discussion… but [U.S. Secretary of State] Kerry’s plan recommended a coalition that includes the Vatican, together with a group of Muslim countries such as Turkey and Saudi Arabia” (ibid.). (Vatican to Control Jerusalem’s Holy Sites? , December 20, 2013.)

***

It is concerning to see LCG's leaders have taken such a source as though it were gospel. No good can come from this.

People deserve to know that LCG uses WorldNetDaily in this way.

Mosque Vandalized in PCG's Hometown, Edmond, Last Month

PCG's leaders seem to think that Islamophobia does not exist. We are assured by them that bigotry against Muslims is not a problem. If anything they tend to portray Muslims in a very horrible manner.

But right in PCG's hometown this hateful act happens.

The following news report is from KFOR (April 13, 2015).
EDMOND, Okla. – Before Sunday prayer service, raw bacon was discovered by a child at a local mosque.
“I always felt safe here. I always felt it was a comfortable place to go,” Adam Soltani, CAIR executive director, said.
On Sunday, vandals tossed bacon along the doorway of an Edmond mosque near the University of Central Oklahoma.
“Someone would have to know that according to the Islamic faith, pork is not allowed for Muslims to eat, so it sends a message that they know that and that they want to offend,” said Soltani.
Students are shocked to see this happen in their community.
It’s really disgusting, actually. I just don’t understand why people would do that,” Erick Larson, a student at the University of Central Oklahoma, said. (Source.)
(Hat tip: Loonwatch.)

It is impossible at present to know who was behind this act of hate. Anti-Muslim bigotry is present outside of PCG. So it is entirely possible, even probable considering how few there are in PCG, that the hate filled person or persons responsible for this had nothing to do with PCG.

Let us remember again the absurd assurance from PCG's leaders that anti-Muslim bigotry is not a problem. The following two quotes are adapted from a previous post.

Here Joel Hilliker condemns attempts by British leaders to calm down social tensions after the July 7, 2005 bombings in London.
Though the malignancy of radical Islamism is spreading in many non-Muslim nations—throughout Europe, North America and Southeast Asia in particular—in Britain the problem is uniquely bad. For its pathetic response to the incursion of militant Islam, commentator Daniel Pipes calls it the “weakest link in the Western chain.”
Official response to the July 7, 2005, terrorist attack in London provided a perfect cat scan of the advanced state of the disease. Reportage of the event quickly produced a politically correct, Islam-free version of the murders: The perpetrators were “bombers,” not “terrorists.” That they were Muslims who had been recruited at a British- and EU-government-funded Islamic youth center known for its radical politics was glossed over.

In the official account, the real victims were British Muslims, who were certain to suffer an increase in “Islamophobia” from ignorant Britons who would naturally conclude from the attack that all Muslims are evil. The deputy assistant commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, Brian Paddick, tried to head off public mistrust of Muslims by saying, “Islam and terrorists are two words that do not go together.” The Nottinghamshire chief constable made it his top priority to deal with the problem—not by clamping down on extremism, but by pacifying the Muslim community with gestures such as ordering 20,000 green ribbons for all public officials to wear in a show of solidarity with Muslims. (Joel Hilliker, "The Sickness in Britain's Heart", The Philadelphia Trumpet, November-December 2006, p. 18.)
Here is Joel Hilliker once again referring to the July 7, 2005 terrorist bombings in London and condemning attempts by British leaders to minimize social strife.
The rush to exhibit such multicultural sanctimony has become so predictable after such incidents. The more that Muslims attack, the louder we praise them. The same Upside-Down reaction was on parade five years ago, after Islamic suicide bombers killed 52 Londoners on their morning commute. British officials didn’t blame Islam—but Islamophobia. London’s mayor asserted that the true fault lay in “80 years of Western intervention into predominantly Arab lands because of the Western need for oil.”

Reality is screaming in their faces, and they are closing their eyes, plugging their ears, and saying “La la la la la.” (Joel Hilliker, "The Upside-Down World", The Philadelphia Trumpet, August 2010, p. 5.)
Here is another relevant quote which is adapted from a previous post regarding The Trumpet Weekly in 2012.
December 8 [2012]. "Arafat, still terrorizing Israel" (p. 4). In this bizarre little article PCG's writers portray the exhumation of Yasser Arafat's body to determine if he was poisoned as an act of terror against the State of Israel committed for sinister purposes.
Are authorities really trying to discover if he was assassinated, or is this just a stunt designed to stir up hatred toward Israel? Speculation that Arafat was assassinated has swirled for years, even though conclusive evidence has never been discovered. The results of the tests will not be known for another three to four months, but already, the Palestinians have indicated their intent to take those found responsible to the International Criminal Court. This indicates the investigation might just be part of a plan to take Israel before the International Criminal Court for Arafat’s death rather than a search for justice. The exhuming of Yasser Arafat is a stark reminder: Even from the grave, the former Palestinian leader is still bringing terror upon Israel.
Even I am shocked at this portrayal of events from PCG's writers.

To insinuate that a legal exhumation made to determine if murder had occurred is an act of terror makes words like terrorism practically meaningless.

PCG's writers always portray the Palestinians in the worst possible light. Even when discussing an exhumation to determine if a murder had occurred it is portrayed as an act of terrorism.
How worthless are the assurances of PCG's leaders that anti-Muslim bigotry is not a big deal.

Sunday, May 3, 2015

PCG's Reliance on WorldNetDaily: Part 2

Here is another example of PCG using uncritically using WorldNetDaily to inform their readers despite the bad reputation it has among many people. This quote is from Joel Hilliker mentioning a book published by WorldNetDaily's publishing arm. 
This is what makes the book White Girl Bleed a Lot, by award-winning author Colin Flaherty, such an astonishing read. It thoroughly documents what is nothing less than the modern rise of the race riot in America: dozens upon dozens of dozens of events with a clear racial component, many of them black-on-white or black-on-other-race assaults punctuated by blatantly racist hate speech. (Joel Hilliker, Ignoring the Race Riots Won’t Make Them Disappear, July 25, 2012.)
Is Hilliker right to trust this book? 
WorldNetDaily (WND) says it opposes racism in any form. That’s why the online publication has added a series of articles on “black mob violence” to its usual fare of antigovernment conspiracy theories, gay-bashing, anti-Muslim propaganda, and End Times prophecy.

The series, which began in mid-2012, is penned exclusively for WND by one Colin Flaherty, who according to an editor’s note posted at the top of his pieces, “has done more reporting than any other journalist on what appears to be a nationwide trend of skyrocketing black-on-white crime, violence and abuse.” ...

Flaherty catalogues episodes of “black mob violence” with the obsessive care of a true connoisseur. Though he began by writing exclusively about black-on-white attacks, he has lately branched out into covering black-on-black violence, though he rarely bothers to note the race of the victim and always mentions that of the perpetrators.  (From Hatewatch, October 23, 2012.)
 Here is another critique of that book.
WND has continued to publish Flaherty's race-baiting articles, even as he places less emphasis on facts and more on keeping alive his dubious narrative that all blacks are mob-prone thugs. The fact that Flaherty completely ignores the fact that people of other races commit the very crimes he purports to be outraged about amply demonstrates this is all about race-baiting, not about the truth. (ConWebWatch, February 20, 2013.)
It would seem that Joel Hilliker's trust in this book is quite misplaced.

How sad it is to imagine that Joel Hilliker has propagated this book to his readers without checking up on what was said. Now others have read this information and may have become needlessly fearful of African Americans. This is very sad. How many African Americans will suffer because of such words?

PCG's Reliance on WorldNetDaily

Banned by HWA has released a post pointing out that many among the COGs happen to think that WorldNetDaily is a "news" source worth listening to.

As shall be seen here PCG's leaders also trust WorldNetDaily as a "news" source and quote it in their articles with no trace of suspicious that WorldNetDaily. Taking their words at face value it may be seen PCG's leaders uncritically treat it as a source worth quoting. No matter what they say it is treated as obviously true. PCG's leaders never say that anything WorldNetDaily says just might be wrong or slanted in some way.

It must be stated that WorldNetDaily has a terrible reputation. 
Big news this week from WorldNetDaily, America's pre-eminent source of far-right fringe theories and weird scams: about half of America would like to see Obama impeached, including a lot of Democrats. (Jason Linkus, "Half Of America Wants To Impeach Obama, According To Impeachable Polling Outfit", Huffington Post, May 21, 2013.)
PCG's leaders trust WorldNetDaily.

Below is a collection of quotes which show PCG's leaders, including Gerald Flurry, Stephen Flurry, Joel Hilliker, Robert Morley and the late Ron Fraser, uncritically take the various sensationalistic claims and stories of WorldNetDaily at face value. There is no attempt to correct them. Whatever WorldNetDaily says is presented by PCG's leaders as uncontested facts.

***

Panamanian presidential candidate William Bright Marine, writing to the Justice Department on May 4, stated, “I have yet to speak to one single American who is not outraged at the fact that the Clinton administration has allowed Communist China to obtain control of U.S. ports, U.S. bases, and functions of the Panama Canal. They, today, effectively control access to the Panama Canal.… This agreement could not have happened, without the consent of the Clinton administration” (WorldNet Daily, May 25, 1998). ...

With a view to the strategic importance of the Canal, Admiral Moorer stated, “The Canal is the only viable way to transport oil to the East Coast and Gulf of Mexico from the West” (WorldNet Daily, Oct. 19, 1998). (Ron Fraser, “The Gate of His Enemies…”, February 1999.)

The U.S. government certainly seems to think so. Like many other institutions, most government agencies are making no commitment to reaching “Y2K compliancy” by 2000. “The Defense Department [for one] is reported to be far behind in preparations for Y2K compliancy. It is working only on mission-critical systems…” (WorldNet Daily, Jan. 6). (Gearing for Martial Law, February 1999.)

It is reported that last summer, in a closed session with the Senate Foreign Relations committee, Admiral Thomas H. Moorer, USN (Ret.), former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, warned of grave security risks brought on by the Chinese takeover of the Panama Canal. The admiral declared, “I’m an old sailor now, but I know trouble when I see it…trouble that could evolve quickly into a conflict in our own hemisphere with worldwide implications.… I speak of the transfer of the Panama Canal to the Panamanian government under the circumstances which now exist. There’s far more going on there than meets the eye” (WorldNet Daily, Oct. 19, 1998). (Gerald Flurry, The Rise and Fall of a Superpower, January 2000.)

Author Peter Hitchens stated recently, “They think the history of Britain, rather than being an honorable story of democracy and liberty and civilization, is actually a catalog of squalor, depression and misdeeds. Because that is what they have been told. They have been brought up by their educators and most of the broadcasting systems to despise their country” (WorldNetDaily, Jan. 21; emphasis mine). (Ron Fraser, The Denial of History, February 2001.)

Is Israel ready for war? Some analysts claim that “the chances are high for a major military explosion in the Middle East” (www.worldnetdaily.com, Aug. 1). (Turning Up the Heat?, September-October 2001.)

In the Al Arabiya story, a spokesman for the group, Mohammad Ali Samedi, said that “since the movement’s beginning a year and a half ago, he has been busy signing up recruits, organizing conventions and training members for martyrdom operations” (World Net Daily, July 7). (Iran’s 40,000 Human Bombs, August 8, 2005.)

Indeed, it could be said that a generation in Britain is being lost to Europe by the willful destruction of national history, thanks in large part to its educators. “They think the history of Britain, rather than being an honorable story of democracy and liberty and civilization, is actually a catalogue of squalor, depression and misdeeds. … They have been brought up by their educators …” (WorldNetDaily, Jan. 21, 2001). (British Soften History to Appease Germany, January 2006.)

According to WorldNetDaily, Hosni Mubarak’s government has thwarted a potential coup, in the planning stages, by terrorist conspirators from the Muslim Brotherhood. The report says Egypt arrested a leader of the Muslim Brotherhood who confessed to the plot during an interrogation session with authorities. (Egypt Stops Coup Plot on Mubarak, August 15, 2006.)

In an interview with WorldNetDaily, a chief rocket coordinator for the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades in Judea and Samaria [the West Bank], named Abu Oudai, claimed major Israeli cities and the country’s international airport would eventually become Palestinian rocket targets, particularly following Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s planned withdrawal from most of Judea and Samaria [the West Bank], which borders Israel’s main population centers. … (Will Rocket Attacks Expand to West Bank?, July 13, 2006.)

Egyptian security officials are also reportedly expressing concern that Palestinian terrorists are moving south to plan attacks on Egyptian targets. ... One Egyptian official told World Net Daily, “If Palestinians from Gaza succeed in carrying out an attack against Egypt, it will be a turning point in Palestinian terrorism.” (Joel Hilliker, Sinai Becoming Terrorist Haven, September 19, 2006.)

Aaron Klein from WorldNetDaily.com wrote, .... (Hezbollah Uses Palestinian Camps to Stash Weapons, October 2, 2006.)

Two publications have printed articles about the discovery of Nehemiah’s wall in Jerusalem since theTrumpet.com first reported the news three weeks ago. On November 11, in an article titled, “Archaeologist uncovers Scriptures’ famed wall,” WorldNetDaily quoted and linked to theTrumpet.com: ... (Stephen Flurry, Jerusalem Post: “Nehemiah’s Wall Uncovered”, November 29, 2007.)

The Human Rights Council is also investigating the Alberta-based Christian Heritage Party of Canada and its leader Ron Gray, after a homosexual activist claimed material on the website was offensive to homosexuals. The main article in question was reprinted from WorldNetDaily .... . (Robert Morley, Canada’s War on the Bible and Free Speech, January 1, 2008.)

According to World Net Daily, “The stock market’s continued weakness reflects an increasing likelihood that the mortgage crisis has not yet bottomed out, with the unfortunate result that more losses from Collateralized Mortgage Obligations in bank asset portfolios are yet likely to be realized.”  (Stephen Flurry, The Weekend Web, March 2, 2008.)

If sharia law coming to America doesn’t shock you, it is probably because you are unfamiliar with its full ramifications. Here are some of its more controversial aspects, as reported by WorldNetDaily: ... (Robert Morley, Sharia Finance: Last Gasp of a Doomed American Economy, November 11, 2008.)

According to most press reports, the murder was just a wage dispute gone wrong. But the fact that [such and such happened] ... suggests that it was anything but a simple murder (World Net Daily, April 9). (Robert Morley, Kill the Boer and Bring Me My Machine Gun, April 13, 2010.) 

Matt Hissey says when he manned GOProud’s CPAC booth, he was thanked by a stream of participants for coming and “for driving the wingnuts away.” Barron criticized a prominent Republican attorney for her role in the boycott by branding her “a nasty bigot.” He called boycotting Republicans “losers” and sneered, “They’re all excited that Jim DeMint is boycotting. And that’s fantastic. I’m glad that he’s willing to be on the Island of Political Misfit Toys with [World Net Daily’s Joseph] Farah and the Concerned Women for America.” (Joel Hilliker, Amazing What Passes for ‘Conservative’ These Days, February 16, 2011.)

So far this year, nine generals and flag officers have been terminated by the Obama administration. World Net Daily calls this an “extraordinary number.” The site reports that over the past five years, close to 200 high-ranking officers have been fired—some under very suspicious circumstances. (Robert Morley, Is President Obama Purging the Military of Dissenters?, November 6, 2013.)

Since then, President Obama has terminated close to 200 high-ranking military officers. This year alone, nine generals and flag officers have been fired or have been pressured to resign. World Net Daily calls this purge of top military brass an “extraordinary number.” This amounts to a major eradication of the leadership of the U.S. military. (Worldwatch, January 2014.)

***

It is concerning to see PCG's leaders taken such a source as though it were gospel. No good can come from this.

People deserve to know that PCG uses WorldNetDaily in this way.

Friday, May 1, 2015

PCG's Rigid View of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

PCG has a very simplistic view of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Regardless of what happens on the ground within the Holy Land PCG's articles can be reliably trusted to tell the same story line PCG's leaders have adopted since 1996 at least.

PCG's Storyline of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

What stands out about PCG's rigid stance is how utterly incurious they are about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. They do not challenge themselves to see if events contradict their story line. No matter what happens they "know" what is really happening. Any events that occur are simply reinterpreted to adhere to their predetermined story line. 

Every article of theirs discusses some immediate topic and often quotes some recent news articles but they are just window dressing for PCG's writers to repeat the same story line they have been saying since at least 1996.

PCG's story line on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict goes something like this. (The following is my paraphrase of PCG's story.)
Israel is good. The Palestinians are bad. They are terrorists. They are influenced by Iran
The peace process is not a sincere attempt by the Palestinians to make peace but a sinister attempt by the Palestinians destroy the State of Israel using non-violent means. It constitutes the State of Israel's "deadly wound". 
Any attempt by the State of Israel to sincerely negotiate with, or give concessions to, the Palestinians is extremely foolish and is bound to fail miserably and is stridently condemned by PCG's leaders as not only foolish but even blasphemous. 
Israel and America are fated to break their alliance. This is referred to as "breaking the brotherhood". 
The Israelis are fated to foolishly enter an alliance with a German led Europe only to be betrayed and conquered by the Catholic European superpower and taken as slaves into continental Europe along with the Americans.
All Israelis and Americans enslaved by the European superpower will be liberated and restored to their former estate after Christ returns. (My summary of PCG's story line of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.)
PCG's story line regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was set in Gerald Flurry's 1996 booklet, Hosea and God's Adulterous Wife, and Gerald Flurry's 2001 booklet, Jerusalem in Prophecy.

PCG Repeating Themselves: Part 1

One example of PCG's rigid view of the conflict may be seen in what Gerald Flurry wrote in the original 1996 Hosea booklet. (Note: These words are not in the current version of this booklet.)
Europe is becoming a real powerhouse. French President Jacques Chirac has publicly called for a Palestinian state. The Palestinians were delighted. They gave him a hero’s welcome on a visit to the Middle East in late 1996. The Israelis were deeply hurt. After giving away so much of their land, powerful foreigners pressure them to go beyond their own very generous goals of land for peace.  
France and Europe know that such a public maneuver will gain them favor with the terrorists and with the Arabs from whom they get almost 100 percent of their oil. They are willing to sacrifice Judah to achieve their goals. Much more is happening here than the public could even imagine!  
In speaking before the Palestinians, Mr. Chirac stated that Palestinian statehood “is not in any way a danger to the security of anyone. On the contrary, a Palestinian state and comprehensive and just peace guarantees security for all.”  
That is easy for him to say. But it is treacherous to the Jews. They have to live in a sea of Arab enemies. And these statements make it a lot more dangerous—for Palestine! ... 
Germany no doubt endorsed Mr. Chirac’s explosive views. The Germans are the real power behind Europe. (Gerald Flurry, Hosea and God's Adulterous Wife, 1996 version, pp. 28-9.)
Five years later this anecdote is repeated in Joel Hilliker's August 2001 article, "The Counterfeit Peacemaker". At one point this article refers to what Gerald Flurry wrote in the 1996 version of Hosea and God's Adulterous Wife.
Arafat has found particularly favorable reception in Europe. On the whole, Europe, in assigning blame for Mideast problems, habitually points to Israel. 
In 1996, French President Jacques Chirac became the first head of state to speak to the Palestinian legislative council. He was loudly cheered for “treating the Palestinians to a rare feast of support and succor,” according to the New York Times. In his speech he called for Israel to concede all of the Palestinians’ main demands. (Joel Hilliker, "The Counterfeit Peacemaker", August 2001.)
Even though Hilliker's article was printed five years after President Chirac's speech he still cites it in blatant imitation of Gerald Flurry's 1996 article and booklet. Hilliker gives no acknowledgement of the fact that he is repeating what Flurry said five years earlier. A reader would not know he is repeating Flurry's words here. Although as we shall see later Hilliker does quote Flurry later on in this 2001 article.

Three years later Hilliker cites the same story three years later in 2004. This is eight years after this story was first cited in 1996.
Having this Bible-based understanding has given the Trumpet a clear-eyed view of the situation for many years. Editor in Chief Gerald Flurry wrote back in December 1996, after a pro-Palestinian speech by French President Jacques Chirac ... (Joel Hilliker, "The Enemies of Jerusalem", March-April 2004.)
 So we see that PCG likes to parrot the same lines again and again about this most serious conflict.

PCG Repeating Themselves: Part 2

We now turn back to Gerald Flurry's 1996 booklet, Hosea and God's Adulterous Wife. In that booklet Gerald Flurry also says the following.
Mr. Chirac DEMANDS that the Jews give the Arabs even more than liberal American leadership does! So this is not just a serious slap at Israel. IT'S ALSO A STRONG MOVE AGAINST THE ISRAEL-AMERICAN AXIS. IT'S ALSO A POWER MOVE TO TAKE OVER THE PEACE PROCESS FOR EUROPE'S GREAT BENEFIT. The European Union is moving to be the heavyweight in the Middle East.      
Europe is moving not only to be a co-sponsor in the peace process--they want to gain control of it! And they are also investing many millions of dollars to do so! (Gerald Flurry, Hosea and God's Adulterous Wife, 1996 version, p. 30.)
Note the confusing way Flurry describes the situation. He labels Israeli Jews as simply "the Jews". In fact most Jews are not in the State of Israel at all. Such talk is confusing.

Flurry talks of "the Arabs". This obscure the fact that the current conflict is mainly between the State of Israel and the Palestinians. It seems as though Flurry cannot see that there is a difference between the Palestinians and the other Arabs. Such talk is confusing.

Also why on Earth does Flurry talk of a "ISRAEL-AMERICAN AXIS"? Why is he not embarrassed to use a term that is associated with the infamous Axis that America and many other countries heroically fought against in World War II?

Furthermore in Hilliker's article he quotes Gerald Flurry at length. The words he quote appear on page 30 of Flurry's 1996 booklet but Hilliker appears to be quoting from The Philadelphia Trumpet article that booklet was based on as the first quoted sentence in the booklet is "So this is not just a serious slap at Israel."
Here are the prophetic words Trumpet Editor in Chief Gerald Flurry wrote in response to Chirac’s 1996 speech: “This is not just a serious slap at Israel. It’s also a strong move against the Israel-American axis. It’s a power move to take over the peace process for Europe’s great benefit. The European Union is moving to be the heavyweight in the Middle East. 
“Europe is moving not only to be a co-sponsor in the peace process—they want to gain control of it!” 
As time progresses, we are watching as these profound and revelatory words are proved true! (Joel Hilliker, "The Counterfeit Peacemaker", August 2001.)
It would seem that Hilliker is not embarrassed to talk of an "Israel-American axis" either.

Three years later Hilliker cites the same story three years later in 2004. This is eight years after this story was first cited in 1996.
The fact—supported by history, current events and biblical prophecy—is that EUROPE WANTS TO CONTROL JERUSALEM. 
Having this Bible-based understanding has given the Trumpet a clear-eyed view of the situation for many years. Editor in Chief Gerald Flurry wrote back in December 1996, after a pro-Palestinian speech by French President Jacques Chirac, “[T]his is not just a serious slap at Israel. IT’S ALSO A STRONG MOVE AGAINST THE ISRAEL-AMERICAN AXIS. IT’S A POWER MOVE TO TAKE OVER THE PEACE PROCESS FOR EUROPE’S GREAT BENEFIT—at the expense of the U.S. and the Jews. The European Union is moving to be the heavyweight in the Middle East. 
“Europe is moving not only to be a co-sponsor in the peace process—they want to take control of it!” 
Already they are positioning themselves to do just that. Europe would like nothing more than to implement the “solution” to the present conflict. But that “solution” will result in the demise of the Jewish state! (Joel Hilliker, "The Enemies of Jerusalem", March-April 2004.)
Eleven years later PCG's writers continue to promote the same story line without fail. Accusing America of plotting to betray the State of Israel and other such things.

PCG's leaders are just repeating the same storyline. It does not matter if the situation itself changes PCG's leaders can be relied on the say the same things. This is not a sign of having special knowledge. It is a sign that they do not know what is happening at all. They merely sell their dogmatic storyline.

PCG Blinded by Dogma

Are they not curious about the situation? Do they never for a moment wonder if they just might be missing something? Notice what one of PCG's writers alluded to in an article in 2005.
With more than a quarter of the population [of Palestinians] unemployed and half of all Palestinians living below the poverty line, Abbas has been seen as ineffective. (Timothy Oostendarp, "Hamas Waxes Stronger; Israel Will Pay The Price", December 20, 2005.)
It is astounding that PCG's writers never seem to ask themselves if such widespread poverty among the Palestinians, a fact even they themselves admit despite themselves, is a reason why relations are so tense within the Holy Land between Israelis and Palestinians. It is astounding that PCG's writers seem unable to even wonder if there just might a connection.

Do PCG's leaders ever stop to ask why they condemn and vilify a people that they themselves admit endure widespread unemployment and are often impoverished?

Also many Palestinians happen to be Christians. They rarely admit this fact.

It seems as though PCG's writers have never questioned if their preconceived stance regarding this conflict is correct.

The reason they do not notice such things is because they have already decided that they "know" what is "really" going on. Any information will happens to contradict their dogmatic stance is simply ignored and they "find" exactly what they expected to find. Any contrary information is carefully ignored. Consequently PCG is useless in understanding what is actually happening in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

The purpose of this post is not to tell people how to view that painful and tragic conflict but to point out how simplistic and rigid PCG's stance on this issue is.

So it may be seen that PCG's writers are useless at explaining what is happening within the Holy Land or in describing the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Whether you support the Israelis or the Palestinians or try to be neutral PCG's rigid story about it is useless in understanding what is happening in the Holy Land.

David Privratzky's Article for PCG

Last year we in the COG blogosphere were all saddened to learn of the death by suicide of Janet De Gennaro, a PCG member in Chicago who originated from Canada.

It was revealed that she had been ordered to have no contact with her family and this caused a lot of discussion regarding Gerald Flurry's draconian no contact policy enforced upon ex-members and "Laodiceans". (In PCG's jargon "Laodicean" refers to the members of any other COG group besides PCG.) This monstrous policy has been in force since 2000.

Her husband was one David Privratzky. Her father later  that they were never legally married.

David Privratzky is clearly still within PCG. In fact on March 27, 2015, PCG's website posted an article by him.

His article briefly describes some social outing of PCG members in Chicago. 
Forty-six members of the Chicago congregation gathered at Wood Dale Lanes bowling alley for a 10-pin bowling social and pizza party on the night of January 31.
So it is clear that he is still in PCG's good graces. This terrible event might have stained his relations with PCG's leaders but they seem to have decided to keep him on their good books. They even entrusted him to write an article of this sort.

For anyone who wants to read more about this serious topic of suicide I would suggest the following:

Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Reading PCG's Article, The Mark of the Beast



Back in the January 1995 issue of PCG's recruitment magazine, The Philadelphia Trumpet, Stephen Flurry wrote an article entitled "The Mark of the Beast". It restates HWA's dogma that worshiping on Sunday in the Mark of the Beast. It is available as a reprint article. You can read this article on their website.

Let us see what Stephen Flurry has to say.
Some assume the mark is something people should definitely have since it will enable you to buy and sell; and after all, everyone wants to buy and sell, right? (p. 1.)
Who is Stephen Flurry talking about? The mark of the Beast is always portrayed as a bad thing. This is a straw man argument. This is no such argument.
Mr. Armstrong warned for many decades of the final resurrection of the Roman Empire. After World War II, he boldly proclaimed that Germany would rise again and lead a group of 10 united nations in Europe. For this to be accomplished, communism had to crumble in Eastern Europe. Mr. Armstrong also predicted this. And that is exactly what has happened! Communism has fallen in Eastern Europe and now a group of nations is very quickly pulling together to form a powerful combine economically and militarily. (p. 2.)
This is wrong. It is often asserted that the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 proved that HWA was right and he really did see the future.

This of course is nonsense. Herbert W. Armstrong said that Christ would return within twenty years in his book Mystery of the Ages. (PCG has since deleted those words so someone in there knows HWA spoke nonsense.) How convenient for them to forget this.

Also Herbert W. Armstrong never said the Soviet Union would collapse. He thought it would survive intact until a few years after Christ's return. It shows how biased some many in the COGs are that they so often omit this pertinent detail. This inconvenient truth is just tossed into the memory hole.

It is true that HWA said that some Eastern European states would break away from Moscow's orbit and join the European Empire he said would arise at any moment. But he never talked of the Soviet Union collapsing. He did not teach that. Also he portrayed the rise of the European Empire to be far quicker then what has actually happened. In Mystery of the Ages Christ was supposed to return by 2005 at the most.

So assertions that the fall of the Berlin Wall somehow prove that HWA was right is just complete nonsense spread by people who, for whatever reason, are still in denial that HWA was a false prophet who merely talked out of his own "human reasoning".

We now continue with Stephen Flurry's article.
Those familiar with Mr. Armstrong’s writings, many of which were written in the 1950s and 1960s, know he prophesied of these events! Mr. Armstrong was preaching it at a time when it looked impossible. And now it is happening—precisely as he said. We need to know WHY! (p. 2.)
It is because you want to believe that HWA was right.
The Roman Empire is the greatest war-making power this world has ever known. That proves this beast is not a great religious organization as some people believe. It refers to a great war-making nation. Verses 5-7 show that this evil beast will 1) speak great things, and 2) make war with the saints, or God’s people. (p. 2.)
The "great religious organization" Stephen Flurry here alludes to is the Roman Catholic Church.

Stephen Flurry then cites some obscure book printed in 1836 entitled History of Roman Catholicism. It was published by a publishing firm named S.L. Holbrook. Back then mutual hostility between Protestants and Catholics were far more widespread than is the case today.
Here is a quote from a book titled The History of Roman Catholicism (1836, page 524): ... (p. 4.)
It appears the book is entitled History of Roman Catholicism, not The History of Roman Catholicism as Stephen Flurry here presents it. Such failure to attend to details is merely representative of more severe factual failings in this article.

Here is the full name of this 1836 book:
History of Roman Catholicism: From the Reign of Constantine the Great, A.D. 325, Down to the Present Time Exhibiting a Full and Impartial Detail of the Superstitutions, Corruptions, and Tyranny of the Papal Church
It appears as though this book was never reprinted after 1836. So right now it is only available at a cost of about $130. Why does Stephen Flurry choose to quote from such an obscure and inaccessible book? Wouldn't it be better to quote a book easily accessible to his readers?

Stephen Flurry then proceeds to repeat once again his father's doctrine that only PCG members are "Philadelphians" and all those in the other COG groups are "Laodiceans" doomed to be executed by the future European Empire.
A little more background is necessary at this point. The Bible reveals two groups of God’s people extant during the Great Tribulation (the time of Satan’s wrath upon the whole world). Revelation 12:14-17 show that one of these groups is protected during the Tribulation while the other group must experience it. Numerous pieces of Philadelphia Church of God literature prove these two groups to be the Philadelphia and Laodicean churches (Revelation 3:7-22). The Philadelphians are protected (verse 10) while the Laodiceans are punished in the Tribulation (verse 19).

The mark of the beast will be enforced during the Tribulation (Revelation 13:5; notice “forty and two months”—or 3 1/2 years). So those who are beheaded because they reject the mark are none other than the repentant Laodiceans who go into the Tribulation. They lose their lives physically, but will be resurrected to rule with Jesus Christ a thousand years. Revelation 15:1-4 give more details concerning the reward of those repentant Laodiceans who refuse the mark. (p. 3.)
It is often asserted that in the future the Laodiceans are fated to be executed by the European Empire for refusing to observe Sunday. The fear of being killed off in this way is an induced phobia which causes PCG members to be desperate to be sure that this will not happen to them. Consequently they do what PCG's ministers tell them to do because they think they will be executed by the future European Empire if they are out of PCG.
The little horn in [Daniel 7] verse 8 refers to a great religious organization that speaks great things.
He means the Roman Catholic Church. Armstrongites tend to be evasive about this when introducing this doctrine but HWA taught that the final Pope would be able to perform miracles such as summoning fire from the sky and use such miracles to bolster the rise of the future European Empire.

Then comes this fascinating passage. So Stephen Flurry is fulminating about the Catholic Church using the Roman Empire to change Saturday to Sunday. He then makes a statement which appears to be untrue.

Is the highlighted sentence below accurate?
Changing the official day of worship to Sunday was made by Constantine during the Nicean Council of A.D. 325. Here is what he said: “At this meeting the question concerning ... Easter was discussed. ... First of all, it appeared an unworthy thing that in the celebration of this ... feast we should follow the practice of the Jews. ... Let us then have nothing in common with the Jews . ... It has been determined by the common judgment of all, that the ... feast of Easter should be kept on one and the same day.”

In other words, Easter was to be kept on Sunday and the Passover, one of God’s seven annual festivals, was expressly forbidden! (p. 4.)
That severely edited passage was talking about Easter, not Sunday, as is obliquely admitted in the last section of the quote. It is not true that "Changing the official day of worship to Sunday was made by Constantine during the Nicean Council of A.D. 325". They were talking about Easter.

Actually the Council of Nicaea did not even talk about whether or not to worship on Sunday or Saturday at all. It was concerned with two issues: 1) To make a decision concerning the doctrine of Arianism which asserted that Jesus Christ was unworthy of worship and 2) to settle the date for Passover.

There were other decisions made as well but not whether to worship on Sunday or Saturday. That was not even an issue at the Council of Nicaea.

If you don't believe me just look at the canons of the Council of Nicaea for yourself. They do not even talk about whether or not to worship on Sunday or Saturday. That was not at issue in that Council.
Since it was Constantine who enforced Sunday observance in the Roman Empire, we should expect this 1,260-year tribulation period to begin when he made his decree in A.D. 325. And that is exactly what happened. With his decree, those saints who remained faithful to God’s Sabbath command were forced to flee into hiding for fear of their lives. Persecution against these people set in almost immediately. (p. 5.)
It is funny to note that no one seems to know anything about this except Stephen Flurry. If you look at the annals of church history during the fourth and fifth centuries AD there is no mention of any major persecution of Sabbatarian Christians. Because there was no such thing.

Also when did this period of persecution end? 1260 years after A.D. 325 is A.D. 1585. What happened then? This question is always conveniently ignored by those promoting this "church history" dogma. Herman Hoeh in his 1959 booklet, A True History of the True Church, never mentioned anything happening in 1585. And neither does Stephen Flurry. This is because nothing happened in 1585. This dogma is nonsense.
In Revelation 2:16, God warned them to either repent, or be faced with the sword. Most did not repent. So they had to suffer the sword, just as God said. According to A True History of the True Church, over 100,000 of them were martyred. The Pergamos era was virtually wiped out. (p. 5.)
Herman Hoeh just made that figure up. Hoeh cited no sources in making that emotive statement. Actually the Paulicians survived for centuries until around the time of the Byzantine Emperor Alexis in the early 1100s. And Alexis did not exterminate them. Rather it seems he was somehow able to engineer some sort of merger with the Orthodox Church.

One detail that is not mentioned by Stephen Flurry about Hoeh's booklet also details some of the false reasoning behind HWA and Hoeh's assertion that the Great Tribulation would begin in 1972 and that Christ would return in 1975
Here is a group which observed the Sabbath and rejected the pagan trinity belief! They were severely persecuted for what they believed. A crusade against these people was instituted in Southern France. Once again, many thousands were martyred.

Around the time of A.D. 1,000, it looked as though this era of God’s Church had come to an end. This is significant, because concerning the Thyatira era, God said the last works would be more than the first (Revelation 2:19). (pp. 5-6.)
Now this time Stephen Flurry is not making stuff up. This is clearly a reference to the anti-Albigensian crusade of 1207-1227. But for some strange reason Stephen Flurry does not even bother to note when this crusade occurred. The reason why will be seen very shortly.

Also the Albigensians were not like HWA's followers at all. Rather they believed that Satan was a God, not just a perverted Angel.The word Albigensian is not even mentioned in this article at all even though Stephen Flurry is clearly alluding to them.

He also gives the impression that this mythical Thyatira era seemed to reach its end by A.D. 1000 but only after alluding to the anti-Albigensian Crusade of 1207-1227.

This is very confusing. How on Earth is anyone unacquainted with this topic support to make any sense out of this?

Stephen Flurry then immediately continues with these words:
That is exactly what happened in history. The era was revived during the last half of the 12th century by a man named Peter Waldo. (p. 6.)
And Peter Waldo began preaching in the 1160s, at least forty years before the anti-Albigensian Crusade began.

Now we see why Stephen Flurry was being so confusing about the anti-Albigensian Crusade. He wants to portray this crusade as occurring before Peter Waldo when in fact Waldo started preaching decades before the anti-Albigensian Crusade began in 1207.

Stephen Furry wanted to portray the anti-Albigensian Crusade of 1207-1227 as occurring before the rise of Peter Waldo to make his story more exciting. It is to make Peter Waldo seem even more remarkable by making it seem as though he was reviving a movement that had been ravaged by a crusade. In fact Peter Waldo began to preach back in the 1160s long before the anti-Albigensian crusade began in 1207.
It was around this time that Pope Alexander III made this stunning decree at the Council of Tours in A.D. 1163: “Whereas a damnable heresy has for some time lifted its head in the parts about Toulouse, and already spread infection through Gascony and other provinces, concealing itself like a serpent in its folds; as soon as its followers shall have been discovered, let no man afford them refuge on his estates; neither let there be any communication with them in buying and selling: so that, being deprived of the solace of human conversation, they may be compelled to return from error to wisdom.” (p. 6.)
But Pope Alexander III was not talking about the Waldensians. He was talking about the Albigensians. These words are taken out of context and inaccurately presented as though it is about the Waldensians.

Why does Stephen Flurry say untrue things here? Could it be that his teaching is just simply wrong?

Of course the real problem with this "church history" dogma is that it is complete nonsense. Armstrongism has no link with the Paulicians or the Waldensians or the Albigensians. In actual fact Armstrongism is an offshoot of the Millerite Adventists of the 1830s-1840s. 
Sunday observance, as Mr. Armstrong thoroughly proved, is the mark of the beast that will be enforced in the near future. Most of the world has willingly accepted this mark for many centuries now. But God’s people still keep the Sabbath. And those saints who have become lukewarm in these last days will be tested on this very command! (p. 7.)
What country on Earth forcibly force people to worship on Sunday? Not the United States. These are just emotive words with no facts behind them.
Sunday, Satan’s mark, goes hand in hand with the popular customs and beliefs of this world: Christmas, Good Friday, Easter, etc. (p. 7.)
Total nonsense. Rather Stephen Flurry is trying to exploit the reader's new found disgust with worshiping on Sunday and use this strong feeling to get the reader to shun Christmas, Easter, birthdays and other mainstream holidays. The effect on these prohibitions is to make one socially isolated from mainstream society. A person in such a position suddenly finds that he can only socially and celebrate festivals only with the group, in this PCG. The purpose of banning Christmas, Easter and birthdays is to make such persons socially dependent on the group.
But Exodus 31:13 also says God sanctifies those who obey the Sabbath. Sanctify means “to set apart for a holy use or purpose.” Just try obeying God’s Sabbath command along with His annual holy days and see if it doesn’t set you apart in this world! It was for breaking the Sabbath that both Israel and Judah went into captivity, anciently (Ezekiel 20:5, 11-13, 17-21). (p. 7.)
When one observes these things he or she becomes set apart by doing those things, not because God made him or her special. That is just a delusion used to make people think that observing such things make them special in a way different from all humanity.

Incidentally this is very similar to what HWA wrote in his booklet, The United States and Britain in Prophecy. Is this plagiarism?
We have already seen how those who refuse the mark of the beast will be martyred. When we put the scriptures together it becomes clear: By holding on to God’s Sabbath commandment you are rejecting the mark of the beast, which is Sunday observance, and all of the pagan, worldly customs that go along with it. (p. 7.)
Normally the mark of the Beast is said to be Sunday observance but here Stephen Flurry exploits this idea to taint all these other mainstream holidays as forbidden by (PCG's) God.
But in verse 14, it says the woman is taken to a safe place. This occurs at the beginning of the Great Tribulation. The Philadelphians will be protected. (p. 8.)
This is a reason why PCG members stay within PCG despite the many problems within it. They are told that if they stay within PCG they will get to go to a place of safety and escape from the troubles of the Great Tribulation. But if they are out of PCG then they will be executed by the future European Empire.

Stephen Flurry ends his article with these words.
There is not much time left to prove where you stand with God. Are you accepting this mark of the beast today? Will you accept it in the Tribulation? Those who do, will be subject to the wrath of God. But for those who reject this evil mark, the greatest possible reward you could ever imagine awaits you! (p. 8.)
Twenty years later we are still waiting for the Great Tribulation to occur. People have had plenty of time to join PCG, see all the things wrong in it and leave PCG in all these twenty years.